5 ms·
I don't understand why everybody keeps saying that a win for Apple is a blow for innovation. Samsung didn't innovate. They flat-out copied. Seems to me that all
by eridius 14y ago
I don't understand why everybody keeps saying that a win for Apple is a blow for innovation. Samsung didn't innovate. They flat-out copied. Seems to me that allowing blatant copying like this is what will suppress innovation, because why bother spending 5 years and a lot of effort/money designing something awesome if someone else can come along and clone your product in 3 months?
- novalis 14y agoConsider that what you call innovation is seen by many as natural progression built on the shoulder of others and what you call blatant copying is in the same category. You just place each in different adjective narratives. The jury glossed over looking at prior art because it would "bog" them down, isn't that a tad more alarming then all the narrative provided for who is the "good" and who is the "bad" guy in this...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- throwaway64 14y agoare you really suggesting that the iPhone in all aspects had no precedent, at all? That is completely absurd, sorry.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- lawdawg 14y ago3 months? I think your math is a bit off. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IPhone_(original) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IPhone_(original) - June, 2007 vs http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samsung_i7500 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samsung_i7500 - June, 2009
- simplexion 14y agoLG Prada - January 2007
- novalis 14y agoI love apple, they make great stuff and the eco system is a vision so well crafted it dominates anything else ever developed in that field... I had a MBP as my main machine on the road for some years even, don't make it sound like someone with another POV is simply discarding or "rewriting history". Apple copied a lot from several sources to make the original iphone, don't make it sound like they didn't because you prefer and love the brand. I get it, it's a good phone, it isn't a free pass to obliterate every other contribution to what made it great. " It was -- literally -- like nothing that had ever come before it. It was -- literally -- like no other Android phone at the time" No, it wasn't, it was progression on the work of many others and prior art that was discounted by the jury on the apple vs samsung case, is -- literally -- proof of that. Stay well. :)
- ChuckMcM 14y agoIts a question of scope. There are a lot of patents in this case that a majority of engineers or designers would not consider worthy of patent protection, the most infamous being the 'rounded corners' one. That these patents were upheld then has a huge chilling effect on everyone's design. Can I be sued because my device is rectangular? How about square? Are all quadrilaterals covered? Those are ridiculous questions on their face, but you've just seen someone who got hit with a billion dollar judgement and you can't tell that they did anything wrong, and it paralyzes you. That is why its a blow for innovation. All the rabbits will freeze hoping the hunter can't see them.
- catch23 14y agoNo, it's not a blow to innovation. The only reason Apple went after Samsung and not HTC or other Android handset manufacturers is because Samsung has gone into detail copying every small feature from Apple. If you look into Samsung's prior history, you'll see they do this for every popular product on the market -- it's part of their business model, and it's not focused specifically on copying Apple. They copied Motorola products before the iPhone came on the scene. The details of the blatant copying are addressed in that 127 page "smoking gun" that was released recently. I think businesses that focus on cloning other people's successful products actually reduce innovation because the innovation comes from the initial product inception, not from a copy. If cloning actually increased innovation, we should be seeing lots of innovative products come out of china since they're so good at making copies of other people's products.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoAre you saying that now that this case is 'over' and Apple won it, they won't sue anyone else on the same patents? If so I think that is pretty naive. If you look at other cases you will see that Apple will be compelled to sue everyone else, and/or get a license from them for these patents. If they did not do that then Samsung would be able to argue that Apple didn't really believe in their patents, they were just trying to put Samsung out of business. That at least is well understood, you can lose the protection of your trademarks or design patents if you don't enforce them.
- harryh 14y agowhy bother spending 5 years and a lot of effort/money designing something awesome if someone else can come along and clone your product in 3 months Um, because you'll be able to sell that thing over and over for gazillions of dollars and turn your company into the most valuable company in human history?
- antihero 14y agoBecause all creation is built upon the shoulders of giants. How can you innovate and compete if you have to pick through a ridiculous web of patents for fairly obvious stuff at risk of having your company destroyed and being sued into oblivion? What if someone had patented the wheel?