3 ms·

Real AI safety is enforced regulation and smart policies, period. Don't let the government's FOMO on new weapons enable these companies to add new coal and met

Real AI safety is enforced regulation and smart policies, period. Don't let the government's FOMO on new weapons enable these companies to add new coal and methane power to the grid and build data centres in water-stressed regions. Make them pay for the externalities they cause. If it weren't subsidized these companies wouldn't be operating at the scale they are, AI would be in a lab, where it belongs doing cool stuff for science. Heck, don't let government let alone private corporations weaponize this technology, full stop. Economic policy that protects businesses and individuals online. Peoples' hosting bills are going through the roof from AI scrapers. The harm is nuts. These companies aren't respecting any of the informal rules and are doing everything they can to form monopolies and shut down competition. We need social policies that prevent AI use cases from harming the economy. Policies that prevent displacing skilled workers without redistributing the accrued wealth to the labour class. If it's really improving productivity by such a huge factor then we should all be working less and living comfortably. But I dunno how you prevent the disinformation, fraud, and scams. They've been around for years and it's always a cat-and-mouse game. Social media has just made it worse and AI is just more fuel for the tire fire.

NoMoreNicksLeft 1y ago
Enforced regulation has become impossible for at least the last 25 years or so. Anyone can just build a datacenter in some foreign country, and that software still affects the people in your country. Back when they were complaining that Russia was interfering with our elections (2016ish?) I wondered what it would take to completely cut Russia off from the Internet. Granted, the Soviets still pulled stunts with less technology, but it was still a manageable problem then. Now? Well, we couldn't cut them off if we wanted to, could we? Even if we bullied Europe into severing all the fiber backbones there and elsewhere, China and North Korea and a dozen other countries would still keep them connected. And we'd still face the problems we face now. Not that we would try that. Though it might be a sane and even a reasonably good policy, you'd have jackasses here and elsewhere (and not just Russian shills either) talking about how we can't possibly disconnect the friendly Russianerinos, they're good people even if some of their oligarchs aren't. So we'll get some performative regulation theater that changes nothing. And everyone will just wonder what went wrong, quietly.

NoMoreNicksLeft 1y ago

Enforced regulation has become impossible for at least the last 25 years or so. Anyone can just build a datacenter in some foreign country, and that software still affects the people in your country. Back when they were complaining that Russia was interfering with our elections (2016ish?) I wondered what it would take to completely cut Russia off from the Internet. Granted, the Soviets still pulled stunts with less technology, but it was still a manageable problem then. Now? Well, we couldn't cut them off if we wanted to, could we? Even if we bullied Europe into severing all the fiber backbones there and elsewhere, China and North Korea and a dozen other countries would still keep them connected. And we'd still face the problems we face now. Not that we would try that. Though it might be a sane and even a reasonably good policy, you'd have jackasses here and elsewhere (and not just Russian shills either) talking about how we can't possibly disconnect the friendly Russianerinos, they're good people even if some of their oligarchs aren't. So we'll get some performative regulation theater that changes nothing. And everyone will just wonder what went wrong, quietly.