2 ms·
Red Hat have a luxury Sun have denied themselves: breaking stuff between versions. Between major versions. RHEL4 is still supported, and will be for several m
by SwellJoe 18y ago
Red Hat have a luxury Sun have denied themselves: breaking stuff between versions.
Between major versions. RHEL4 is still supported, and will be for several more years, and never breaks compatibility. RHEL has a seven year security update cycle (and a five year full support life cycle). It's not Solaris style backwards compatibility, but it's more than long enough for any server I've ever managed. The average server life in the web services business is right at three years. That leaves four years of wiggle room.
Sun has occasional done major breaks in the past. Not as frequently as Red Hat, but I have dealt with issues in the past.
Do you know they won't support you if you upgrade RHEL4 to 5 in-place?
I actually didn't know that. I've done such upgrades numerous times (hundreds, at least) in the past and never had any problems. On the other hand, I've attempted Solaris upgrades in-place, and been damn near beaten to death by the machine in the process. I think I'd prefer to not have support and have it work, than to have support and need a helluva lot of it.
Solaris is not like it is because Sun doesn't know how to get new versions of their userland. Rather, they've chosen not to.
Yes, I know. That's why it's so damned frustrating. Sun has smart people working for them. They could be building a leading edge operating system, but they aren't. They're building an operating system that would have been embarrassing for a Linux distribution ten years ago. Package management has been a solved problem for years...and yet, Sun still ships a retarded bunch of crusty old pkg tools and they recently added a clunky GUI to sit on top of it so they can pretend they've improved their package manager. No matter how good a few pieces of the tech are, or how good backward compatibility is, if the user experience sucks, I'm not going to use it for the majority of my systems. And, right now, the user experience on Solaris sucks. Really, deeply, truly, and with enthusiasm, sucks. I figured Ian Murdock being on board would at least get package management fixed (since Debian was the first Linux distro to have reasonably modern package management in apt-get), but that hasn't happened.
I guess we'll see if OpenSolaris can solve these problems...but, we're, what, two or three years into the OpenSolaris experiment, and you still can't just download an installable CD for the damned thing. You have to run it in a VirtualBox, or jump through really complex hoops and be extremely selective about hardware.
Sorry, I actually jumped into the conversation to say nice things about Sun. But, you dragged me back through my years of dealing with Solaris boxes, and trying to support OpenSolaris and Solaris in our products, and it brought out Angry Joe.