4 ms·
The Gender Attractiveness Gap
- bronlund 1y ago[flagged]
- Diti 1y agoThe study mentions the perceived attractiveness comes from body shape. Unless plastic surgery is involved, men can’t really compete.
- DannyBee 1y agoAs the paper says, studies generally require they remove makeup and any non permanent look enhancing things. So they do control for this to the degree they can
- monster_truck 1y ago[flagged]
- Veen 1y agoIt’s about a subjective phenomenon.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- suddenlybananas 1y agoWhy is this specific paper harmful?
- jinnert 1y agoWhy would you react like this? It seems like one of those phenomena we all intuitively know to be true, and they've tried to capture this as best they could with the method described.
- ggm 1y agoI don't find this critique particular compelling, but I do hope some illumination is thrown on what is clearly a vehemently held view. Please expand.
- Diti 1y agoGee, if only it was possible for people to try and replicate results, peer review the paper, and publish a counter-study.
- _Algernon_ 1y ago>While self-selection is unlikely to explain the GAP, another potential artifact of data collection could be systematic differences in grooming practices between genders. Women typically invest more time and resources in grooming than men (Das & Stephen, 2011). However, most studies follow standardized photo-shooting protocols requiring participants to remove makeup and other enhancing accessories (e.g. Ebner et al., 2018; Kleisner et al., 2024; Torrance et al., 2014; Zhang et al., 2019). While some grooming practices, such as eyebrow shaping or long-term skincare routines, may not be entirely controlled by these protocols, their impact is likely minimal. I disagree with their premise that this impact is "likely minimal". I also would want to know what percentage "most studies" refers to.
- 4ndrewl 1y agoDid the authors take into account that humans have 'culture' (and structures of (male-dominated) power associated with it) whereas other species don't to any great extent?
- jinnert 1y ago[flagged]
- IX-103 1y agoIf we do, it won't be a new phenomenon. They've been around practically forever.
- soco 1y ago"matriarchal model" quote please? Maybe I'm not in the west enough (Switzerland) but I definitely see pretty much the same power structure as ever, just with a few female managers and a few whining males. But I do see indeed a few trophy husbands - ordered in the same mail catalogue where the thousand times more brides are ordered.
- watwut 1y agoHow are they pursuing look "at the cost of career, wealth"? In other studies, good looking men earn more and are more successful in negotiations.
- jinnert 1y agoI shouldn't have made the two seem mutually exclusive. I think physical attractiveness is becoming a far higher priority for each successive generation of men while hard work, loyalty, dedication, etc are declining in perceived value, to the extent that these may even be viewed as the traits of a loser. We have abandoned the benefits of meritocracy, and young men are adapting to that. Rather than looksmaxxing in lieu of pursuing success, young men are looksmaxxing as it has become essential to success.
- 1y ago
- reedf1 1y agoI don't think a cross-cultural meta-analysis properly controls for the cultural effect of gender attractiveness given we live in a (progressively more) globalized, interconnected, world.
- krona 1y agoUnconvincing. Why did the authors select the face as the determinant of attractiveness? AFAIK the human female focuses on the upper body in general, with nothing in particular. Cultural variations exist, obviously. This (upper body strength, generally) would make sense for evolutionary reasons. It makes more sense than the (male) peacock's tail, for example.
- Arnt 1y agoIt's a meta study. Meta studies generally choose a scope for which there are many studies. I assume that there exist more studies of facial attractiveness than of upper body attractiveness. 30 seconds of googling agrees, but is, of course, 30 seconds.
- yawpitch 1y agoNever met a single human female that would actively select upper body strength over a face they like the look of, but I guess YMMV.
- sunflowerfly 1y agoJust look at the cover of “mom porn” books at the dollar store. They are mostly body builders with muscular bodies.
- aaronbaugher 1y agoOn forums where women talk about attractive male actors, there's a heavy emphasis on shoulders and arms. It's definitely a thing. That's not to say they don't care about the face or other features, but those don't get nearly as much attention.
- delichon 1y agoI read a claim that most male to female transitions are about wanting to become an object of desire, and most female to male transitions are to avoid being an object of desire. I've never knowingly even met a trans person and have no basis to judge. Does this ring true or false?
- PaulHoule 1y agoA transgender friend of mine for college was certain she was a girl when she was a child, she hadn’t had time to be exposed to all the men-vs-women BS, at least not directly.
- dfxm12 1y agoAnecdotally, no.
- watwut 1y agoAfaik, this is not something trans people themselves would ever be saying, but what people who do not think being trans is a thing say about them.
- _cenw 1y agoThat sounds like Blanchard's autogynephilia, which is widely disputed and rejected by most trans people and other sexologists alike.
- im3w1l 1y agoI think it may be because humans have a higher intelligence than other animals. This makes it possible for men to display genetic fitness in other ways than looks. For women, in constrast, the most important thing to signal is their capability of carrying a baby to term, and the primary way they do that is through physical traits. Though with plastic surgery and cosmetics subverting the signal on the one hand, and with better medical science capable of saving mother and child from many issues on the other, it is becoming less relevant. Edit: Though keep in mind that this is my speculation, and furthermore a broad strokes picture and there is huge individual variation.
- loudmax 1y agoMy theoretical explanation for the gap is that women are sensitive to much more than physical appearances when selecting a mate. When men select a mate, they over-index on physical characteristics, relative to women. So, women will take into account a man's physical appearance, but also his social standing is also very important, plus perceived intelligence and dependability and so on. When men look at women, physical beauty is paramount. Intelligence and so on is a plus, but not nearly to the extent that it is for women looking at men. The other part of the explanation is menopause. Humans live long past the age of sexual fertility, which is somewhat unusual in the animal kingdom. Presumably, ancient human social structures made it beneficial to have grandparents around, in a way that does not exist for most other animals. Relative to other species, this puts more evolutionary pressure on human males to seek out females that are of reproductive age, and ignore older women. The combination of these factors means that female physical appearance comes out as a prime selector in humans, in a way that it doesn't for other animal species. Male physical appearance is also significant, but relatively less important because of other factors, especially a male's status in the social hierarchy. Anyway, that's my explanation, but I wouldn't hold any of this as a firm belief. Coming up with evolutionary psychological explanations for sex differences is easy. Actually testing them is much harder.
- beAbU 1y ago> Humans live long past the age of sexual fertility, which is somewhat unusual in the animal kingdom Interesting take. Do you reckon this happened for long enough in human history that it's had an impact on the evolution on the male psyche? I'm under the impression that it's only in the last 1000 years or so where life beyond 30-40 years started to become the norm.
- jappgar 1y agoHN is not a good place to ask questions on Anthropology, so I'd encourage you to read primary source materials. You have a common misconception about human longevity. The "average" lifespan of humans was only 30 -40 years because very young humans would frequently die from disease or accidents. Humans have been capable of living to 70+ years for many millenia, it was just rare. 50 yearold humans were not rare though. The average is low because of infant and childhood mortality.
- aaaja 1y ago> Outside academia, our findings highlight how culturally embedded norms and gender-based expectations shape aesthetic judgments and influence societal perceptions. > We propose that these biases stem from cultural norms linking femininity with beauty This is probably it. The "beauty" industry, which almost entirely targets women and girls with its predatory messaging, is a multi-billion dollar market and they do everything they can to promote this as an ideology. To the point where it's become embedded in culture.
- fabiofzero 1y agoWhen incels write white papers.
- bernawil 1y agoMy take is that, biologically, creating an attractive female is easier than creating an attractive male, specifically regarding facial attractiveness. A symmetrical female child is almost guaranteed to grow up to be attractive, whereas the same isn't true for a boy. The "right" hormonal profile needed to develop attractive male features is rarer than what women require. A symmetrical girl who doesn't develop pronounced secondary sexual traits (such as full lips or prominent cheeks) is still generally considered attractive to both men and women. In contrast, masculine faces that lack strong jawlines or brow width usually aren't. Additionally, high testosterone can backfire in men, leading to overdeveloped brows or nose bridges, which may reduce attractiveness.