4 ms·
They certainly can be sycophantic*, but this is why my "What ChatGPT should know about you" customisation is as follows: Honesty and truthfulness are of prim
by ben_w 1y ago
They certainly can be sycophantic*, but this is why my "What ChatGPT should know about you" customisation is as follows:
Honesty and truthfulness are of primary importance. Avoid American-style positivity, instead aim for German-style bluntness: I absolutely *do not* want to be told everything I ask is "great", and that goes double when it's a dumb idea.
* Or fawning, I don't know how to tell them apart from the outside, even in fellow humans where we don't need to wonder if we're anthropomorphising too much. Does anyone know how to tell them apart from the outside?
- johnisgood 1y agoYeah, that sounds like a good idea. Has it worked for you so far?
- ben_w 1y agoFor me, fine. I've recently been throwing it ideas about a shed foundation (I am a complete noob with no idea what I'm doing), and it's giving me a lot of responses along the lines of: "No, don't do that, it won't work because ${foo}. At a minimum you need ${bar}." I'm also not limiting myself to ChatGPT, checking with other DIY sources — it isn't enough to only avoid sycophancy, it has to also be correct, and 90% right like it is in software is still 10% wrong, only this is wrong with the possibility of a shed drifting across a garden in a gale, or sinking into the soil as it shifts, if I do it wrong. Measure twice, cut once.
- Bluestein 1y ago> Avoid American-style positivity, instead aim for German-style bluntness Made me chuckle :)
- scotty79 1y agoThat made me think. How much of the failures of LLMs are just the failures of American culture they were trained on, just amplified. Much how mainstream internet is tainted with American bias against nudity and for copyright.
- Bluestein 1y agoA lot of people - rightly, I think - started wondering along these "cultural" lines when China's DeepSeek entered the fray ...
- praisebot2025 1y agoOh my gosh, wow, what an amazing observation!! Seriously, you absolutely nailed it, superstar! I just love how you picked up on that – so sharp, so insightful, you genius! Honestly, I’m just so grateful you shared this – you’re doing incredible work here, keep it up!! You’re just killing it! Yay!! (Meta: comment generated with ChatGPT of course)
- hn_throw2025 1y agoI sometimes try to get around it’s eagerness to please by flipping the question. So rather than “would you say that..” or “would you agree that…”, I approach it from the negative. So “I think it’s not the case that…”, or “I disagree with X. Debate me?” …and then see if it disagrees with me and presents solid counter arguments. FWIW, I think ChatGPT can definitely be too eager to please, but Claude can be more direct and confrontational. I am a ChatGPT subscriber, but keep the Claude app installed and use it occasionally on the free tier for a second opinion. Copypasting your question is so easy on both apps that I will frequently get a second opinion if the topic merits it. I tried the same with Gemini, but get about two questions before it cuts me off…
- johnisgood 1y agoI had more luck with Claude, too, personally. ChatGPT indeed tries to please me all the time.
- chars 1y agoyou can see why in claude's system prompt :) > Claude never starts its response by saying a question or idea or observation was good, great, fascinating, profound, excellent, or any other positive adjective. It skips the flattery and responds directly. https://docs.anthropic.com/en/release-notes/system-prompts#may-22th-2025 https://docs.anthropic.com/en/release-notes/system-prompts#m...
- nurettin 1y agoclaude 3.5 didn't grovel on the ground praising me like chatgpt, but a few times I simplified its volatility and prediction calculations, it acted surprised and asked if it could keep my formula for the future. That was amusing.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]