3 ms·
I'm not sure about Germany, but in Denmark it's just a service of the state. Doctors' salary, and hospitals' equipment needs, are assessed and negotiated the sa
by _delirium 14y ago
I'm not sure about Germany, but in Denmark it's just a service of the state. Doctors' salary, and hospitals' equipment needs, are assessed and negotiated the same way as with other sectors of the public-safety apparatus, such as the police department, fire department, and military. You'd like to keep your hospitals well-stocked, your fire engines maintained and modern, your air force state-of-the-art, etc., but without spending infinite money on any of those, so similar decision-making procedures are used for each. Some services are contracted out to the private sector on a competitive-bidding basis. For example, private companies run a number of the ambulance services, and also the Copenhagen bus system: the government draws up its requirements, solicits bids, and chooses a bidder, who then gets an N-year contract. In addition, there are medical-device manufacturers, both foreign and domestic, who sell on the same competitive-bidding basis. So far the bidding seems to be relatively clean, especially compared to, say, what happens with U.S. defense contractors.
Moral hazard doesn't seem to be a large problem with hospital services (doctors aren't going to order an unnecessary surgery), and there is a strong culture against unnecessary prescription drugs. So about the worst that can happen is someone wastes their local physician's time 30 minutes at a time. Since small-time office visits aren't where most of the healthcare costs go (in either Denmark or the U.S.), it's a minor concern. As far as foreigners, that's a concern, and handled by the immigration system (you probably won't get a visa if that's the reason you're trying to enter). The main current concern is intra-EU system-shopping of that sort from Europeans, who don't need visas. There are attempts to standardize something around that (the EU "blue card" scheme is one), but it's one of those awkward areas that showcases the EU's quasi-integration. There is also a debate currently about whether Denmark should start charging tourists, since it's one of the few countries that provides completely free emergency care to anyone. Many see this as the right thing to do: if a visitor is injured in a mugging, for example, some people view charging them for the hospital visit as adding insult to injury, like sending them a bill for the police investigation would be. But there is also annoyance that other countries don't reciprocate, so a little bit of a sentiment of, "well if the bastards are going to charge me for getting mugged in NYC, let's charge them when they come here".
- sp332 14y agoThe USA does not have a culture against prescription drugs. On the contrary, many patients are not satisfied unless the doctor gives them some pills. Antibiotics are often demanded even for viral infections, which probably lead directly to MRSA and other drug-resistant bacteria.
- _delirium 14y agoThat's true; I think there are definitely cultural factors that make such a system harder to implement in the US. An even bigger one is probably differing attitudes towards end-of-life "heroic measures". I had in mind more a culture among doctors, though: Danish doctors will simply not give you antibiotics no matter how much you beg, if they consider it unnecessary. That's also a norm among American doctors, increasingly emphasized in med school and by professional organizations, but it doesn't seem as strongly followed in practice. That may also be related to the American quasi-private system, which allows "doctor-shopping": if the first says no, you can always find another one who'll write the prescription (and some doctors even make a business out of a word-of-mouth reputation for being lax with prescriptions).
- DanBC 14y agoAnd weirdly, non-compliance with medication is roughly similar in the US (very expensive meds) and the UK (cheap meds, and 80% of people who need a prescription don't pay anything). There's not much change if you look at the severity of need for meds either - many organ transplants fail because people don't comply with the meds.
- Shish2k 14y ago> the worst that can happen is someone wastes their local physician's time 30 minutes at a time I've also heard a theory that this isn't a bad thing: IIRC in Japan there's a culture of going to the GP for every tiny little thing, which means that they have a massive number of 5-minute visits - but potentially serious illnesses are spotted and cured before they become serious, which means that overall health costs are lower and results are better.