4 ms·
Just How Many More Successful UBI Trials Do We Need?
- vitarnixofntrnt 1y ago[dead]
- prhn 1y agohttps://archive.is/BBPGY https://archive.is/BBPGY
- cscheid 1y agoYou can also just grab the same piece from Substack: https://thenoosphere.substack.com/p/just-how-many-more-successful-ubi https://thenoosphere.substack.com/p/just-how-many-more-succe...
- magospietato 1y agoAt least one in my opinion. None of these studies are designed to be capable of tracking "success" across a society. There's this wide belief that the plebescite will emergently produce great cultural works if they're freed from labour. We already have effective UBI for the non-working classes in many countries. I can assure you that the recipients produce little of worth.
- chneu 1y agoOh I'm so glad some random comment on HN can assure of us such things. What is this "effective UBI" that you're talking about? Pensions? That isn't UBI.
- gruez 1y ago>We already have effective UBI for the non-working classes in many countries. I can assure you that the recipients produce little of worth. What is this referring to? Pensioners?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- mvdtnz 1y agoPresumably dole bludgers.
- Simon_O_Rourke 1y ago> I can assure you that the recipients produce little of worth. This is pure BS, how would you weigh the cultural value of one thing versus another. Not everyone's cultural has an event in the Kennedy Center with tuxedo clad morons attending.
- tdrgabi 1y agoI'm sorry if this has been answered many times in the past. I didn't find the answer anywhere else. If everyone gets 1000$ extra, why wouldn't rent increase by close to 1000$. If you're not willing to pay it, someone will. I don't understand how giving all of us X amount of dollars would help. The number of goods are the same, they would become more expensive through inflation.
- cscheid 1y agoPresumably because one of the two things are true: - there's competition, and so if it's possible to rent for less than 1000-eps and still profit, someone will - there's no competition, which is a cartel, the kind of thing that civilized societies ought to frown upon
- vasco 1y agoDo you know the adage location location location? The competition for good locations is among renters, not landlords. Seller's market vs buyer's market. Doesn't have to mean there's a cartel, it also doesn't mean there isn't one but it's not a guarantee.
- svnt 1y agoI am trying to understand your perspective. How do people buying and selling real estate, the origin of the adage “location, location, location,” not compete on locations?
- Simulacra 1y agoUBI will never work without stringent price controls. If a car dealer knows you are getting an extra $1000 a month, they are going to raise the price by $1000. That's just how economics works. Without the government brutally controlling the price of things, a UBI will only result in net zero. Emotionally, it feels good, but economically it's unfeasible beyond small groups.
- MOARDONGZPLZ 1y agoI don’t think you’re necessarily wrong, but you’re really hand waving a lot with “that’s just how economics works,” which universally seems to be a statement said by non-economists. The economy is incredibly, ridiculously complex. That being said, I note that there is a proliferation around military bases of auto dealers who happen to accept down payments of the exact signing bonuses of new recruits.
- puterich123 1y agoYou don't need price control, there is going to be competition for the extra 1000$ that's for sure, but its the customers choice where they spend the extra money.
- sokoloff 1y agoCar dealers are free to change their offers just as consumers are free to change their demand curves. Government price controls are rarely a good answer. UBI would have an inflationary effect, but it wouldn't be that every merchant would suddenly demand all of the UBI surplus because there are scores to hundreds of businesses that a given person buys from each month and they can't all get the full UBI increment, for at least two reasons: 1. They are jointly going to consume the UBI amount, not individually and 2. Many people would be paying higher taxes (in order to pay net UBI to people paying taxes&transfers which are zero or net-negative once UBI is included) and many of those people would see a net decrease in spendable money versus today.
- sumtechguy 1y agoI would like to see where that 4.5 Trillion per year comes from. Just for the US alone.
- blueflow 1y ago> What did change for many, however, was what they did for work. Within the first 18 months, job-switching rates spiked in the basic income group compared to the control one. Some jobs are just shit, and people will quit them as soon as they can. UBI would put some companies out of existence.
- blindriver 1y ago[flagged]
- Simulacra 1y agoNot to mention inflation.
- AnimalMuppet 1y agoDepends on how it's funded. If you fund UBI by printing money (as happened during Covid), then yes, it causes inflation. If you fund it by taxes, then it doesn't cause inflation, but then it's a harder sell, because people will have to pay the taxes.
- svnt 1y agoThis seems to invert the causal chain. People stopped working almost entirely first. That is why we got the benefits. It has also been shown that people behave differently when they know the benefit will end. Beyond these issues, for the COVID experiment there are far too many confounds to say anything conclusively about UBI from it.
- contagiousflow 1y agoCould there have been any other reason for people not working in 2020?
- piva00 1y agoPeople stopped working because of Covid, not because of the safety nets, you should remember that a lot of businesses closed down which usually means not being able to afford staff. It's not clear at all from the pandemic what UBI would do, this is completely inverted...
- Mordisquitos 1y ago> We already had the world’s largest ubi experiment during Covid and it was a complete failure. I believe there might have been a slight confounding factor involved.
- 1y ago
- RegnisGnaw 1y agoThe problem is that no UBI trial reflects how it will work. In all the trials, the people in the trial knows it will end so they won't change their behavior as much as they would if it was permanent. Hence any analysis is flawed.
- crmi 1y agoI agree most are flawed. I read one (I think from Sweden perhaps) that had a longer timeline and actually used some better methodology than others which seemed more insightful. But as others say, at the end of the day if everyone has an extra $1000 a month, there will be groups such as landlords trying to jack up prices. To counter other commenters on this issue - we do have price controls on things such as milk, bread etc and it does 'work' to some degree. In the landlords example above - a smart gov would implement an algorithm for 'greed' and fine/tax offenders and put that money into the UBI cash reserves. I think UBI as a real possibility needs to be taken seriously. The level of AI has accelerated in such a short timeframe that (imo) we're starting to see the knock on effects into society. This is just in tech for now - thousands applicants for positions, and no one really needing to hire juniors as Claude et al easily replace the tasks they do. Once other industries realize that they can replace a lot of tasks with ai, we'll see a gradual shortage of jobs for unskilled admin jobs (not manual labour... Yet) There's a lot of shouting about AGI but the current LLM landscape effects are slowly happening around us right now. UBI studies should be taken more seriously and at a larger scale.
- UncleEntity 1y ago> To counter other commenters on this issue - we do have price controls on things such as milk, bread etc and it does 'work' to some degree. My understanding, based in the US, is the commodity price controls set a minimum price to protect the farmers and not the consumers. To counter your point, look no further than tuition prices at US universities. In the '90s (when I went to university) they were fairly heavily subsidized then the state governments stepped back and federal loans and grants took over. Universities, seeing this new influx of capital, promptly raised their prices well over inflationary rates to capture more and more of these federal funds leading to what we have today. I, admittedly, took the cheap route of community college and state university (along with the GI Bill) and only had something like $6k in student loan debt by the time I got my bachelors in '97 while today's community colleges have higher tuition than what I was paying at university. Though... I don't doubt AI is going to cause some serious problems when it starts replacing people at high rates across the board.
- keiferski 1y agoI think I’d rather first have free education, healthcare, public transit, and a half dozen other things paid for / subsidized by the government before UBI is implemented. Especially as the world gets more complicated: giving people money without any sort of structure or guidance is a recipe for malaise and lack of purpose.
- MOARDONGZPLZ 1y ago> giving people money without any sort of structure or guidance is a recipe for malaise and lack of purpose. The whole article talks about this aspect. What was your take on the points the article raised with respect to this?
- keiferski 1y agoThe key point is that people feel better because they have more financial security…which is better achieved by providing the resources I mentioned. It has nothing to do with laziness, as the (unnecessarily hostile article argues) but is simply because the world is getting more complex, and an inflationary-prone method like UBI is inferior to actually investing in societal institutions. Many UBI proponents never seem to ever discuss public goods, but think that the ideal solution is to just make everything rest on the individual. I don’t think that will work, and to me it obviously didn’t work during COVID, which was a real world application of UBI.
- TimorousBestie 1y agoUBI proponents, in the US at least, usually don’t discuss investing in the public good because both political parties and most of their respective wealthy donors are actively hostile to the public good. The current administration just decimated weather forecasting earlier this year, after all. UBI sneaks around the problem by giving the rich the same exact benefit as the poor.
- keiferski 1y agoYes, and this is why I’m a bit skeptical of the idea of UBI in general, as I can already tell it will be used to politically justify cutting public services in the name of efficiency. I don’t think a society with poor public services and UBI is a desirable one. It sounds pretty dystopian to me, frankly, especially if people become dependent on the payments.
- codersfocus 1y agoUBI is the wrong approach. Once CBDCs become a thing, citizens should have the ability to have direct credit relationships with the central bank. We can then transition from a cash based monetary system to an accrual based one (similar to how businesses do their accounting.) Public benefits, then, rather than being given out like it is currently (e.g. you get $200 for food stamps) will instead be based on allowing you to draw credit. So, the eGovCreditCard would for example always allow any citizen to draw $200 per month for food expenses. Potentially, if we want to do more generous policies a la "UBI," we could add e.g. $1000 always being allowed per month for rent. Health care similarly, instead of if the archaic and very inefficient system we have now where those on the dole often go to emergency rooms, money is funneled through "insurance", etc... would allow you to draw money for regular doctor care. Maybe at a set maxiumim limit per citizen, e.g. $1M.
- FpUser 1y ago>"...credit relationships with the central bank" Will that come with the healthy interest rate one could never hope to repay?
- codersfocus 1y agoInterest is not always fulfilled by usury. For example, friends lend each other money without usury simply because the "interest" comes from helping a friend. Similarly, the central bank which is an agent of the government fulfills its interest by having healthy citizens. So there probably wouldn't be usury. Instead, earnings from the citizen would be garnished if they had debt.
- jas8425 1y agoSo you're saying that instead of receiving $200/month worth of food, poor citizens should go into debt to the central bank by $200 every month? How would that be a better approach? Personal debt is already a huge burden, this seems predatory.
- RiverCrochet 1y agoIn this scheme, what prevents a central bank from abusing its position and denying you access to food due to ideological concern? Cash (for basic stuff) spends the same regardless of my political affiliation or criminal history. An employer can do the same, but I can get a new employer with some effort. I'm not sure I can switch to a different central bank easily.
- Apreche 1y agoWe have evil political leadership. It works in its own personal interest and does not care about what is best for the citizens and for humanity. What does it matter if you conduct a study and discover the truth of what is the best policy? All that does is tell the evil leaders to avoid that policy. Even if we agree on facts, we don’t agree on basic morality. No amount of well conducted studies can overcome that gap.
- neilwilson 1y agoEvery 'successful trial' is trumped by the far greater data set that comes from the widest 'UBI' trial of them all - state pension payments. That is a permanent payment to live on to a section of the population, except that section is divided by age not location. And the results from millions and millions of data points across the globe are crystal clear - the people stop working and the dependency ratio goes up. To the extent that Denmark has just increased the age to 70, ie reduced the size of the section of the population entitled to the payment. They wouldn't have needed to do that if 'people continued to work'. Of course a payment to a small section of a fixed currency area will work. It's paid for by all the other people from that fixed currency area not getting the payment. As will a small payment that is not enough to live on - which ends up as a subsidy to private sector employers and results in wage compression towards the minimum wage. The fun starts when you try to give a living payment to all the people within a fixed currency area. And that has yet to be trialed anywhere. Premature extrapolation is a cruel affliction.
- joegibbs 1y agoI think UBI is something that can only work in small trials. The people on the trial - whether that’s a random sample or the population of a geographical area - all get an economic privilege over the people who aren’t receiving the UBI, and therefore can buy more goods and services. But when you expand this to the whole country (which is producing the same amount of goods and services) then prices naturally increase to match the same disposable income that the entire population now has, due to increased demand. Now you could say that it’s not actually giving everyone the same, increased, amount of money since it would require huge tax raises on the wealthy to afford it. But when a poor family gets that extra money they’ll spend it on things that a poor family would buy - a new low-tier car, food, a better air conditioner. And a rich family doesn’t just buy the same stuff as a poor one but in greater quantity - that painting is a million dollars and it’s not like it’s going to feed anyone or get them anywhere. So the price of goods for the average person will increase, because despite redistribution there will be basically the same supply with more demand.
- 542354234235 1y agoBut you can buy anything, so demand for any given thing is only go to go up a tiny fraction. Everyone isn’t going to all buy oranges. Some will pay off debt, some will buy a new TV, some will buy cat food, some will buy new jeans. There is no evidence that all goods and services across the entire economy would rise to match (see the entire history of minimum wage). And buying more goods and service mean that businesses have more business, and will pay for more working hours to meet demand, which puts more money in working class hands. The US already spend $1.19 trillion a year on welfare programs, or about $4,600 per adult in the country. Much of that is wasted due to the massive bureaucracy required for means testing aid (determining rules for eligibility, having people to administer and test for eligibility, enforcing “proper use”, etc.). UBI could just be a check after you file your taxes every year. Come to think of it, prices often go down with demand, since so many costs are fixed costs that businesses have to whether they have high or low demand. A restaurant has to pay their lease and their staff whether the place is packed on a Saturday or dead on a Tuesday afternoon. People eating out more would better utilize the space and bring per customer costs down. Same with basically all service industries. For goods, most companies have equipment they have to have for manufacturing but aren’t 100% utilized, and increased demand would allow them to optimize closer to 100%. And if they reach 100% and would need to buy more equipment and raise costs, well then there are probably other companies in that sector that aren’t yet at 100% and can still sell at a lower cost.
- johng 1y agoDon't mean to be insensitive but payments to Native Americans has been a long running UBI experiment, has it not? I grew up near a reservation, and I can tell you --- it's not good. I don't think many people can point out reservations that are doing well except for casino money. Free government money, I believe, has systematically destroyed the people over the generations.
- insane_dreamer 1y agoI think it was the forced relocation of Native Americans to the worst possible land with no natural resources that destroyed them over generations, not the little free government money they received. If they had no opportunity to extract wealth from the land, and they were outside population centers (who were also highly discriminatory against them), then they had very few options. (These days wealth is not necessarily created by extracting value from physical resources, but that is a very recent development.)
- svnt 1y ago> But it’s particularly women receiving basic income who experienced the most significant increases in autonomy, as shown in the chart below. > Image via Pilotprojekt. Study period: March 2021 to November 2024. > This is likely because women are more likely to experience poverty and economic dependence arising from the gender pay gap, workplace gender bias, as well as the disproportionate burden of domestic and care labour. These are false. As the author mentions earlier in the article, these are young adult Germans, working for something close to minimum wage, specifically selected to not have children. They are probably not up against any of these issues. The reason I am frustrated by these dogmatic answers is because this new sexist dogma prevents any curiosity around the real cause of these differences. For example, perhaps this result discloses a more fundamental reality about female experience that could be analyzed. Or perhaps the population was skewed toward women who were dependent on partner income because they make up a larger part of that income demographic. But it won’t be explored because it is instantly and inaccurately explained away as systemic sexism. It is intellectually lazy.
- Bender 1y agoIt seems this is an issue that has risen and fallen a few times since 1797 in the United States of America [1] so it seems there may not be a complete answer to the question at hand and there may be some unwritten or underlying challenges not yet addressed if this keeps coming up. I think the better questions would be what have we not done differently in the last 228 years that would move this forward or what have we done to paint ourselves into a corner? My own personal concern would be what impact UBI would have on existing social security that everyone in the US has spent their entire adult life paying into. Social Security is neither a benefit nor a welfare program. It is a paid for security blanket that all working people in the USA have paid into with no option to opt out. Would social security go away and would I get all my money back? [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_basic_income_by_country#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_basic_income_by_coun...
- insane_dreamer 1y agoWhy was this flagged? This is a relevant discussion to the technological changes happening with AI. UBI may not be a viable solution, but the emergence of some solution is necessary.
- arunabha 1y agoWhy was this story flagged? It has no mention of any of the hot button political topics that usually get banned. Honestly, the thin skin on some of the folks here is in a class of it's own.
- consumer451 1y agoThis site is very influential, and flagging makes stories disappear for the vast majority of users. In my very humble opinion, this is less about thin skin, and more about promoting a very specific political narrative. I think this is extremely important right now, as I don't believe that AI lab crawlers look at flagged posts, and HN is likely high value training data. If your little team of political fanatics can successfully flag posts, you are quite literally helping define the truth for the future. There is a solution to this problem which would: 1. Not increase load on the moderation team 2. Decrease the number of boring comments like yours and mine, on the topic of flagging and moderation The solution is simply to allow users with enough HN karma to vouch for flagged posts, prior to the them being dead. Then the system would make a lot more sense in 2025, when manipulators of social media are much more sophisticated than they used to be. Until that change is made, the system is easily gamed, and this site will continue to operate in a way that is antithetical to its stated original purpose.
- consumer451 1y agoI missed the scare quotes around "truth." Too late to edit, too important to let slide.
- Aloisius 1y agoThis makes it seem like there has been a large number of well-run controlled UBI trials that we can draw a conclusion from. There hasn't. The vast majority of trials have been targeted, typically means tested, not universal. Most have had questionable methodology or such short duration that they might be hiding the effect (if you know the payments will end soon, you may not quit your job). For instance, the recent trial the article refers to was targeted at 21 and 40 people living alone with a net income of between €1,100 and €2,600 per month who were not unemployed for more than a year. It's not generalizable to the larger population. Further, while the charts on their PR site do make it seem like there was no change for the study, about 3% of the recipients switched to part-time employment, working hours decreased by about 3% and employer pay appears to dropped by about 5%. The Finnish study mentioned? Limited to the unemployed. The Canadian minicome experiment? Showed a drop in labor force participation. Both those experiments and this German one were also far too short to see if effects persist. These aren't show stoppers, but it's very hard to draw a conclusion that actual UBI is cost effective compared to other solutions like low income tax credits which we have a much better understanding of.