4 ms·
> What resources are on asteroids that justify the energy expenditure to get from space and back? With chemical rockets, not much. With "a propellant-less pro
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> What resources are on asteroids that justify the energy expenditure to get from space and back?
With chemical rockets, not much.
With "a propellant-less propulsion propulsion system such as solar sails or electric sails," bringing water (propellant) to low-earth orbit starts making sense [1], as does mining platinum, but only if "the quantity of platinum from space would substitute an equal quantity of terrestrial platinum," i.e. moving heavy industry off the Earth's surface [1].
Given asteroid-mining profitability is dominated by "the throughput rate, which depends on the mining process," it's possibly to see a path to certain rare-earth minerals becoming profitable to mine in space if environmental controls on Earth are tightened while constant-thrust propulsion technologies advance.
[1] https://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.03836 https://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.03836
- sorcerer-mar 1y agoJust skimmed but does this answer the question of getting to and from the surface of earth? Or are we just stockpiling platinum in LEO for some reason?
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> does this answer the question of getting to and from the surface of earth? Yes. (Deöbiting from LEO is cheap, like 90 m/s for the Space Shuttle, because you can use the atmosphere.)
- sorcerer-mar 1y ago… Presumably the problem is mostly getting up…? Is the plan to just drop hunks of platinum or do we need to put reentry vehicles up there?
- randallsquared 1y agoWith a relatively small initial investment, you can build reentry vehicles out of the asteroid, depending on the specific composition.
- pfdietz 1y agoOr, just fashion the metal into ingots that are coated with an ablator (carbon, say) and allow them to enter as artificial meteorites. Suitably sized they will hit the ground at reasonable speed and can be dug up.
- Teever 1y agoEven better than carbon use an ablative made out of olivine that can sequester CO2 as it ablates. That way by offloading mining and refining into space to prevent the damage that these activities incur on earth you're also undoing damage to Earth from past human activities.
- pfdietz 1y ago> With chemical rockets, not much. The energy involved in chemical rocketry is actually not that much. Getting a kilogram to LEO is roughly as expensive (in energy) as flying it to the other side of the world in an airliner. Getting stuff back from an earth-crossing asteroid can also be very cheap energetically, with very small delta-V (if one is willing to wait long enough).
- sorcerer-mar 1y agoBut we don’t ship mined materials around via aircraft… because it’s obscenely expensive…
- pfdietz 1y agoAnd the delta-V back from a NEO is as little as 1% of that to get to LEO from the Earth's surface. Also, the materials we're talking about from asteroid mining, like platinum group elements, probably are shipped by air, just for security. This whole argument is reminding me of the facile and bogus argument that launch to earth orbit from planet's surface is expensive because of the energy needed.
- sorcerer-mar 1y agoIf it's a bogus argument then mount a counterargument. The question is simple: what is worth mining in space? So far we have... "maybe platinum." Maybe! Aside from the conspicuous absence of math, "maybe platinum" isn't remotely important enough a factor in earthbound mining to justify asteroid mining on the basis of preserving earth, obviously.
- pfdietz 1y agoLook at those goalposts shift! I don't need to argue things are practically mineable in space to rebut the point. I just need to argue if they aren't practically mineable, energy consumption isn't a reason. I have already given you the counterargument. > we have maybe platinum Those making the energy argument need to rebut every possibility. The "it takes to much energy to ship back" is ludicrously wrong for platinum. The argument destroyed, why would we need to say more? It takes as little as 0.1 km/s delta V to get onto an Earth-intersecting orbit from known NEOs. The energy of a mass moving at 100 m/s is 5x10^3 J/kg, or 1.4e-3 kWh. If a kWh costs $1 in space, this would be a fraction of a cent per kilogram. This delta-V is so small that the energy cost of sending back base metals would be affordable. Hell, the energy cost of shipping gravel from space would be affordable! Other costs, probably not, but that's not the claim we're addressing.