3 ms·
The SpaceX model is ideal for low Earth orbit where technology and markets are mature, I think it has trouble at Mars if not the Moon. SpaceX can launch a lar
by PaulHoule 1y ago
The SpaceX model is ideal for low Earth orbit where technology and markets are mature, I think it has trouble at Mars if not the Moon.
SpaceX can launch a large number of Starships to LEO and have them fail because the turnaround time is a few weeks. You only get to go to Mars once every two years or so, so if it takes 10 attempts, that is 20 years. SpaceX's control system is completely remote control from mission control: they'd need to build something entirely different to work around Mars.
Right now Starship does not have an appealing lunar story. The baseline scenario that astronauts climb out of Orion, spacewalk to a Starship, then go to the moon on a Starship carries about the same payload as the original LEM with a much larger and taller vehicle that is likely to tip over or have its nozzles broken by rocks. It would be cool if you could land and return the full 100 tons but to do that you need to refuel. Some combination of:
-- land 100 tons and turn the Starship into storage tanks/living space/a workshop
-- using some of those 1-way journeys to stash fuel for return trips
-- producing O2 from rocks but using CH4 from Earth
-- producing O2 from electrolysis of polar ice
seem possible with various levels of risk. A H2 + O2 rocket could be fueled entirely from polar ice but not Starship. It's not so clear if it makes sense to use polar ice to make propellants or if it makes sense to use it to accumulate a stock of volatiles that are recycled on a permanent settlement.
- notahacker 1y agoI think the "SpaceX model doesn't fill the gap" issue is bigger than just not using ISRU-derived peroxide rockets; that seems like the sort of thing they'd be really good at (even though the people I know working on that problem that are Europeans with university affiliations, not SpaceX employees) if they determined it was a mission requirement. It's more that propulsion is a pretty small part of the overall mission, which involves everything from portable handheld devices to astronaut physiology to in-space manufacturing if you want to build actual bases. Are there SpaceX skunkworks projects looking at that sort of thing? Probably, they've got money and space enthusiasts and a boss that doesn't mind that sort of thinking. Are they funding that sort of exploratory research to the level NASA or ESA or research institutes? Nope, and I'm not sure the "vertically integrate everything" model that's served them so well as a commercial business doing repeatable things in LEO is ideally set up to collaborate with the people that do either.
- PaulHoule 1y agoMy analysis of Mars colonization is that it is 99% about the people there being able to manufacture 99% of what they need with as small a population as possible and 1% about getting the people there. If 1 person can support themselves the effort almost certainly succeeds, if it takes a city of 10,000,000 it almost certainly fails. A deep space colony might be able to build megastructures such as solar sails, energy converters and shades and deliver them to places like the Earth-Sun L1 point. You can't make anything on Mars that can't be made on Earth and it's implausible you could bring anything back from Mars that couldn't be made much more cheaply here. You're left with the political situation of Asimov's short story The Martian Way, where a Mars colony is caught off from Earth and forced to become self-sufficient. Even if Earth was interested in subsidizing a Mars colony for the time being, the Martian colonists would want to develop self-sufficiently as quickly as possible. People who look seriously into the problem of space colonization tend to follow the same tracks that Eric Drexler did. His molecular assembler and nanomill concepts have not aged well but I'd imagine that something functionally similar could be pieced together out of 3-d printing, fermentation, genetic engineering, flow chemistry and other pieces. Musk's talk of sending 1,000,000 and neglect of "advanced manufacturing" makes his plans seem unrealistic to me.
- notahacker 1y agoYeah, I think I agree with pretty much all of that. And again to the extent the assembler stuff is feasible you have to look at who's doing it. Well the 3D printing in space demos took place on the ISS, with the first being a NASA-incubated, SBIR-funded startup and the second being an ESA initiative involving iconic oldspace company Airbus and some academics. It's certainly not as profitable as owning most of the world's launch capacity and not coincidentally most of the world's satellites, but the people that are doing the low level, high risk stuff are coming out of research institutes and living off agency funding....
- PaulHoule 1y agoAs I see it, "Advanced Manufacturing" is important here on Earth, not so much from the self-sufficiency angle (though it's an interesting question for countries like Argentina) but from the viewpoint of carbon balance.
- ge96 1y agostarship orbits the moon, they build those rail launchers that launch non-organic payload from moon surface to moon orbit
- PaulHoule 1y agoThose at least look better than they did in the Moon is a Harsh Mistress and O'Neill periods. The US military has tested 2.5 km/s railguns, it takes just 3.5 km/s to get to the Earth-Moon L1 point. If the Starship could really land 100 tonnes, it could land one of those exclusive of power supply... It's not some huge thing that looks like a kilometer-scale maglev anymore. I could picture one of those things moving say 80 tons/day of bulk material if it wasn't for the problem of the barrel getting trashed in less than one day. The design of the catcher is a tough problem though and still unsolved. There are lots of answers that aren't so attractive, such as fielding a big piece of styrofoam that you'll eventually melt and reform or some kind of thing that throws a capture device with a cable attached at passing projectiles.
- numpad0 1y agoRailguns are cool, but I think superconductor based maglevs are more viable. They don't need any sophisticated controls for neither acceleration nor floatation. Hypothetically you can just fuel a cargo sled with LN2 to a fill line, give it a nudge, and it'll start rolling without needing any sophisticated computerized controls. Floatation is handled by pair of upoer and lower passive guide coils on the wall, just induction current can keep vehicles vertically centered. Propulsion is handled by constant alternating current on alternatingly pointed coils. Speed can be modulated between zero to max by merely modulating strength, not frequency or phase, of vehicle side magnets. It does need a lot of materials to build one with 3.5km/s max speed on the Moon, though, so a robotic Lunar foundry might have to be built first. But once that goes up... space megaprojects will be free, and launches from planetary surfaces will mainly be used for humans or valuable items.
- PaulHoule 1y agoI think you are right that it looks more like a coilgun than the railgun. I hope it can be scaled to the size of the Paris gun because it could be sent in parts and could point high in the sky at the right spot. Enough material could be sent to the earth-moon L1 and L2 points to make a small artificial asteroid, radiation shields, etc.
- philwelch 1y ago> The SpaceX model is ideal for low Earth orbit where technology and markets are mature, I think it has trouble at Mars if not the Moon. How much of that technology and market has SpaceX themselves developed over the past 15 years though? They had to invent Starlink to grow the commercial launch market past the point of saturation. And while Starship isn't particularly well designed to make round trips to and from the Moon, it can deliver an enormous amount of cargo in a one way trip, plus the ship itself can be repurposed. So if you're going to build a moon base it's a good option.
- PaulHoule 1y agoOn some level Starlink was something new, but it is something new that serviced a market that everyone knew was there. It went from announcement to commercial service in 5 years.
- philwelch 1y agoStarlink isn’t the impressive part. The impressive part is that by solving reusability, SpaceX instantly outscaled the existing launch market and was forced to find ways to generate their own demand in order to maintain growth. Which goes to show that LEO is nowhere close to a mature market; in mature markets, companies don’t have to resort to these elaborate forms of vertical integration the way they do when they invent something that fundamentally changes the market faster than anyone else can adapt. By way of analogy, radio is a mature market. Maybe a little more than mature, to be honest, it’s well past its prime. In the early days of radios, you know who ran the radio stations? The companies that made radios! Because who’s going to buy a radio without a radio station to listen to? It took years for people to figure out the radio advertising business model but RCA wasn’t willing to wait that long so they just operated a bunch of radio stations as a cost center to encourage people to buy more radios. But then the market matured and the roles of “broadcasting” and “manufacturing home radios” diverged into different companies.
- verzali 1y agoSpaceX didn't invent Starlink, they just had the capital to get past the initial high expediture beforw the project becomes viable. Many other people attempted to build a Starlink-like constellation before SpaceX. They failed because they couldn't fund the satellite rollout phase.