3 ms·
It's easy to say but not so easy to do. The two Western designs built in the last generation are the EPR and the AP1000. The EPR is so unconstructable that it
by PaulHoule 1y ago
It's easy to say but not so easy to do.
The two Western designs built in the last generation are the EPR and the AP1000. The EPR is so unconstructable that it could have been designed by Amory Lovins to put the nails in the coffin of nuclear power. The supply chain for the AP1000 is centered in China. If it wasn't for problems of war and peace the rational thing to do might be ask the Russians to come in and built a VVER.
GE is pushing the BWRX300 which might get some cost reductions because it doesn't need a steam generator, but the small size doesn't help the economics and the cost numbers they are talking about are amazingly low.
- SoftTalker 1y agoSmaller scale can make construction more practical though, even if the economics are worse than the theoretical best. Billions have been lost on unfinished large-scale nuke plants more than once, because they take too long, are too complex, and get more and more mired in politics as the years drag out. A small plant that could be online in months or at most a year or two from start of construction is way more pragmatic.
- PaulHoule 1y agoThe concrete benefit I see for the small LWR is this: it is possible to build a pressure vessel by welding segments together but most economical to build one in a superheavy forge that can pound one out of a single piece of steel. There are no superheavy forges in North America (although there are many in various Asian and European countries) although the BWRX300 is small enough that it can be made in Canada. As for simpler construction it has to be proven. The AP1000 was a "modular reactor" in that they tried to make it out of large modules that could be built in a factory and stuck together on site. The factories struggled to make those modules and when they arrived they often needed major rework. The ACP100 was recently completed in China https://nucleus.iaea.org/sites/INPRO/df13/Presentations/011_CNNC%27s%20ACP100%20SMR-Technique%20Features%20and%20Progress%20in%20China.pdf https://nucleus.iaea.org/sites/INPRO/df13/Presentations/011_... and press releases boasted that it was one of the most complex construction projects of all time -- what I wanted to hear was "this is one of the most simple construction projects of all time!"
- mrbluecoat 1y agoLet's hope the plan incorporates cutting-edge advancements, like molten salt and liquid thorium designs.. https://www.livescience.com/technology/engineering/chinese-scientists-make-nuclear-power-breakthrough-using-abandoned-us-research https://www.livescience.com/technology/engineering/chinese-s... I'm also hopeful there's a resurgence of interest in Small Modular Reactors (SMRs).
- PaulHoule 1y agoPeople forget that we quit building coal burning power plants at the same time we quit building nukes... For the same reason. The capital cost of the steam turbine is atrocious. Molten salt, HTGR and LMFBR designs could all be coupled to a supercritical-CO2 powerset which would fit in the employee break room of the turbine hall of an LWR. The steam generators for a PWR are larger than the reactor vessel itself, but a higher temperature reactor could miniaturize them [1]. You still see old literature that claims the LMFBR has a higher capital cost than the LWR but a lot of that comes from the expensive powerset and heat exchangers which have to be doubled to prevent a water-sodium reaction in the primary loop. So yeah, 4th generation reactors could be a revolution but they are not a bird in the hand and it won't be a matter of "we'll write a check to build a 1 GW reactor" whether you are New York State or Google, it will be matter of "we'll build a test reactor" and it could be another 15 years at least before we get to the TRL 7 stage. [1] https://www.precisionmicro.com/understanding-printed-circuit-heat-exchangers-the-role-of-chemical-etching/ https://www.precisionmicro.com/understanding-printed-circuit...
- throw0101c 1y ago> Let's hope the plan incorporates cutting-edge advancements, like molten salt and liquid thorium designs.. Let's hope not. At least not for the first few new nuclear plants. There is a lot of operating experience with 'traditional' designs and lessons learned over the decade. There are also new lessons learned with the Vogtle AP1000s. Any new construction (in the US) should be AP1000s to take advantage of those lessons. Once people are familiar nuclear again then perhaps look at different designs. But you should learn to crawl and walk before trying to run. (A lot of nuclear construction is the civil works, and is the same for any type of design, and getting that down to cookie cutter output would help any different designs as well.)
- FuriouslyAdrift 1y agoThere's also the incredible cheap and easy to mass produce submarine and shipboard reactor designs. Going smaller and build lots more brings costs down tremendously. Combined with breeder reactors plus reprocessing to deal with waste. You'd have to miltarize all staff to deal with profilieration risks and then license out delivery to private corps (utility companies).
- PaulHoule 1y agoIt's kinda the opposite. Submarine reactors burn like a cigarette which is great from the viewpoint of rapidly changing power output and dealing with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iodine_pit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iodine_pit but terribly uneconomical. Optimizing economics is about optimizing power output from a given volume of pressure vessel. The power of a nuclear reactor is limited by the ability to get heat out of the fuel rods and into the coolant so good economics requires producing energy evenly throughout the whole core, which commercial reactors do and submarine reactors do not. Submarine reactors are worth it, however, because being able to go around the world over and over again without surfacing is of great military value. It's insane how fast a nuclear aircraft carrier can travel, there's enough uncertainty over where it will be in 15 minutes that an attack with a reasonably sized nuclear warhead could fail to kill it so, so china developed maneuverable hypersonic weapons that could punch a hole in the deck with a conventional weapon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-21#DF-21D_(CSS-5_Mod-4)_Anti-ship_ballistic_missile https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-21#DF-21D_(CSS-5_Mod-4)_Ant...
- FuriouslyAdrift 1y agoIf nuclear is going to work, it cannot be commercial. The economics won't work out. It has to be federally owned and operated (preferably by military staff so they are under UCMJ) and run as a public good and not for profit.
- jltsiren 1y agoFinland tried the VVER option as well, and it was even worse than EPR. Between 2013 and 2022, the Russians proved incapable of providing sufficient documentation that a construction permit could be issued.
- throw0101c 1y ago> The supply chain for the AP1000 is centered in China. Vogtle Units 3 and 4 started a supply chain in the US. Especially Unit 3, which is one of the reasons it was so expensive: a lot of things had to be learned. Unit 4 was (IIRC) 30% cheaper than Unit 3 because a bit of a workflow was developed. Any future US AP1000 units should be better than Vogtle—if people don't try to re-invent the wheel and use the same trail used in that project.
- Saline9515 1y agoThis is caused by the (overly) stringent regulations asked by the French authorities, and the loss of skill around building modern nuclear reactors. For instance, the EPR can withstand an airliner crash. Besides, the EPR is very powerful and can produce clean, constant and pilotable electricity at the largest scale for a very low footprint. No other tech currently matches nuclear, especially for uses that require high and predictable loads, such as AI or smelting.