4 ms·
Maybe data and hypothesis should be published independently from conclusions, such that the conclusions of the researchers are not privileged over others. Witho
by delichon 1y ago
Maybe data and hypothesis should be published independently from conclusions, such that the conclusions of the researchers are not privileged over others. Without the conclusion, the peer review of the data can be more neutral and focused. Peers can review conclusions on their separate merits.
If the experimenter is in a better position to judge their own data than others, then they have not included sufficient data.
- efitz 1y agoMaybe hypothesis and methodology should be published before seeking a grant, before any data is collected at all. The methodology could perhaps benefit from peer review.