2 ms·
The underlying publication http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2115203 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2115203 reported on i
by tokenadult 14y ago
The underlying publication
http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2115203 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2115203
reported on in the Ars Technica article kindly submitted here is a student law review article, specifically a "note," a classic form of first publication for innovative legal reasoning on a novel issue. I can report, as a one-time law student who was a member of my law school's law review, that every law student's dream (if the law student has a scholarly bent) is to publish a law review article that in turn is taken up by an appellate court and then cited as the basis for the court's opinion. That happened to one of my classmates--his comment on a case in the Minnesota Law Review was cited by the United States Supreme Court in a decision that agreed with his reasoning.
So the author here interviewed by Ars Technica is young, early in his career, and speculating on what COULD happen or opinionating about what OUGHT TO happen. He hopes to persuade a court that his reasoning is correct. But the article is not a sure-fire prediction of how any court or any law enforcement agency will respond to Bitcoins. The Bitcoin experiment has some novel features, and litigation related to it will probably produce new court case holdings (at a minimum) and possibly new statutes as well. "The life of the law has not been logic; it has been experience." Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr., The Common Law (1881), page 1.
As I have written before, perhaps the greatest contribution the Bitcoin experiment will make to humankind is to teach you and me and our neighbors more about the realities of economics. Here we see that the Bitcoin experiment will also teach us more about the reality of the law (in several different countries of the world, and how law from one country can be applied to transactions that involve another country.) Where there is legal uncertainty, there is transaction risk, and persons using Bitcoins to engage in commercial transactions will have to figure out how to price that risk.
AFTER EDIT: There is an interesting idea in another comment submitted before mine.
I would really like to see a full-frontal assault by a first-world government on Bitcoin, just to test how resilient it is to such an attack
I hazard the guess that significant resources have already been devoted by the National Security Agency in the United States and by comparable government agencies in other countries to figure out multiple attacks surfaces in the Bitcoin ecosystem. It may be that those attacks will not be publicized by any government, but held in reserve for a time of need. Perhaps operatives of this or that government can better conduct covert operations with the help of Bitcoins, in one case, while perhaps they can disrupt the activities of a hostile government by disrupting Bitcoins, in another case. I'm sure there are plenty of interested onlookers analyzing the Bitcoin experiment.