3 ms·
Modern food can be so fantastically calorically dense that it's depressing to sit down (ha!) and compare food taken in versus the amount of exercise one can rea
by jacques_chester 14y ago
Modern food can be so fantastically calorically dense that it's depressing to sit down (ha!) and compare food taken in versus the amount of exercise one can reasonably perform. Anybody who has ever done so will have immediately realised how much pedalling a slice of pizza or a donut can be equal.
You may have heard that "abs are made in the kitchen", or "you can't outrun the fork". And this just shows that it's true even for very physically active people.
I train in Olympic-style Weightlifting, probably one of the more demanding physical activities. Elite international-level athletes in Weightlifting can be visually categorised into two groups: superheavyweights and everybody else.
Why? Because superheavies don't need to make a weight class, there is no incentive to strip down fat. So they eat heavily to support maximal hypertrophy and training intensity.
Whereas weightlifters trying to squeeze in at the top of a weight division will often have very low bodyfat. How is this achieved? Through a tightly controlled diet.
We are talking about athletes who in all other respects train the same way. A Chinese superheavy trains the same way as a Chinese welterweight. A Bulgarian superheavy, same as a Bulgarian heavy. And so on. Literally every day, racking from hundreds to thousands of calories of exercise. But they eat differently.
And the results speak for themselves.
- litmus 14y ago>>>>"Of course, if we push our bodies hard enough, we can increase our energy expenditure, at least in the short term. But our bodies are complex, dynamic machines, shaped over millions of years of evolution in environments where resources were usually limited; our bodies adapt to our daily routines and find ways to keep overall energy expenditure in check." And yet how do we get from a modern man spending most of time sitting down spending the same energy as a Hadza walking ~100 miles a week to a modern Olympian swimmer supposedly spending 12,000 a day and maintaining 8-10% body fat while swimming 50 miles a week? Does 10+ years qualifiy as 'short term'? http://www.michaelphelps.net/michael-phelps-diet/ http://www.michaelphelps.net/michael-phelps-diet/
- jacques_chester 14y agoI think that the NYT article was poorly written. It's hard to tell what was meant by controlling for differences. For example, fat people have a higher BMR, simply because they are larger. Tall people have a higher BMR, because they are larger. And so on. The "Phelps diet" is a bit of a media beatup, apparently. Not that it matters, Phelps could still get fat if he wanted to. Elvis is estimated to have been eating more calories than that in the year before his death.