3 ms·
There is censorship but not in the traditional sense. Submissions and comments are down-voted and flagged based on the beliefs and world views of the majority
by Bender 1y ago
There is censorship but not in the traditional sense. Submissions and comments are down-voted and flagged based on the beliefs and world views of the majority HN crowd and this creates an echo chamber of sorts based on the majority demographics of HN and has little to do with community guidelines of which are rarely followed. For example is something is political yet aligns with the majority strong political views it will be upvoted.
People that do not live within the accepted majority world views will feel isolated, ostracized, ignored and censored. As an example I self-censor 98% of my views here. Instead I share them on smaller semi-private sites that research and discuss this site and a handful of other sites. In my opinion that is a decent path to balance ones experience and help avoid being gas-lit and face smacked. One can create their own private or semi-private bubbles and onboard people that feel ostracized and censored. Some use Mastodon for this. Some create their own self hosted chat and forum servers. I know, more echo chambers. People can build their identity on their own servers and use sites like Facebook, Tweeter, Reddit, HN as a public disposable cache to share specific thoughts and then discuss the responses on their own servers. People can choose whether or not to permit search engines, AI and other bots on their own servers. People can also permit or block any topics they wish on their own servers.
I think it can good for ones mental health to not try to fit entirely into a majority demographic especially when so many cultures are trying to mold themselves to fit a shared community. I think this is especially important when sites like HN become popular enough to attract paid agent provocateurs and state level actors along with their victims that either consciously or sub-consciously attempt to keep narratives on a specific and popular "acceptable" path.
Hypothetically speaking in Minecraft a worse scenario be malicious UI front-ends to HN that could subtly manipulate votes and flags using legitimate accounts without their knowledge given the majority here are on cell phones. Even dang would not detect this behavior. This is just one reason why people should review their flag and vote history and why phone apps should be de-compiled rather than just trusting source code. One should not trust sandbox analyzers as the code can detect what it is running on. This is one reason I like to MitM my own traffic.