3 ms·
I'm hyperfixated on the idea that they're angry at Metz for "outing" Scott Alexander, who published some of his best-known posts under his own name.
by tptacek 1y ago
I'm hyperfixated on the idea that they're angry at Metz for "outing" Scott Alexander, who published some of his best-known posts under his own name.
- autarch 1y agoIsn't "Scott Alexander" his first and middle name? Did he actually use his last name on his blog before the NYT published that piece?
- tptacek 1y agoYes.
- Viliam1234 1y ago[Citation needed]
- tptacek 1y agoTricky to do without giving you an archive link of a post with his last name on it, which I'm disinclined to do. Here, in this community, with this community's norms, I'm happy to oblige him. But here is not the real world.
- Viliam1234 1y agoCome on; Scott Alexander Siskind now has his real name published in New York Times, RationalWiki, and Wikipedia, since early 2021. You can find this all on the first page of Google results (exactly as he predicted). He even mentioned his name in the first article on his Substack blog, but then returned to the pen name his readers are more familiar with. And he has already lost the job he was trying to protect back then. Now AFAIK his main source of income are subscriptions on Substack, and obviously those are not threatened in any way by having his name mentioned one more time. Please let's respect each other's intelligence by not playing the game of pretending that posting Scott's full name before 2021 is the same as posting Scott's full name after 2021. So, do you have examples of "some of his best-known posts published under his own name" before 2021?
- tptacek 1y agoYes. This isn't a controversial point. It was very much part of the conversation at the time; just go read the threads.
- Viliam1234 1y agoI checked using Google search, and Scott's full name does not appear even once on https://slatestarcodex.com https://slatestarcodex.com , his pre-2021 blog. Is this information surprising for you?
- tptacek 1y agoHe had a blog before Slate Star Codex. The impression I have is that I know more about this than you, and I'm not invested in this discussion enough to educate you adversarially, so I think it makes the most sense to just leave this subthread where it lies.
- Aurornis 1y agoLate to respond, but here's one such link: https://web.archive.org/web/20130118213127/https://www.overcomingbias.com/2013/01/hail-scott-siskind.html https://web.archive.org/web/20130118213127/https://www.overc... Title of the post is "Hail Scott Siskind" from Robin Hanson's blog Overcoming Bias. This blog was a central point of the early rationalist movement. Notably, posts like this were scrubbed some time near the New York Times debacle. There was an active effort to scrub mentions of "Siskind" from rationalist adjacent blogs around that time. It was amazingly effective at rewriting the history. You won't find any mention of the activities to scrub "Siskind" from the rationalist blogs, though.
- comp_throw7 1y agoYour persistent refusal to acknowledge that Scott did not want to go from a world where his patients Googling his real name did _not_ immediately lead to his blog, to a world where it _did_ immediately lead to his blog, and that was his primary (and valid) objection to having his real first and last name put into print, is baffling.
- throwaway314155 1y agoHis reaction to this incident as being a sort of targeted hit piece towards him specifically was utter paranoid nonsense and just really made him look full of shit from an outside perspective. Further, authors of the piece received countless death threats from a mob of angry redditors with no real insight other than "someone got doxxed?!?! HOW DARE THEY!!!" (a narrative which I personally fell victim to before reading the actual article). Scott did nothing to remedy this situation and perhaps even fanned the flames a good deal. More people should read the article, if anything because it provides interesting insight into Sam Altman's shady behavior. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/13/technology/slate-star-codex-rationalists.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/13/technology/slate-star-cod...
- bmandale 1y agoMaybe mr metz could have written under a pseudonym in order to avoid the very serious threats on his life
- throwaway314155 1y agoHave you ever had random people harass you and threaten violence towards you in heavy numbers? No amount of resolve will keep that from being a deeply stressful situation.
- bmandale 1y agoI don't doubt it's not fun, but I also don't think that either you or Mr Metz really give a shit. Rather, you like to bandy about this harassment as proof that your opponents are evil (of course, when it's your opponents being harassed, then that's a sort of divine punishment, and hence also proof that they're evil). If it were any other way, then you wouldn't particularly bring it up in reference to scott, since there isn't much of anything scott can do about other people committing harassment. Furthermore, you might express a degree of sympathy for his efforts to avoid harassment by not having his dox published in the nyt, rather than indignantly expounding on your god given right to publish whatever you feel like.