4 ms·
Covid killed 1,193,165 people in the USA alone. Do you think the lockdowns failed to prevent that number from being significantly larger?
by simonw 1y ago
Covid killed 1,193,165 people in the USA alone. Do you think the lockdowns failed to prevent that number from being significantly larger?
- tonymet 1y agodiagnostic error
- thfuran 1y agoWhat?
- tonymet 1y agothat figure
- thfuran 1y agoOn what basis do you make that conclusion?
- tonymet 1y agoflimsy definition of “covid death”. Questionable & in-flux PCR testing, Shoddy antibody tests (calibrated against PCR), Dubious definition of “covid disease”, e.g. “you can have covid and be asymptomatic”. 7 digits of precision. How many digits died with the actual disease, from the actual disease, or coincidentally with an antibody test? A few million elderly die each year regardless. Re-classifying a large share as “covid” is a plausible accounting mistake.
- thfuran 1y agoThe rest of the spitballing aside, your last point didn't hold up. Perhaps unsurprisingly, organizations like the CDC spend a lot of effort trying to get good estimates of mortality of various causes and have thought about this sort of thing before: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid19/excess_deaths.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid19/excess_deaths.htm
- tonymet 1y agoon a typical year there are 300,000 deaths due to medical error. If you tell 30% of the population to go to the hospital unnecessarily you can hit 1M excess deaths very easily. The definition of the disease and disease mortality were nebulous. If someone goes to the hospital in panic because of a cough, they are ventilated and die -- was that from covid?
- roenxi 1y agoThat seems quite possible; I haven't seen anyone waving evidence around that the US lockdowns helped. Have you got any figures estimating what order of magnitude difference they made?
- simonw 1y agoHere's a recent one (looks like it's gone through peer review now, there were earlier preprints that hadn't floating around): https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40468026/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40468026/ The PDF is linked from https://www.researchgate.net/publication/387051732_Estimating_The_Impact_of_Public_Health_Interventions_on_COVID_Mortality_in_The_United_States_Using_Reductions_in_Influenza_Mortality_as_an_Indicator_Of_Non-Pharmaceutical_Infection_Control https://www.researchgate.net/publication/387051732_Estimatin... > This study uses influenza mortality reduction (IMR) as an indicator of the aggregate effect of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPI's) on the spread of respiratory infections to assess their impact on COVID mortality. [...] A counterfactual model of no NPI's suggests they prevented 850,000 COVID related deaths in the United States.
- roenxi 1y ago1) That is NPIs, it doesn't break out the impact of lockdowns. There was a big drop in IMR across all the states, even though it seems rather unlikely that all states followed the same policies. 2) If we attribute all the change to lockdowns that would suggest the lockdowns were a minor disaster. If 32% of the population didn't get vaccinated - that is basically a 3rd of the population locked down for nothing, up to around 50% in some areas. One obvious issue is lockdowns are always competing against people voluntarily choosing to stay home and isolate themselves and adopting special procedures in nursing homes. The high correlations between vaccination rate and IMR suggest it might actually just be picking up how concerned communities were with COVID and how much effort they put into protecting themselves. It is an interesting study though, I like the approach.
- tonymet 1y agowouldn't this also be part of the AI catastrophe?