5 ms·
I would love to find a fundamental flaw in this reasoning, but I can't. It was, I guess, naïve to not expect exponential technological progress not to reflect i
by rbanffy 1y ago
I would love to find a fundamental flaw in this reasoning, but I can't. It was, I guess, naïve to not expect exponential technological progress not to reflect in the political structures. The world is changing, and changing very quickly.
The article doesn't get much into what can be the next step - fully autonomous drones that travel by night, charge by day, and find a target by themselves. A bit like landmines, with a shorter half-life, but highly mobile and intelligent enough.
- walrus01 1y agoHow would they charge? The watt hours needed to fly a medium sized VTOL uav of any type for any reasonable amount of time can't be collected by the size of pv panel that can be reasonably carried by the same craft. Not unless it sits still for a week in a sunny spot.
- hackernewds 1y agothey don't need to be constantly flying. as long as work is not done, there isn't much energy being burned. and most of the energy burned is not with the rotors
- walrus01 1y agoIf you mean something that is put in place with a full charge and just uses PV to trickle charge keep itself awake and alive, sure. I was thinking a scenario where something is dropped off, flies 10-15 minutes and lands somewhere to await a target. It would need many days to charge before it could fly again for ten minutes.
- mcphage 1y ago> Not unless it sits still for a week in a sunny spot. Isn’t that the answer to your question, then?
- walrus01 1y agoKind of, but it seems such things would be obvious and exposed to being easily located if just sitting around idle in sunlight collecting charge. Not exactly like a landmine.
- snickerdoodle12 1y agoA drone sitting on a roof where no one ever goes isn't exactly obvious
- dotancohen 1y agoWill militaries or civilian operators soon operate fleets of drones that scan rooftops and other exposed sunny locations for charging drones?
- ben_w 1y agoEven if they do, can still be camouflaged as e.g. a bunch of leaves, or other detritus.
- dotancohen 1y agoSounds like an arms race to me. In any case, the solar cells should still be visible.
- spwa4 1y ago(solar cells can be non-reflective black, the reflectivity is just to double-dip the suns rays)
- dotancohen 1y agoI had no idea, thank you! Such cells would be half as efficient I suppose, so would need to be twice as large and probably at least twice as heavy. I wonder how that might affect design and payload constraints as it scales.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- strtok 1y agoFind an outdoor wall socket?
- namrog84 1y agoWhat about those drones that charge via power lines?
- jeremyjacob 1y agoFor the curious: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C-uekD6VTIQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C-uekD6VTIQ
- eszed 1y ago> sits still for a week Why would that be an issue? Planners have to think further ahead, but the threat is only marginally decreased.
- BurningFrog 1y agoYou can have other drones swap in fully charged batteries when needed.
- ldom22 1y agoSo called “vampire drones” have the capacity to identify electrical transmission lines and leech off them
- rcruzeiro 1y agoThis is still speculative tech, no?
- rbanffy 1y agoI bet it won't by next month or so.
- BriggyDwiggs42 1y agoI remember seeing a demo. It doesn’t honestly seem very hard.
- rcruzeiro 1y agoI don’t think induction alone would cut it. Having the drone make contact and step down hundreds of kilovolts seem pretty hard to me. Plus the EM interference on the drones systems would be a challenge under the best circumstances.
- snickerdoodle12 1y agoDrop a charging pad on a roof somewhere
- beefnugs 1y agopower lines are AC, same tech as wireless phone charging, you just need to coil wires properly
- ben_w 1y ago> The watt hours needed to fly a medium sized VTOL uav of any type for any reasonable amount of time can't be collected by the size of pv panel that can be reasonably carried by the same craft. Drones aren't limited to quadcopters. > Not unless it sits still for a week in a sunny spot. So do that? Humans are persistance predators, or so I'm told. We didn't domesticate horses by running faster than them, but by because they had to rest, and when they stopped we'd catch up, and then they'd run again, a cycle that repeated until they couldn't run any more. But these days, we humans are no longer nomadic: we live in predictable homes, and most of us who work do so at predictable locations. A drone that takes a year to get to one of us? We could outrace it, or shoot it down… but only if we know it's there.
- rbanffy 1y ago> A drone that takes a year to get to one of us? We could outrace it, or shoot it down… but only if we know it's there. As someone in the IRA once told Margaret Thatcher, "We only need to be lucky once. You need to be lucky every time".
- madaxe_again 1y agoThe reasoning is sound, but incomplete. The reality is that a majority of people are simply too lazy to do this stuff. We are talking about populations that call a guy to come change a lightbulb - rigging a drone with explosives, figuring out control at a distance - this is beyond the scope of capability for the majority of malcontents. Most would-be pipe bombers end up nabbed at the point where they try to purchase a charge for their devices. Same deal here. Yes, there’s scope for a small number of bad actors to wreak havoc, but the thing about small numbers is that they are readily dealt with through existing law enforcement frameworks. On a state level, war is war, and arms races are never static. You send flotillas of drones? I manufacture flotillas of counter-drone drones. Yes, there is an asymmetry currently, but just as air supremacy was once seen as “well, this makes war practically impossible”, and became just another battleground, the same will happen here.
- glitchc 1y agoIt only takes a few dedicated true believers to fundamentally change how society works. 9/11 only happened once.
- rbanffy 1y agoI often have to point out they won. They wanted to change the US, and the country is, today, almost unrecognizable. Patriot Act, FISA courts, and now illegal deportations and an alliance with Russia at the top level.
- madaxe_again 1y agoThe US wanted to change. PNAC spelled out almost all of what happened after 9/11, before 9/11, and it was a gift to the security industrial complex hawks. They literally said in their report that a Pearl Harbor type event would likely be necessary: “Further, the process of transformation… is likely to be a long one, absent some catastrophic and catalyzing event—like a new Pearl Harbor.”
- sieabahlpark 1y ago[dead]
- idiotsecant 1y agoCharging isn't needed or even very helpful. It's a million times easier, cheaper, and more efficient to just drop a few cheap drones in areas your target might go, then have someone monitoring remotely activate them at the appropriate time.
- NewJazz 1y agoDropping the drones is an opportunity for surveillance to catch you via license plate, gait, et cetera.
- ben_w 1y agoThe range of even an inefficient quadcopter drone being what it is, if your target is somewhere in San Diego then "in the area" of your target includes bits of Mexico. (For competently designed fixed-wing drones, Canada is "in the area" of San Diego).
- justsomehnguy 1y agoDrone dropping drone doesn't have a license plate nor gait.
- NewJazz 1y agoYeah guess you could have a self driving semi-truck (full of quadrocopters) programmed to flip its plate and truck on.
- idiotsecant 1y agoOk, I guess I will drop it in some unimportant ditch 20 miles away at 1am on a nondescript stolen bicycle. That cost me about 1% of the cost of this hypothetical recharging hunter-killer terminator.
- snickerbockers 1y agoHe failed to consider that small actors won't have a monopoly on drones. The best counter is for the defending authority to have even more drones on constant patrol looking out for any drones that don't satisfy whatever the criteria is for a "good drone". This brings its own host of problems because the people have to become accustomed to constantly being surveilled by a swarm of government drones with the ability to assassinate anybody at any moment and nobody to hold criminally accountable, but my point is that this technology is available to the defenders too.
- ffsm8 1y agoI am not sure if you realize how hopelessly impossible that is. You're aware that the (to my knowledge, which is entirely based on documentaries) primary way drugs are shipped to the USA are drones nowadays? Some via air, some underwater etc There is just to much area and drones are tiny. It's infeasible to track them without spending insane amounts of money (and creating a total surveillance state as a by-product)
- snickerbockers 1y ago>I am not sure if you realize how hopelessly impossible that is. It's not impossible if it's predominantly automated. You have swarms of "police drones" on patrol actively scanning for other drones and when they see one that they don't like (some sort of signed certificate that authenticates the owner and their license) they shoot it down. It works as long as the "police drones" are plentiful and well dispersed to the point of maintaining dominance. >and creating a total surveillance state as a by-product that's what i meant when i said this brings its own host of problems. My point's not that our way of life will continue unabated my point is that this particular force multiplier goes both ways, and the defense will be a sort of "drone police corps". The biggest problems will be whatever happens outside of the "margin of error" (ie accidentally shooting down the wrong drones, civilians caught in crossfire, people hurt by falling debris) and the general end of any notion of privacy (not that America isn't already going in that direction anyways).
- 1y ago
- spwa4 1y agoWell, how about this: there is a lot of knowledge that if it were publicly available in a useful form, could do incredible amounts of damage. From viral DNA/RNA sequences to the exact procedure to get a fission cascade. The exact chemical formula to a lot of different nasty concoctions, or in some cases just the fact that particular things even exist (e.g. you don't need radioactive material to create radiation poisoning ... even mass radiation poisoning) Advanced knowledge has only once been used in a terror attack, and not very effectively. These types of drone would need to collect a lot of not-so-easy-to-get knowledge. You'd need weapons, mechanical design, electronic fuses ... but mostly an AI good enough to make decisions on their own. And frankly, with good AI you could do a lot more damage than this without ever killing anyone.
- Gigachad 1y agoFeel like there is something comforting that the state of things hasn’t been bigger bombs, more destruction, and more harm, but instead became highly targeted attacks that massively cripple a countries military infrastructure with almost no harm to anyone else.
- consumer451 1y agoTechnology advancing faster than society has always seemed like the most likely "great filter" to me. The recent advancements in the normalization of hate and suffering, while tech keeps advancing, makes me feel like I have Cassandra Syndrome, aka, I feel like I am taking crazy pills.
- ddq 1y agoYes, a lot of us feel the same way. It's clear to me the next step is for us to start coming together, grouping up and sharing our ideas. I read on the internet every single day people expressing these feelings and for some reason we remain impotent and helpless when we could be uniting and inventing. Where is the will? I can only hope it's simply happening outside the scope of my vision. But it really needs to be happening faster. We are coming face to face with the concept of exponential growth itself. Humanity versus the feedback loop. And it will take coordinated genius to best such a naturally powerful foe.
- consumer451 1y ago> Where is the will? The memory of what happens when hate takes control died, literally. The people who survived WWII are mostly gone. Now, without their knowledge, without their shame, we are swinging back to the other side. My concern is that the swing happens to go the wrong way, at the same time that we happen to have an incredibly asymmetric ability to destroy each other. We might be 1 or 5 swings away from that being a truly end-of-times situation. At this point, that seems to me like it would be when a pissed off kid, whose parents were killed as "collateral damage," could create a novel pathogen with only a $10k lab. If tech and hate keeps advancing at the current rate, what is that, 100 years max? We really need to get our shit together.
- aaron695 1y ago[dead]