3 ms·
> folks here who were dragging the Internet Archive for controlled digital lending, just trying to be a digital library The problem with the Internet Archive w
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> folks here who were dragging the Internet Archive for controlled digital lending, just trying to be a digital library
The problem with the Internet Archive was it jumped into uncontrolled lending. Basically, there was no practical reason to buy a book that the Internet Archive would "lend" you. That simply isn't true for an LLM citing a book, which may still cause me to read it.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoDisclosure: No affiliation besides sending them financial support as well as physical collections. I am a supporter, to put it mildly, because we need libraries that cannot be burned. [section removed; refer to harshreality's context in sibling comment, which is more thorough than what I had commented] As a reasonable person who believes one should be reasonable until they can no longer be reasonable, as a hacker, this is a green light to be unreasonable as it relates to onerous copyright regulations infringing on the commons. Copyright stakeholders took too much from the commons, and this enables people to take back (with a combination of judicial review and technology). https://www.library.upenn.edu/news/hachette-v-internet-archive https://www.library.upenn.edu/news/hachette-v-internet-archi... https://blog.archive.org/tag/controlled-digital-lending/ https://blog.archive.org/tag/controlled-digital-lending/ https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=internet%20archive%20digital%20lending&sort=byDate&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> While there was a brief period during COVID where lending restrictions were removed from the lending system due to quarantines and shutdowns (and you could quite literally not get into some physical libraries) This is the moment their liability accelerated. It was stupid, impulsive and put--and may continue to put--the whole project at risk.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoWell, they made a bold move to protect what they believe in as a bona fide library [1], and while it was not successful, I am more than happy to see a bigger bully come along and even things out. Copyright holders aren't just going to allow fair use, or let profits go uncaptured, ya know? They're going to keep taking until there is nothing left and everything is locked behind a paywall for ~150 years [2] (life + 70 years). Edit (wrt your reply): Drop into a weekly lunch at the SF location and have a conversation on this. Additional context is always helpful, I find. [1] https://blog.librarylaw.com/librarylaw/2007/07/internet-archiv.html https://blog.librarylaw.com/librarylaw/2007/07/internet-arch... [2] https://www.copyright.gov/help/faq/faq-duration.html https://www.copyright.gov/help/faq/faq-duration.html
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Copyright holders aren't just going to allow fair use What they allow doesn't matter. Under controlled lending, the Archive was operating within precedent. I'm not against launching a test case for uncontrolled lending. But doing it with the entire library, irrespective of publication date or jurisdiction, and through the main organisation was just stupid.
- mistrial9 1y agopeople were in a panic under lockdown here in urban California, and elsewhere. The whole of the Internet Archive is experimental and out-of-the-box.. It is beyond unjust to watch corporate data hoarders profit at large while IA gets excoriated by fellow "smarty" people. IA is wonderful in their weird ways.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> beyond unjust to watch corporate data hoarders profit at large while IA gets excoriated by fellow "smarty" people. IA is wonderful in their weird ways I love the Archive. And as I said above, I'm not fundamentally against uncontrolled lending as a legal test case. But doing it with the entire catalogue, instead of just e.g. older books, and doing it out of the main organisation such that there is no legal segregation between the experiment and the entire project struck me as incredibly impulsive. They're wonderful and weird. But perhaps not the best steward of what's pitched as an archive.
- harshreality 1y agoDuring the initial COVID lockdown, IA implemented their National Emergency Library lending program, which is the only uncontrolled (not 1:1) lending of works known to be under copyright that I know of: 1. Almost all physical libraries, including at universities, had shut down, and IA's efforts were to compensate for that. Supply of previously-purchased-for-public-use books had dried up overnight. 2. Normal 1:1 lending was not observed, but DRM was still applied. No books lent during that period were usable outside of a narrow window, without the end user intentionally circumventing the DRM which is a distinct crime and isn't trivial for the average computer user. 3. IA entered into dialogue with major academic publishers before implementing the emergency library. They published an opt-out address on their blog. That wasn't as visible to all publishers or independent authors as it probably should have been, but everyone knows if it had been opt-in instead, authors and publishers all would have reflexively refused, despite the unique situation. Mainstream publishers and most authors simply do not care if people can't access library books for a month or two. They would ban libraries if they could. They're so high on their intellectual property rights they think those can't be relaxed no matter what. 4. As far as I know, all NEL books were scanned PDFs, from donated library book collections. Casual readers don't read scanned books for entertainment. The idea that this significantly displaced kindle purchases, for instance, or lending of real ebooks from local libraries, needs a citation. There's plenty of additional background here: https://blog.archive.org/national-emergency-library/ https://blog.archive.org/national-emergency-library/