5 ms·
What is the most realistic submarine movie? (2019)
- TacticalCoder 1y agoBefore reading TFA I was going to post: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Das_Boot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Das_Boot And after reading TFA I can see it's the most voted one. I don't know if it's the most realistic one but, sheesh, does it feel claustrophobic and stressful!
- rwmj 1y agoIt's a brave man indeed who volunteers after watching Das Boot (2nd from the end in the article).
- adt 1y agoWhy not ask the actual crew? Just watched this last week about the USS Oregon, and the crew were asked their favourite sub movies... https://youtu.be/YeVsxF-MVQE?t=394 https://youtu.be/YeVsxF-MVQE?t=394
- mellosouls 1y agoI watched and the cultural references seemed pretty limited compared to TFA. I didn't hear Das Boot even mentioned...
- DocTomoe 1y agoI would not be surprised if the average US submariner is not exactly the kind of person who would seek out german anti-war movies about submarines. I mean, us as IT people ... how many of us have even heard of Dhunki, an 2019 Indian movie about morals and suffering in an Bangalore IT company?
- bookofjoe 1y agoI would bet the average U.S. submariner wasn't even born when "Das Boot" was released in 1981 — 44 years ago.
- DocTomoe 1y agoAge of a movie is not an indication of it being known by younger audiences. Star Wars is 46 years old, and virtually everyone knows it.
- bookofjoe 1y agoI'm not an IT person and I'd never heard of "Dhunki" until your comment. Turns out it's on Prime Video: https://www.amazon.com/gp/video/search?phrase=Dhunki&k=Dhunki&ref=atv_rs_redirect https://www.amazon.com/gp/video/search?phrase=Dhunki&k=Dhunk... https://www.amazon.com/gp/video/detail/B07WJ34ZC5/ref=atv_sr_fle_c_sr4e8ffb_1_1_1?sr=1-1&pageTypeIdSource=ASIN&pageTypeId=B07WH13293&qid=1750599338631 https://www.amazon.com/gp/video/detail/B07WJ34ZC5/ref=atv_sr... I'm watching it tonight! Thank you for the tip.
- bookofjoe 1y agoSigh. The curse of the acronym. I have to look up what TFA stands for. At least I didn't waste fellow HN peeps' time by commenting "What does TFA mean?" I will never understand why someone would take more time to post a comment like that than it would take to Google it....
- bookofjoe 1y agoTurns out I'm not the only one! Here's a spirited discussion on HN from 2019 in which a number of commenters note they have no clue what it means, or else have had it wrong all along: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19781756 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19781756
- mellosouls 1y agotbf i only started using it the other day after i googled it myself (though I dimly remembered it from the past). I've normally used OP (as in Original Post) but that can get confused with Original Poster (and the initial comment rather than the featured article). TFA is more specific and now that I've learned it I think its valid to use on a board where it is likely to be a regular useful shortcut.
- fat_cantor 1y agoIt was widely used on slashdot, I just assume that people who use this Three Letter Acronym (TLA) are also /. refugees
- fat_cantor 1y agoTLAs FTW!
- ChrisMarshallNY 1y agoSounds like the German film Das Boot is a winner (the German version of All Quiet on the Western Front is also amazing. Looks like the German film industry is doing well). My fave was the burb by Lieutenant Commander Jeff Vandenengel (U.S. Navy).
- shiroiuma 1y ago>Sounds like the German film Das Boot is a winner (the German version of All Quiet on the Western Front is also amazing. Looks like the German film industry is doing well). It is? By what metric? Yes, Das Boot is a fantastic movie, but it came out around 1980; that's about 45 years ago now! The new AQotWF movie has great reviews too. It just came out within the last year I think. That's two great movies in a 50-year period. This is not what I would call "doing well". There might be a few more examples of good German movies, but overall I would not call the German film industry world-leading by any means.
- ChrisMarshallNY 1y agoFair enough, but I have watched quite a bit of German stuff, lately, thanks to Netflix and Amazon. I’m sure that the driver is lower cost, but the shows have still been excellent. There’s also the rather interesting English-language Spanish stuff that Netflix has been broadcasting, and some great Scandinavian stuff (I preferred In Order of Disappearance to Cold Pursuit, even though the American version was quite faithful to the original). I know that Hollywood has been doing a lot of of offshore development (just like Silicon Valley—for the same reason), which has likely been training non-US artists in American production techniques and sensibilities (just like Silicon Valley).
- pjc50 1y agoI have a slightly more negative take on the same (positive!) phenomenon of non-English origin content becoming more popular with English audiences: the ability of Hollywood to actually complete and deliver projects is deteriorating, especially among mid-size productions and TV series that don't cost millions of dollars per episode. (also K-drama and telenovella plotting just absolutely trashes focus-grouped US streamer TV insipidness)
- southernplaces7 1y agoIt was an absolute given that Das Boot would by far be the first movie mentioned by so many of them in this post. It was the instant first movie that came to my mind and nothing comes quite close, even today, decades later. An absolute masterpiece of serious film making. Fun facts now: the cast of Das Boot was obliged to constantly stay indoors during the entire length of filming, forcefully as part of an effort to both give them a grossly pallid, sickly complexion like you'd expect from a WWII era submariner at sea for months, and to create a sense of claustrophobia that would percolate into more realistic acting. Also, the mockup of the submarine's interior was built for maximum realism in its size and all usable physical details, with the actors rigorously trained to move through this space as naturally as possible (as a real German U-boat crew would) The effort, along with the great script, fantastic cast and of course, memorable music, shows in pretty much everything, right down to the disgusting details of how they look and act after weeks at sea. One hell of a movie, and while my personal experience with submarines is zero, this is the one that feels like it should be absolute most realistic depiction of crewing a sub from that era. It fully deserves its rank as one of the most highly rated films of any kind on most movie ranking websites, like IMDB and etc. I can also see why it's the most highly voted film among submariners. Even if modern nuclear subs are at a whole other level of comfort compared to anything from 85 years ago, certain basics stay the same: It's a claustrophobic, fully enclosed space with nothing but artificial lighting, observation almost entirely through instruments, and crushing, nearly inescapable, horrible death just a few inches of hull and a couple sudden mistakes away. All this is the case in a way that just doesn't apply to the same degree with any surface vessel, where you can still somehow feel directly connected to and within reach of the wider, comforting world. It probably has more in common with space travel than being out at sea in these characteristics.
- ghaff 1y agoEven if authentic, a modern nuclear sub movie just isn't going to have the same feel. I suppose you could cite K-19: The Widowmaker though that's relatively old at this point as well.
- Jedd 1y agoI expected K-19 to be further up the list - or at least get a mention. My naive metric for realism roughly translates to 'How much does this feel like a documentary?' - and K-19, in spite of the big names, certainly felt like a story being re-told.
- zabzonk 1y agoA little OT, but the funniest sub movie has got to be "Operation Petticoat", with Cary Grant and Tony Curtis at their best. And it does have a real (though pink) WW2 sub in it.
- anonymousiam 1y agoDas Boot is probably the most realistic. For more drama, Crimson Tide is a good watch. The Hunt For Red October is more of a fantasy, but also good drama.
- jvanderbot 1y agoIt's funny because Crimson Tide is picked out here as one of the least realistic. The mention some alternative modern movies instead
- anonymousiam 1y agoNo disagreement here. Perhaps I wasn't clear enough when I prefixed the alternatives with "for more drama." Drama is usually unrealistic.
- jmcgough 1y agoVery amused that someone picked Down Periscope, which for some reason is where my mind immediately went.
- ajschrier 1y agoFormer colleague worked on submarines before joining our company - he confirmed this exact point.
- avoutos 1y agoDas Boot's soundtrack also takes the cake for me. Just compare the main title themes for Das Boot and Red October; both are good, but Das Boot's make you feel like you are in a submarine. The combination of synths, mechanical sounds, and even the sonar ping sound really adds to the artificality and claustrophobia.
- bookofjoe 1y agoIf you get a chance, visit an Apple Store and ask to watch 2024 "Submerged" — first scripted film in Immersive Video — on Vision Pro. Trailer: https://youtu.be/yDvASSABhNQ?si=iVSqDKuIUlrh23IF https://youtu.be/yDvASSABhNQ?si=iVSqDKuIUlrh23IF Apple commissioned director Edward Berger (Academy Award-winning "All Quiet on the Western Front") to make this story of a torpedo attack on a U.S. sub during WW2. Talk about claustrophobia and fear....
- bookofjoe 1y agoRuntime: 17 minutes
- gcanyon 1y agoI guess it's good to validate the answer, but I would have guessed Das Boot going in, and the answers merely confirm that I already knew the answer. The couple of exceptions are interesting though.
- DocTomoe 1y agoOne movie that was not even mentioned: The Fifth Missile (1986). Aboard a nuclear-armed submarine, crew members gradually begin to descend into madness. The cause: chronic inhalation of toxic paint fumes from freshly coated interior surfaces. The resulting disorientation leads them to mistake a routine drill for the outbreak of a real nuclear war. If Down Periscope gets a honourable mention, The Fifth Missile should, too.
- bookofjoe 1y agoGood news bad news: Good: It's on YouTube in its 2-hour 50-minute entirety, free. Bad: It's in French with French subtitles and a terribly low-res picture. Fun Fact: It's a made for TV (NBC) movie. Have at it: https://youtu.be/KMWo3hUNixc?si=eUAfihWua1eNltD6 https://youtu.be/KMWo3hUNixc?si=eUAfihWua1eNltD6
- swayvil 1y agoYellow Submarine, clearly.
- johannes1234321 1y agoWith so much attention on Das Boot, I would also recommend the DVD version of the TV series. The TV version shows the monotony which transports the relief when finally making enemy contact a lot more. In the DVD versions the individual episodes are cut together into a continuing movie of more than 4 hours. The director's cut however has improved visuals and sound, also worthwhile if you don't have the time for the big thing.
- Hilift 1y agoOn the Beach (1959). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_the_Beach_(1959_film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_the_Beach_(1959_film)
- hoseja 1y agohttps://store.steampowered.com/app/494840/UBOAT/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/494840/UBOAT/
- fat_cantor 1y agoAdm Greenert nicely describes the attitude toward early 90s sub movies (Hunt for Red October vs Crimson Tide). For this audience, in addition to driving maneuvers, he might have added that the main premise of Red October (a clipped message) never could have happened under the existing communication protocol.
- fracus 1y agoThis article asks various Navy men their thoughts. This one by Lieutenant Commander Jeff Vandenengel stuck out. - Office Space is the best submarine movie. TPS reports, multiple bosses, a defective printer, coming in on Saturday, the oversight team of “the Bobs” that are “there to help,” and the engineers are not allowed to talk to normal people. Incredibly accurate!
- Xmd5a 1y ago>the engineers are not allowed to talk to normal people why?
- globalise83 1y agoBecause engineers can't talk to customers. They need a project manager to receive the requirements sent over from the customers, and then bring the requirements to the engineers (or have someone bring them over).
- rwmj 1y agoYou might want to add some indication if this was sarcasm. If it wasn't then that's wrong - engineers should be directly talking to customers, at least some of the time. It's by far the best way to get direct feedback on what real problems customers are having with the product.
- rusk 1y agoI think they were describing “is” as opposed to “ought”
- spullara 1y agoit is basically a quote from the movie
- wanderingstan 1y agoThe relevant scene: https://youtu.be/hNuu9CpdjIo https://youtu.be/hNuu9CpdjIo
- nemosaltat 1y agoIt looks like senior officers are a bit over-represented in this survey, not surprising since it came from the US Naval Institute. Senior Partridge seems to be the only one willing to admit that Down Periscope does a surprisingly good job of capturing the inanity and absurdity of submarining. I’d argue Office Space, mentioned in a sibling comment, underrepresents the suck for the Wardroom, Nukes, and possibly MTs.