5 ms·
From: http://live.theverge.com/apple-samsung-verdict-live/ http://live.theverge.com/apple-samsung-verdict-live/ "No across the board. Not a single [patent] pro
by aaronbrethorst 14y ago
From: http://live.theverge.com/apple-samsung-verdict-live/ http://live.theverge.com/apple-samsung-verdict-live/
"No across the board. Not a single [patent] proven invalid by Samsung."
that's big.
edit: "Damages from Apple to Samsung: zero." (edit2: oops, dumb typo)
- JoshTriplett 14y agoThe words "proven invalid" seem like a nice summary of what's so broken about this situation.
- tzs 14y agoHow so? Issued patents have already undergone an examination by a patent examiner, who found that the patent met the statutory requirements for validity, so it seems reasonable to me that someone wishing to overturn that decision should bear the burden of proof.
- mbell 14y agoYou have far more confidence in patent examiners than I do.
- btilly 14y agoPatent examiners do NOT conduct a very thorough review. The attitude is that it is better to get the patent out (for which they get paid) and let the courts sort out the bad ones. On this point I've been informed by patent lawyers that at trial something like 2/3 of patents will be found to be invalid. The problem is that nobody knows ahead of time which of those patents will be found to be invalid.
- veyron 14y agoI have a few friends working as examiners for the USPTO. The review is more thorough than you make it sound. The problem is that the procedures drive examiners to err on the side of approving the patent. If the patent is rejected, a lawyer can appeal and the SPEs get involved. In the appeal, it takes much more evidence from the examiner to demonstrate that the patent is invalid.
- gtirloni 14y agoThe USPTO is dumping shit on the judicial system and they are taking it. We're hoping they won't take that for very long but I doubt it. Courts will keep doing what they do, apply the law, even if the law sucks. Perhaps when the system is clogged and companies can't release a product without wasting lots of money going over useless patents.. then we'll see some change.
- josephlord 14y agoConceptually this has to be right. It would be better for everyone if it was clear that with occasional exceptions you could assume granted patents were valid. Unfortunately the examination process doesn't seem rigorous enough for this to be the case. This is where greater effort and strictness should be applied.
- manaskarekar 14y ago.. pile of poop? I haven't followed the case closely and leaving aside whether or not Samsung copied from Apple, we just all lost. Were there not a few prior art arguments and all that? Samsung couldn't invalidate any of those?! This is depressing.
- aaronbrethorst 14y agoDespite being an AAPL shareholder, I agree 100%.
- bane 14y agoIt's sickening. This case may significantly raise the bar for invalidating nonsense software patents in the future.
- alecdibble 14y agoPatent reform will most likely have to come out of the legislative process, not the judicial branch.
- r00fus 14y agoConsidering both parties are big whores to the corporate patent lobby, legislative process will likely only change things for the worse.
- scott_meade 14y agoDon't you mean $1.051 Billion?
- aaronbrethorst 14y agoI had the whole thing reversed. Thanks for pointing it out :)