4 ms·
Fair question. If you are an engineer or a startup person, its possible that you don't have insight into the dynamics of corporate BigCos. There is a lot of p
by 001sky 14y ago
Fair question. If you are an engineer or a startup person, its possible that you don't have insight into the dynamics of corporate BigCos. There is a lot of potential for under-the-radar turf wars. This creates potential conflicts of interest (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal%E2%80%93agent_problem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal%E2%80%93agent_problem). This is not every case, but this is a real problem. This leads to the ultimate circle-jerk scenario. "What's in it for the party that puts the cash on the table?" The answer is often the same - hiding failure. Where the agents collude to enrich themselves at the expense of their professional/fiduciary duties. Of course, "in reality" there is enough plausible deniability to let things run their course. There's no real business, so no one will know they overpaid (for 2-4years) The M&A bankers earn their fees, The M&A exec at Big-Co gets his promotion, etc. No harm no-foul, its "on the house". Heck, the VC and the CEO get to put "Exit" on their resume. But yeah. Not really.
Non-Acquihire datapoints:
BBC NEWS | Business | News Corp in $580m internet buy
News Corporation Sells MySpace for $35 Million -
Microsoft Wraps Up $6B aQuantive Buy
Microsoft Writing Down $6.2 Billion Over AQuantive Deal
In the "Aquihire" case, the prices are just lower. This may be hiding failure of the Purchaser to lead, innovate, or hire efficiently (HR/culture failure) or to execute on a product launch (internal team failure). Sometimes, its "better" to just patch over that with a "bolt-on", and pretend to protect the career of a "B" player at BigCo. Again, in an Aquihire there is no actual business (ie, measureable profits) so the valuation is just a game of wave a finger in the air. Because of the delayed/opaque consequnces (ie, the 2-4 year period before anyone figures it out), its more subject to manipulation than any normal (ie, cash-flow positive) transaction.
So, to summarize. Not every acquihire is bad/evil. Sometimes, its a good, fair deal for all. But, by its very nature, the acquihire "process" is opaque and subject to manipulation. Furhtermore, its riddled with potential conflicts of interest. For these reasons, one must not be Naive when thinking about these matters.