2 ms·
>> Yet we are composed of trillions of cells, all 'programmed' to deteriorate over time. > That is incorrect. The diseases of aging are the result of evolution
by lutusp 14y ago
>> Yet we are composed of trillions of cells, all 'programmed' to deteriorate over time.
> That is incorrect. The diseases of aging are the result of evolutionary neglect, they aren't 'programmed in' as if there was a timer running.
No, the earlier poster is exactly right -- all living cells are programmed to deteriorate over time. There are no examples of immortal cells, with one exception -- cancer cells, like those that were harvested from Henrietta Lacks in 1951 and live on today in Petri dishes all over the world (so-called HeLa cells).
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henrietta_Lacks http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henrietta_Lacks
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apoptosis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apoptosis
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Programmed_cell_death http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Programmed_cell_death
A quote from the second article: "Programmed cell-death (or PCD) is death of a cell in any form, mediated by an intracellular program.[1][2] PCD is carried out in a regulated process, which usually confers advantage during an organism's life-cycle. PCD serves fundamental functions during both plant and metazoa (multicellular animals) tissue development."
There is a reason we die -- it makes evolutionary sense. If there was an advantage to living longer, we would live longer. If there was an advantage to living a shorter time, we would live a shorter time. Our present lifetimes result from natural selection and evolution.
- MikeCapone 14y agoYou are looking at it the wrong way. Yes, from the point of view of an individual cell, you are correct. But from the point of view of a whole human, that's not how it works. At 25 pretty much all your cells have died and been replaced many times, and if over evolutionary times we had lived to be 500 years on average, we'd have mechanisms to keep up healthy that long. But we haven't, and so we don't, which is why everything starts going wrong as soon as you get to evolution's blind spot, past the age at which most of us lived and reproduced. If damage didn't accumulate past thresholds that cause various pathologies, we'd basically stay young adults forever. If we can figure out how to fix that damage before it reaches those levels, that's what is going to happen. It's a lot easier to figure out how to fix those few kinds of damages than to change metabolism so that damage doesn't occur, or to cure diseases after they begin. > There is a reason we die -- it makes evolutionary sense. If there was an advantage to living longer, we would live longer. If there was an advantage to living a shorter time, we would live a shorter time. Our present lifetimes result from natural selection and evolution. What is "good enough" for our genes isn't always good for us as people. Most of what can be called "modern progress" is about protecting us from what would happen to us if nature was left to itself. Curing the diseases of aging is just the continuation of that (unless you don't wear glasses, don't live inside a building, don't wear shoes, don't get vaccinated, don't take antibiotics, don't wear any kind of protection, don't brush your teeth, would never have surgery, wouldn't get hearing aids, dentures, etc).
- lutusp 14y ago> At 25 pretty much all your cells have died and been replaced many times, and if over evolutionary times we had lived to be 500 years on average, we'd have mechanisms to keep up healthy that long. You're missing the point that some cells, essential to our survival, are never replaced, and when they decay, we die. One example is brain cells -- they're never replaced, and when they're done, so are we. This means that, unless we can get around apoptosis (programmed cell death), then we won't ever move beyond a certain age. We aren't close to understanding apoptosis. > What is "good enough" for our genes isn't always good for us as people. Ah, someone who thinks he can outwit nature. When we try to outwit nature, we end up outwitting ourselves. > Most of what can be called "modern progress" is about protecting us from what would happen to us if nature was left to itself. You mean, like antibiotics? The antibiotics that we have foolishly mismanaged to the extent that they simply don't work any more? Contrary to your thesis, we need to figure out how to get along with nature, not pretend we can dominate nature. We've tried to run the show, and nature has responded by showing us how naive we are. And this idea isn't some airy-fairy New Age philosophy, it's the result of careful scientific work. We're just getting started in figuring out how to get along with nature, and everything we've tried to date has backfired: Medical and nutritional advances -> overpopulation Antibiotics and other medical breakthroughs -> the gradual evolution of antibiotic-immune microbes. Longevity extension -> overcrowding, a plague of chronic diseases in the elderly, deep philosophical questions about meaningless long lives. > Curing the diseases of aging is just the continuation of that Curing the "diseases of aging" is not your topic. Your topic is the disease of age. That's not the same thing at all.
- MikeCapone 14y ago> You're missing the point that some cells, essential to our survival, are never replaced, and when they decay, we die. One example is brain cells -- they're never replaced, and when they're done, so are we. This means that, unless we can get around apoptosis (programmed cell death), then we won't ever move beyond a certain age. We aren't close to understanding apoptosis. These cells can be replaced via stem cell therapy, and the more we look into things, the more we find that certain types of cells that we thought weren't replaced actually are. > Ah, someone who thinks he can outwit nature. When we try to outwit nature, we end up outwitting ourselves. That sounds really good, but I believe it's BS. You are anthropomorphizing nature. And every day you are "outwitting it" I'm sure. I bet you are quite happy for yourself and your loved ones not to be living like humans were living 20,000 years ago. And who's to say that technological and scientific progress isn't part of nature anyway? Why is curing diseases "against" nature? Not that nature is an entity in the first place.. All there is are the laws of physics. > Curing the "diseases of aging" is not your topic. Your topic is the disease of age. That's not the same thing at all. "age" is not an abstract thing that kills you. There are specific diseases of aging - which are diseases that old people get that young people do not get - that are curable, and that includes all the things that make us frail but aren't usually categorized as diseases (loss of muscle mass, change in texture of skin, etc). Are you saying that Alzheimer's disease and heart disease and going blind and getting fat and arthritis and losing your muscles and sex drive are good things? If so, you are welcome to refuse these therapies when they are developed, but I will gladly take them, just like I'm sure you are taking advantage of all the other modern ways of making human life easier and more enjoyable. You seem to be under what Aubrey de Grey calls the "pro-death trance"; happy that we cured smallpox and you wish we could cure AIDS and whatever, but you don't think we can cure the diseases of aging, so you find excuses for why they are actually good.