10 ms·
An Immune Disorder at the Root of Autism
- w0nderlust 14y agoIf this is true, then it makes sense that vaccines could trigger the symptoms of autism. Looks like the Internet owes Jenny McCarthy an apology.
- eli 14y agoHuh? No, it really doesn't make any sense for vaccines to have anything to do with autism.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- capnrefsmmat 14y agoIt doesn't matter if it "makes sense"; observational studies have shown it to not be the case. Reality disagrees with your intuition.
- w0nderlust 14y agoThose studies simply compared rates of autism in vaccinated populations... so if vaccines are merely bringing out the symptoms in people who already have autism then it still makes sense.
- lutusp 14y agoThis is false, because many careful studies have compared populations, otherwise identical, that differed in one particular -- one received vaccinations, the other didn't. The outcome is that there is no difference between them. Think about this in everyday terms -- consider the financial advantage, the scientific prestige, that would accrue to someone who located such a link. Wealth, fame, the unrequited love of women. But even though this issue has been studied repeatedly, no one has been able to show a scientific correlation between vaccines and autism. Andrew Wakefield pretended to show a link, but his motives are now obvious -- he received thousands of dollars in consulting fees from a group of lawyers trying cases related to this issue, and he sought a patent on a vaccine of his own design, a vaccine that would have enriched him if there was such a link. These facts call his objectivity into question. And examination of his "scientific" work shows a repeated pattern of fraud and deception. I suggest that you think like a scientist. Scientists don't say what you have, in essence: "if it hasn't been disproven, that's an argument in its favor." Scientists only count positive evidence as support for a hypothesis, and there is none for this issue. Indeed all the studies come to the same conclusion -- there is no link between vaccines and autism.
- dllthomas 14y agoIf autism was something we had genetic or biological tests for, this would be a valid concern. Presently, however, we don't have a biomarker for autism - the studies determine whether children have autism by looking at their symptoms. If vaccines did cause a significant increase in symptoms, we should expect it to move some number of individuals from "undetectable" to "detectable" and we'd see that in the numbers. There is the narrow possibility, which may well have been looked at but hasn't been discussed, that vaccines could make autism worse only when it is significant to begin with, so nothing is crossing the threshold between not-quite-autism to autism, but I don't think we have any more evidence cause us to expect that relative to the simpler hypothesis that vaccines have roughly the same impact at any degree of autism: none.
- whoisnumberone 14y agoThank you for being the only one to understand my point (which you pointed out in your second paragraph) and not just knee-jerk down voting. My account was automatically censored by the HN algorithm for exploring a controversial viewpoint. As for the bio-marker there are a number of things that could be looked at: flue/bascterial infection during pregnancy, age of father, anti bodies in mother, rheumatoid arthritis genetic markers in mother, asthma markers. I have to disagree that it is a narrow possibility. So much of the future of a child is determined during the formative years. Intentionally aggravating an at-risk child's immune system over and over again is something that needs to be very closely researched. To not do so at this point given all that we know seems very unethical.
- lotharbot 14y ago> "My account was automatically censored by the HN algorithm" We call it "downvoting". It's something we do when people are wrong. Stop being wrong and we'll stop downvoting you.
- tokenadult 14y agoYour comment is untrue. As the author of the submitted article notes about a related proposed explanation for autism incidence, "First, in the broadest sense, the epidemiology doesn’t jibe." And that has always been the problem with the lawyer-profit-motivated hypothesis about vaccines and autism: it never matched the epidemiological evidence. http://www.cdc.gov/vaccinesafety/concerns/autism/index.html http://www.cdc.gov/vaccinesafety/concerns/autism/index.html http://www.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id=10997 http://www.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id=10997 http://www.vaccinesafety.edu/cc-mmr.htm http://www.vaccinesafety.edu/cc-mmr.htm http://briandeer.com/mmr/lancet-summary.htm http://briandeer.com/mmr/lancet-summary.htm http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2012/08/04/andrew-wakefield-dismissed/ http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2012/08/04/andrew-wakefiel... http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/jenny-mccarthy-jim-carrey-and-green-our-vaccines-anti-vaccine-not-pro-safe-vaccine/ http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/jenny-mccarthy... http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/dr-google-and-mr-hyde/ http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/dr-google-and-... http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/an-antivaccine-tale-of-two-legal-actions/ http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/an-antivaccine...
- w0nderlust 14y agoI'm merely arguing that vaccines could possibly bring out or affect the severity of the symptoms of autism. None of the studies seem to study the severeness of autisms... just the rates, which would be unaffected if autism is already determined by a different factor (apparently age of the father may be one). It's so scary to see how many people refuse to open their minds to possibilities outside their preconceived notions. The responses in this thread are a prime example.
- lutusp 14y ago> I'm merely arguing that vaccines could possibly bring out the symptoms of autism. That possibility has been studied very extensively, and the science is in -- there is no link. > It's so scary to see how many people refuse to open their minds to possibilities outside their preconceived notions. Yes, true, but it's not too late for you to do just that -- read the science, and stop posting uninformed opinions.
- zdw 14y agoIt looks like Jenny McCarthy owes dead children and grieving parents an apology: http://arstechnica.com/science/2012/08/widespread-vaccine-exemptions-are-messing-with-herd-immunity/ http://arstechnica.com/science/2012/08/widespread-vaccine-ex... See also: http://www.jennymccarthybodycount.com http://www.jennymccarthybodycount.com
- lutusp 14y ago> If this is true, then it makes sense that vaccines could trigger the symptoms of autism. No, that is false. That theory has been demolished by the many studies designed to compare outcomes between those who do, and do not, receive modern vaccinations: http://www.autismsciencefoundation.org/autismandvaccines.html http://www.autismsciencefoundation.org/autismandvaccines.htm... The one study that claimed a link has been exposed as a fraud and its author has been sanctioned: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/glenn-d-braunstein-md/andrew-wakefields-vaccina_b_816208.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/glenn-d-braunstein-md/andrew-w... A quote: "In early January, the British Medical Journal called the 1998 study by Andrew Wakefield, which proposed a link between the measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine, gastrointestinal problems and autism, 'an elaborate fraud.' According to Fiona Godlee, the journal's editor-in-chief, 'It's one thing to have a bad study... In this case we have a very different picture of what seems to be a deliberate attempt to create an impression that there was a link by falsifying the data.'" I ask you to educate yourself on this issue before posting discredited claims in a public forum.
- shawnz 14y agoI could see how one might think they're potentially related, but it's quite a jump to suggest that you shouldn't vaccinate for that reason. Besides, the article is talking about in-womb development, which is a much more plausible vector for autism, considering what we know about it.
- ed209 14y agoWith an account created within an hour of this submission I have to ask if you are trolling this forum? Everyone is entitled to opinion, but when discussing articles like this it's fact and science that matter. Comments like your cost lives. We're already seeing increase in measles rates in the UK from the fallout of the MMR scare mongering around 10 years ago. Please understand that parents who perceive any risk to their children will always err on the side of caution. When that perceived risk is based on lies and assumptions you stand the chance of exposing that child to other known and proven risks. Please think before you post.
- adrianwaj 14y agoIf you say that, people will hate you. (and all that goes with it) But, I think it's a range of epigenetic factors that trigger an auto-immune response to have autism expressed according to some genetic program. Vaccines with their adjuvants are but one trigger - and it should be patently obvious that this might well be the case from the article.
- kellishaver 14y agoI think what you're trying to say is not just a direct "stuff in vaccines triggers autism" but more to the point that if the lack of exposure to germs/diseases/pathogens can lead to an immune system response that can cause autism, then vaccines contribute to creating that "too clean" environment, by eliminating those diseases. That's not how vaccines work, though. They create immunity through controlled exposure to the virus. If they were contributing to the "super clean" environment, then they would be preventing exposure.
- darkarmani 14y ago> Looks like the Internet owes Jenny McCarthy an apology. The woman that is responsible for promoting actions (lack of actions) that killed lots of children? http://www.jennymccarthybodycount.com/Jenny_McCarthy_Body_Count/Home.html http://www.jennymccarthybodycount.com/Jenny_McCarthy_Body_Co...
- ahi 14y agoA story on This American Life about a guy who got hookworms intentionally to deal with his immune disorder: http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/404/enemy-camp-2010?act=3 http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/404/e...
- btilly 14y agoI have a friend who did the same. It worked. He has now gone a year and a half without medication, and is in massively better shape than he was on the (expensive and only marginally effective) medications.
- pacaro 14y agoHere's my anecdote. I suffer from psoriasis and psoriatic arthritis. For the most part the psoriasis is not a big deal, it's disfiguring, but only on my legs, and it itches to the point that I'm perfectly capable of scratching long past the point that I'm bleeding. The psoriatic arthritis is another matter, untreated I live somewhere between 5-7 on the pain scale, shaking hands is nerve-wracking (please, no bone crusher handshakes - I do suffer from hand squeezy death) and I can barely walk. On meds I'm basically fine. I use Humira which if I understand correctly is a human monoclonal antibody glued to a receptor that interferes with something to do with T-cells. I.e. it causes a specific immune suppression that massively reduces the process that causes the psoriasis and arthritis symptoms - oh and I'm 100x more likely to get skin cancer. I've been off meds for over 6 months now with very limited impact on my life. All I did was cut out refined sugars and grain from my diet. I discovered this by accident (too lazy to refill my prescription, then realized that I hadn't refilled in ages and yet wasn't in pain) I think that there's a huge load we don't understand in the relationship between inflammation and autoimmune conditions; there are many things that are involved Just my 2¢, I love science so please disregard my anecdotal ramblings
- rz2k 14y agoIt is worth taking a look at how Radiolab covered hookworms, the fallout, and this followup: http://www.radiolab.org/blogs/radiolab-blogland/2010/apr/02/an-update-on-hookworms/ http://www.radiolab.org/blogs/radiolab-blogland/2010/apr/02/... The comments do not inspire much confidence either. To be honest I'm disappointed in Radiolab for being clearer, and addressing some of the crazy there.
- zdw 14y agoThe TL:DR; I get from this is: "we're clean freaks, and thus our immune systems go wonky and start attacking good things because they lack bad things to go after, including unborn children that get autism as a result" This totally validates my need to go play in the mud and eat sketchy food from carts on the street.
- ams6110 14y agoWe're "clean freaks" because we've learned that there are harmful microbes and parasites in the world. Millions die/have died of disease such as cholera and typhoid that are spread chiefly by poor hygiene. The parasites we don't get as a result of having clean water and sanitary sewers are on balance harmful to us. I'm not sure I buy the "hygiene is harmful" argument or that we've gone overboard with it. I think a lot of other factors that have changed in the past 60 years might factor in, including a misguided government/agribusiness lead food pyramid that is way out of balance with our pre-civilization diets, as well as the introduction of highly processed and sweetened food that for many of us forms the majority of our diets.
- olliesaunders 14y ago> I'm not sure I buy the "hygiene is harmful" argument or that we've gone overboard with it. You can be hygienic and still cultivate behaviors that increase your exposure to safe levels of microbes. For instance, I always wash my hands after using the toilet but I’m less concerned than most about the use-by dates on food products and prefer to make decisions based on my sense of smell and taste. Not sure if that’s a good example.
- bad_user 14y agoThere's ample evidence that children growing up at a farm are on average healthier and with a stronger immune system than children growing up in the city. Indeed, hygiene is not harmful, but we have gone overboard with it. As with most things in life, going to the extremes is bad for your health.
- Evbn 14y agoLead food is indeed a huge source of brain disease. That's why lead is banned from paint and similar household products.
- jmillikin 14y agoDoes anyone have references to studies regarding this? The author has a long history of advocating a link between parasite load and auto-immune disease (c.f. http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/29/magazine/29wwln-essay-t.html?_r=1 http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/29/magazine/29wwln-essay-t.ht... from 2008), and since the Wakefield scandal I'm generally skeptical of non-journal articles attempting to link autism and inflammation. The article is advertisement for the author's book, and I can't find any indication that the author has an educational background in biology. Based on his book's Amazon page, he's a journalist.
- tokenadult 14y agoDoes anyone have references to studies regarding this? Thank you for asking that essential follow-up question for most submissions on HN. Some of the references that turn up in a Google Scholar search http://scholar.google.com/scholar?as_ylo=2008&q=autism+autoimmune http://scholar.google.com/scholar?as_ylo=2008&q=autism+a... include free full-text download links, so we can follow up on this. The author has a long history of advocating a link between parasite load and auto-immune disease Yes, I also checked out the author as I submitted this article. He has postgraduate training in science writing, has worked for The Christian Science Monitor (a dodgy publication for medical reporting), and has been published in other professionally edited publications for his freelance science reporting. I thought the submitted article had enough caution of statement and names of actual researchers to be worth discussing here. The article is certainly far from the last word on the subject, but may point to a line of research that will be helpful in SOME (but certainly not all) efforts to reduce the incidence of autism in the future and to help children after they develop autism. AFTER EDIT: Some readers here may be interested in looking at the original case report by Leo Kanner that first described autism. http://www.neurodiversity.com/library_kanner_1943.html http://www.neurodiversity.com/library_kanner_1943.html An author who I think provides a helpful intercultural perspective on autism and its diagnosis is Roy Grinker, http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/health/jan-june11/grinkerext_04-19.html http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/health/jan-june11/grinkerext_... who has studied autism in cultural contexts outside the United States.
- tptacek 14y ago
- lutusp 14y agoIf the immune-response hypothesis pans out (it's only a correlation at the moment), it would lead to an irony of modern times -- a modern household's level of cleanliness can cause: * Asthma * Autism * Allergies * Immune system dysfunctions All these conditions are now "linked" to the "hygiene hypothesis," the idea that we're not doing ourselves any favors by creating near-sterile living environments. A quote from the article: "Scientists have repeatedly observed that people living in environments that resemble our evolutionary past, full of microbes and parasites, don’t suffer from inflammatory diseases as frequently as we do." I emphasize about the linked article that it represents a correlation, not a cause-effect relationship. We won't be able to say with any certainly what causes autism until we can trace its evolution step by step, from a specific environmental stimulus to a biological mechanism, with all the steps fully described. We're not yet close to that goal.
- ams6110 14y agoYeah but we are also much less likely to die at 6 months due to chronic diarrhea caused by cholera.
- lutusp 14y agoYou're posing a false choice -- between well-understood public health threats on one hand, and sterile environments on the other. There's a large, unexplored territory between the two.
- Evbn 14y agoThe unexplored territory might be better, or it might not. Still, cleanliness has far more I think it's favor than the previous state of the world.
- jdietrich 14y agoThe autoimmune hypothesis is yet another autism hypothesis that is advanced primarily by parents, because it offers more hope than a neurological etiology. A lot of people hold strongly to the hope that autism is just a set of symptoms that are triggered by something tangible and readily treatable like a nutritional deficiency or a food allergy, rather than a permanent difference in brain structure. The available evidence points very clearly in one direction - genetics. It also bears repeating that what we call "severe autism" is really "some amount of autism comorbid with very low IQ". Autism is routinely overdiagnosed in preference to a more accurate diagnosis of intellectual disability because parents prefer it, again because it offers more hope, largely due to the popular trope of the autistic savant. Parents of severely disabled children naturally hold out for any source of hope and I don't judge them for that in any way, but we can't let that get in the way of the science that really is their child's best hope. There is no evidence for the hygiene hypothesis.
- Alex3917 14y ago"The autoimmune hypothesis is yet another autism hypothesis that is advanced primarily by parents, because it offers more hope than a neurological etiology." I haven't done any research on this, but at the same time virtually every other chronic illness is caused, causes, and/or is exacerbated by chronic inflammation, so if inflammation during pregnancy doesn't have any effect on neurological development it would be extremely surprising.
- mbateman 14y agoYep. Reading the article I was a little put off by how banal the hypothesis really is. Inflammation, including neuroinflammation, is involved in many pathologies. Whether it is a cause or a symptom is unclear, partially because it is unclear what is going on in neurons exposed to stressors that causes their dendrites to recede. If inflammation is the main cause and best treatment vector for autism, autism is in the same boat as Alzheimer's and other difficult-to-treat inflammation-related neurological conditions.
- maratd 14y ago> we can't let that get in the way of the science that really is their child's best hope If it's genetic, as you assert, then what hope is there? I believe you're correct, but ... > because parents prefer it, again because it offers more hope This sort of thinking is popular because it offers hope and having that hope present offers a higher quality of life for the family.
- akkartik 14y agoJust last week I read that it could be caused by an older father: http://www.latimes.com/health/boostershots/la-heb-older-fathers--genetic-mutations-autism-schizophrenia20120822,0,4956716.story http://www.latimes.com/health/boostershots/la-heb-older-fath...
- billswift 14y agoGreg Cochrane mentions that here, http://westhunt.wordpress.com/2012/08/22/paternal-age/ http://westhunt.wordpress.com/2012/08/22/paternal-age/ , in the context of the influence of paternal age on mutation rates, and excessive numbers of mutations having negative influences on fitness and health.
- DenisM 14y agoCorrelation != causation. It could be that men with some medical condition are both likely to father an autistic child and to postpone child-rearing for health reasons. Heck, the autism itself in a very mild form might be such condition - a mildly autistic man could be likely to pass more severe autism to his children, and have problems finding a mate.
- agravier 14y agoI would like to remind HN that autism being a syndrome, it is likely to be several distinct illnesses with different genetic and environmental factors.
- billswift 14y agoThat is not what "syndrome" means. Syndrome refers to the fact that there are multiple symptoms pointing to the disorder.
- agravier 14y agoReally, I must insist: a syndrome is a set of clinical symptoms. "Austism" describes a set of symptoms. "Autism" does not describe an illness with a well-defines root cause. Hence, my comment: autism is a syndrome, and there could be several distinct illnesses (several root causes) that lead to autism.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoThat's not correct. If something is a syndrome it is more likely to be a single distinct illness rather than multiple distinct ones. I.e., suppose 50% of people suffer headaches, 50% suffer nausea, and 50% suffer aching back. Further, suppose 12.5% (= 50% x 50% x 50%) of people suffer all three symptoms - in this case, the three symptoms put together are NOT a syndrome. On the other hand, suppose 40% of people suffered headaches, nausea and aching back together. In that case the three symptoms together are a syndrome. A syndrome is probabilistic evidence that there is an underlying cause of multiple co-occurring symptoms.
- agravier 14y agoYou are right, I should have written more explanations. Autism is quite special in that the symptoms are behavioral: impairments in social interaction and communication, restricted interests and repetitive behavior (this list is on Wikipedia). These are very different from aches and other simple physical manifestations. In fact, when we try to look for simpler symptoms, the set of symptoms becomes blur, in that no other symptom can be found always present together with to those core behavioral ones. The variety of more physical manifestations of autism hints at a variety of root causes. E.g., gastrointestinal issues are common but not always there. Cerebellar anomalies too. etc... Sorry, I wrote that up fast, if you are interested you can write a reply, I'll try answering tomorrow, it's late for me now.
- jasonlotito 14y agoWithout getting into too much detail, my wife had complications during her pregnancies. My older son (3) is autistic. My younger son might be as well. I'm not sure of the science behind what is being discussed here, but the specific elements it discusses match up with certain things that occurred during the pregnancy. Oddly off-topic and yet on-topic for HN, I'm working on a startup idea to assist families with special needs. I've been trying to go it alone, but not having a partner is tough. No one to speak with, no one to work with. If anyone is interested, even if it's just to chat, email me (found in my profile). I'm bad at asking for help. =/
- verisimilidude 14y agoWould you like some anecdotal encouragement? My mom had a serious liver infection during her second trimester while carrying my older brother. He turned out autistic. After years of dressing down people about vaccines and other snake-oil causes of autism, she forwarded this article to me with one line, "This must be the reason." FWIW. Anyway, I came two years later without complications. I also exhibited many odd behaviors that worried my parents at first, but wound up not being autistic. Hang in there and keep your chin up. Your younger son might be fine.
- jasonlotito 14y ago> Hang in there and keep your chin up. Your younger son might be fine. He is fine. I know that's not what you mean, but regardless of the diagnosis, he is a wonderful child, and I would not have him any other way. My worry isn't for my children, but for the way society treats those with autism. It's hard to explain. Thanks though. =)
- mkopinsky 14y ago> And yet, a trial is under way at the Montefiore Medical Center and the Albert Einstein College of Medicine testing a medicalized parasite called Trichuris suis in autistic adults. Montefiore representin'! (Too bad they failed to mention the names of any of the people involved at Montefiore/Einstein so I could walk over to their lab and look at their posters or talk to them.)
- veven 14y agoI have multiple sclerosis and acquired hookworms about 3 years ago as an attempt to prevent further relapses. HN isn't exactly the place for this, but if anyone has any questions I'd be happy to answer.
- bluekeybox 14y agoIf the hygiene hypothesis is correct, then month of birth/conception should have an effect on the risk of autism. Here is a report about a study which found that autism is most likely in children conceived in winter: http://articles.latimes.com/2011/may/05/news/la-heb-autism-winter-conception-20110505 http://articles.latimes.com/2011/may/05/news/la-heb-autism-w.... There was another study which "debunks" the month of birth claim, but I cannot find a link to it.
- Evbn 14y agoOn the other hand, perhaps due to school schedules in the US, or perhaps highly intelligent people having less sex in the summer time due to other correlations, winter conceptions correlate to higher academic success as well.
- septerr 14y agoWhat I find most interesting about this article is that it offers a way to diagnose autism with something more than behavioral symptoms. I don't know if it will be reliable, but it might be something parent with kids on the fringes of autistic spectrum would want to try. There's always advice floating around that their kid is fine, just a little slow etc. If we can do brain scans and find out if their levels of inflammation are above normal, there would be more certainty.
- rdl 14y agoPre-birth genetic testing (e.g. http://www.lineagen.com/ http://www.lineagen.com/) seems like a pretty effective way to end autism. It works effectively with Down's Syndrome.
- darkarmani 14y ago> Pre-birth genetic testing What exactly will that do? Unless it is fragile-X or something that can be proven using genetic testing, it won't help at all.
- roguecoder 14y agoExcept that autism doesn't have a single mutation that has been identified. Even if it did, autism is not purely a negative: for those who are able to cope it produces world views that can allow us to escape local maxima. Eradication seems an odd goal. Treatment and support are more realistic and less creepy-eugenics.
- boothead 14y agoIt's worth mentioning the GAPS diet here I think: http://www.gaps.me/ http://www.gaps.me/. It seems that autoimmune/inflammatory problems are being associated with more and more diseases.