5 ms·
School of Hard Knocks: ‘How Children Succeed,’ by Paul Tough
- taskstrike 14y agoNothing in the world can take the place of Persistence. Talent will not; nothing is more common than unsuccessful men with talent. Genius will not; unrewarded genius is almost a proverb. Education will not; the world is full of educated derelicts. Persistence and determination alone are omnipotent. The slogan 'Press On' has solved and always will solve the problems of the human race. -Calvin Coolidge
- tikhonj 14y agoI know too many people who work too hard but accomplish too little to believe that. Sure, some persistence may be necessary but it is by no means sufficient! Put another way, I'm sure as many determined people fail as talented, intelligent or educated ones do.
- chernevik 14y agoPersistence often fails, even among smart people, because people don't know how to work productively. They think because they work hard, and are smart, they deserve some particular outcome. They aren't try to produce, they are trying to earn a result. It isn't until people focus on trying to produce and create things of value to other people, rather than "earning" success, "doing the right things", that they begin to succeed. You have to take responsibility for your failures, no matter how unfair they may seem, look for the lessons in them and learn to be more effective. Or at least that is how it seems to me. The distinction here is very subtle, and possible to miss entirely. I think that subtlety may explain a great deal of confusion.
- sown 14y agoWhat do you do when your most determined best effort is still inadequate?
- tagawa 14y agoAs harsh as it sounds, I'd probably re-read Taskstrike's comment above. EDIT: On a more practical note, I find reading biographies of those who've succeeded in the face of adversity gives me motivation to "press on". Dyson's autobiography is a good example.
- sown 14y agoOK, so what do I do when my most persistent determined effort fails? I.e., if I never win and never give up?
- d23 14y agoYou wouldn't ever know, because it would mean being persistent up until the last moment of your life.
- tagawa 14y agoThis is difficult without context, but first I'd replace "never win" with "haven't won yet". And even if you haven't won yet, you've surely learned something along the way (even if it's what not to do). Can this knowledge be used to try again more effectively, or to try something similar in a different field with a higher chance of success (or less risk)?
- nostrademons 14y agoReset your goals. If you never win and never give up, you're probably working on the wrong problem.
- emmelaich 14y agoI almost hate myself for quoting W.C.Fields here, but I can't resist sorry :-) "If at first you don't succeed, try, try again. Then quit. No use being a damn fool about it."
- confluence 14y agoNothing in the world can take the place of Luck. Talent will not; nothing is more common than unsuccessful men with talent. Genius will not; unrewarded genius is almost a proverb. Education will not; the world is full of educated derelicts. Luck and determination alone are omnipotent. The slogan 'Good Luck' has solved and always will solve the problems of the human race. - A reality based Calvin Coolidge Hard work and luck are what's needed to succeed. If you ignore luck - you will end up bitter, sad and depressed. If you were born female in the 1920s - you will not do well. If you were black in the 19th century - you will not do well. If you are poor in the 21st century - you will not do well. If you die before you get anything done - you will not do well. Luck > determination - always has been - always will be. You can increase your chances at success but don't lie to people and say success is by hard work alone - that's a lie.
- givan 14y agoWhat is luck? a set of favorable conditions for solving your problem, some can be in your control and some may not but in the end is up to you. You can work on fixing the unfavorable conditions and take control of your luck, immigration, education, determination, courage, these are the tools that can shape your luck.
- nickpinkston 14y agoWhile we must all acknowledge the crazy amounts of luck we've been privy to - it's not super useful except as a salve for your lack of success - which could totally be due to luck, or to temper your success. Luck and work on dependent - we need to acknowledge that. I've had some damn lucky moments that I had to work my ass off for. Where's the utility in knowing that much is left to luck? The only way I can think is optimizing for luck - networking a lot, giving talks, giving help, etc. all, as some HNer put it "expands your luck surface area" - an apt term
- ZeroGravitas 14y agoReading about the 1920s stock market crash recently it struck me that many men ruined themselves because they were unaware that their previous success owed more to luck than to their mastery of the situation.
- twelvechairs 14y agoIt maddens me when they use 'success' in such narrow terms. There are other kinds of success than a poor kid achieving a university education (as great as that might be).
- keithpeter 14y ago"For both rich and poor teenagers, certain family characteristics predicted children’s maladjustment, including low levels of maternal attachment, high levels of parental criticism and minimal after-school adult supervision." 'maladjustment' seems quite a strong word, but I have seen this pattern with some teenagers I teach, including the ones whose parents have bought them cars, iPads, clothes &c, but don't seem to spend time. A handful this year decided not to go to University (UK: 18 year olds) but to get jobs or training positions in a different city. Sounds hopeful.
- Tichy 14y agoI'm probably too paranoid, because first things I think about are "appeasement": reading that article you can think "ah, it was just my laziness that made me fail, hard work still brings success even to poor people" and "even rich kids fail because they have callous parents". At the same time, a lot of people don't have to work at all, and probably sponsor articles like this to keep the working population calm.
- inthewoods 14y agoAs a parent, I find these kind of books, well, silly. They generally leverage a series of small studies and then provide a handful of examples to reinforce their thesis. Now, maybe this book uses larger studies, but they are pretty hard to come by. So what we're left with is essentially nothing new - poor children don't succeed, and rich kids can go off the tracks. Is this news? Is it news that perseverance matters? I would love a book on parenting that is based on a large enough data set to make it relevant, and then provide some suggestions based on those studies - anyone know of any? My guess is that anyone that reads this kind of book is already likely a decent parent - but I would need to look at the data. :)