7 ms·
The autoimmune hypothesis is yet another autism hypothesis that is advanced primarily by parents, because it offers more hope than a neurological etiology. A lo
by jdietrich 14y ago
The autoimmune hypothesis is yet another autism hypothesis that is advanced primarily by parents, because it offers more hope than a neurological etiology. A lot of people hold strongly to the hope that autism is just a set of symptoms that are triggered by something tangible and readily treatable like a nutritional deficiency or a food allergy, rather than a permanent difference in brain structure. The available evidence points very clearly in one direction - genetics.
It also bears repeating that what we call "severe autism" is really "some amount of autism comorbid with very low IQ". Autism is routinely overdiagnosed in preference to a more accurate diagnosis of intellectual disability because parents prefer it, again because it offers more hope, largely due to the popular trope of the autistic savant.
Parents of severely disabled children naturally hold out for any source of hope and I don't judge them for that in any way, but we can't let that get in the way of the science that really is their child's best hope. There is no evidence for the hygiene hypothesis.
- Alex3917 14y ago"The autoimmune hypothesis is yet another autism hypothesis that is advanced primarily by parents, because it offers more hope than a neurological etiology." I haven't done any research on this, but at the same time virtually every other chronic illness is caused, causes, and/or is exacerbated by chronic inflammation, so if inflammation during pregnancy doesn't have any effect on neurological development it would be extremely surprising.
- mbateman 14y agoYep. Reading the article I was a little put off by how banal the hypothesis really is. Inflammation, including neuroinflammation, is involved in many pathologies. Whether it is a cause or a symptom is unclear, partially because it is unclear what is going on in neurons exposed to stressors that causes their dendrites to recede. If inflammation is the main cause and best treatment vector for autism, autism is in the same boat as Alzheimer's and other difficult-to-treat inflammation-related neurological conditions.
- maratd 14y ago> we can't let that get in the way of the science that really is their child's best hope If it's genetic, as you assert, then what hope is there? I believe you're correct, but ... > because parents prefer it, again because it offers more hope This sort of thinking is popular because it offers hope and having that hope present offers a higher quality of life for the family.
- losvedir 14y ago> If it's genetic, as you assert, then what hope is there? Um... plenty? Tons of genetic diseases are treatable. This is where Genzyme, for example, makes most of its money. Cerezyme for Gaucher's disease or Fabrazyme for Fabry disease to name two.
- billswift 14y ago>If it's genetic, as you assert, then what hope is there? Recognizing what their specific problems actually are, there is significant variation in the strength of the particular difficulties individual autistics face. Teaching autistics to work around their disabilities; there has been significant progress on this approach for recognizing and dealing with other peoples emotions, for example. Getting them the support they need for problems they cannot work around.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoIf it's genetic, as you assert, then what hope is there? Drugs which target the specific pathways triggered by the gene.
- maratd 14y agoNo amount of drugs will affect the structure of a brain.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- lutusp 14y ago> There is no evidence for the hygiene hypothesis. On the contrary, there is copious evidence for the hygiene hypothesis: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hygiene_hypothesis#Supporting_evidence http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hygiene_hypothesis#Supporting_e... PubMed: Epidemiological and immunological evidence for the hygiene hypothesis: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17544829 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17544829 A quote: "...several epidemiological studies were conducted supporting this concept and generating novel ideas for the underlying mechanisms that were then followed up by use of well-defined animal models and human studies." Your statement is, simply put, absolutely false.
- billswift 14y agoThere is inadequate evidence of a link between the hygiene hypothesis and autism, which is what the article was about. I agree that there seems some fairly good support for the hygiene hypothesis and immunological problems, like allergies and asthma. EDIT: replaced "no evidence" with "inadequate evidence", as lutusp noted, the article is claiming a correlation, which is at least weak evidence.
- lutusp 14y ago> There is no evidence of a link between the hygiene hypothesis and autism, which is what the article was about. The article shows a correlation between the hygiene hypothesis and autism. A correlation, by itself, could mean anything or nothing, but it is certainly evidence. Are you using "evidence" as a synonym for "proof", as in law? I ask because science doesn't work that way. This correlation may simply evaporate with further work, or reveal some connection not now apparent, but saying there's no evidence for the correlation is simply false.
- lutusp 14y ago(This is a response to the OP's post after he edited it.) > There is inadequate evidence of a link between the hygiene hypothesis and autism Inadequate for what? The author isn't claiming more than is there, and it's a simple correlation at this point, one that merits further examination. It isn't as though scientific theories are ever proven true. That's not how science works. And this correlation is far from even being a theory. > the article is claiming a correlation, which is at least weak evidence. No -- a correlation is not weak evidence of a cause-effect relationship, in fact it's not cause-effect evidence at all.
- Dn_Ab 14y agoThank you for this. Trying to pin Autism down to a simple cause is foolish. Not only is autism often (thusfar not 100%) caused by a malfunction in the genes it is implicated in thousands of different genes and not even necessarily inherited (in large part being due to denovo mutations). Nonetheless the brain is a wide surface area of attack, there are many ways to assault it that could result in impaired intelligence. Worth noting is that the connection between inflammation, intelligence and health could be more related to the heritable trait of how stable or robust your phenotype is to noise (mutations and stochastic alike). What I also find interesting is that the fear for a disease being genetic will likely flip in the next 2 decades. Genetic diseases will be more easily corrected than diseases that will evolve a slip right under your nose.
- lutusp 14y ago> Trying to pin Autism down to a simple cause is foolish. Foolish unless true. We just don't know, and it's too soon to be abandoning theories. Science doesn't proceed by categorically denying possibilities before they've been fully investigated. > Genetic diseases will be more easily corrected than diseases that will evolve a slip right under your nose. On the contrary, genetic diseases will with rare exception remain incurable.
- Dn_Ab 14y ago1.) We are not disagreeing. Anyone who wants to pin it to autoimmune effects is missing the genetic causes, anyone looking for simple mendelian causes is missing out on multiple gene susceptibilties or denovo mutations, etc. 2.) This is a testable hypothesis and will be known in time. I believe that we will have a good enough understanding and control over genetics such that effective therapies even for adults will be possible in the stated time frame. Also notice I used the word correct not cure, not a mere play in semantics but a subtle change that strongly alters meaning.
- lutusp 14y ago> This is a testable hypothesis and will be known in time. Wait -- if resolution requires the simple passage of time, then it's not testable, indeed it's not really a test. A "testable hypothesis" means a notion that's subject to practical test in the present. Waiting for a future yea/nay outcome isn't, strictly speaking, a test. More of a waiting game. > I believe that we will have a good enough understanding and control over genetics such that effective therapies even for adults will be possible in the stated time frame. Gene therapies have a pretty terrible track record to date. Nevertheless, if your "time frame" is 100 years, then I would have to agree it's likely, based on Clarke's First Law: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clarkes_three_laws http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clarkes_three_laws Quote: "When a distinguished but elderly scientist states that something is possible, he is almost certainly right. When he states that something is impossible, he is very probably wrong." > Also notice I used the word correct not cure, not a mere play in semantics but a subtle change that strongly alters meaning. Yes, agreed, and if this era arrives, treatment recipients will have to be told that their improved condition by no means implies that their offspring won't be similarly afflicted.
- sridharvembu 14y agoDo you have any basis for saying the autoimmune hypothesis is "advanced primarily by parents?" I ask because I have a son with autism, and I have met leading immunologists in famous medical schools who subscribe to this hypothesis. That doesn't make the hypothesis right, but it is taken far more seriously than your comment would imply. Second, "severe autism is really some amount of autism with very low IQ" part is also wrong in my opinion. Autism can be so severe that it makes IQ irrelevant (even in cases where it can be demonstrated to be high). The analogy here is with other mental illnesses like schizophrenia - when it is severe enough, it masks every other trait of that person, including IQ. That does not mean "severe schizophrenia is really some amount of schizophrenia combined with very low IQ". There are many severely autistic individuals who also demonstrate high IQ in specific areas (but still cannot lead anything close to a normal life), directly contradicting your statement. I expect a little more thoughtfulness on a top comment in HN.
- saurik 14y agoI read jdietrich's comment about "severe autism is really...is really overdiagnosed..." not as "is always" (which you seem to have chosen to interpret it as) but "is more often", which doesn't contradict your "autism can be...that it makes" response: I seriously doubt that jdietrich is claiming that no such people exist, and thereby the fact that "there are many severely autistic individuals" doesn't show the statement to be false. Of course, it may be false, but so could anything people say, even when backed up by "sources"; however, I really do feel the need to point out that it isn't false only because there are exceptions, as the word "overdiagnosed" only implies "more often than is warranted" and doesn't in any way leave out the possibility that it is sometimes correct, or even that there aren't "many" cases: just that the number of people who are diagnosed is larger, and possibly still much larger (even with "many" real cases), than the number of people who truly have the issue and should be diagnosed. (To be very explicit: nothing I have said here relies on specific information about autism, nor can it, as I know absolutely nothing about that disorder.)
- DiabloD3 14y agoI have Aspergers, and I feel the same way that Autism might be incurable for those who already have it. This research may help future generations, but I'm not hopeful that it will help me. I am probably going to get downvoted for being realistic about it, but if you don't have autism you really don't know what its like. I wouldn't wish this on my worst enemy, and I would do anything for a possible cure, but I can't allow myself to be filled with a false hope that someday I can live a normal life.
- lsc 14y ago>It also bears repeating that what we call "severe autism" is really "some amount of autism comorbid with very low IQ". Ah, that... actually explains a lot. I've worked with several people with Autism diagnoses, and yeah, they were nerdy... really nerdy and socially inept, but also smart, productive individuals able to lead independent lives; People I'd be happy to call friend. Yeah, I have to go out of my way to figure out how to effectively communicate with them, but it's worth it. If I had a kid that grew up to be like them, I'd be proud. I hear people talking about autism like it's this terrible thing, and I don't really understand, Your kids could very easily turn out a lot worse than the Autistic people I know. Of course, if any of these people were low-IQ, or really, anywhere near average, they'd have a difficult time indeed.