3 ms·
> the ends justify the means” which most popular moral philosophies reject with strong arguments. This is a false statement. Our entire modern world is built o
by com2kid 1y ago
> the ends justify the means” which most popular moral philosophies reject with strong arguments.
This is a false statement. Our entire modern world is built on the basis of the ends justify the means. Every time money is spent on long term infrastructure vs giving poor kids food right now, every time a war is fought, every time a doctor triages injuries at a disaster.
- naasking 1y agoI don't think it's useful to conflate "the ends justify the means" with "cost-benefit analysis". You sometimes use the latter to justify certain means, but you don't have to, that's why they're different. When you believe that the ends justify the means, you can also just give no consideration at all to the ethics of the means. No doctor triaging patients would ever shoot a patient in the head so he could move onto one they thought was more important. Yes they might let patients die, but that's different than actively killing them.
- aussiethebob 1y agoIn the framework of modern civilian medicine sure. I'm sure exactly what you described was done plenty of times in ww1 and similar around that era, and seen as perfectly moral and rational.