3 ms·
Reading the comments here it is painfully clear just how much Hacker news has changed (and definately not for the better). Once PG wrote an essay on exactly th
by tomjen3 14y ago
Reading the comments here it is painfully clear just how much Hacker news has changed (and definately not for the better).
Once PG wrote an essay on exactly this topic (http://paulgraham.com/wealth.html http://paulgraham.com/wealth.html) in which he argues convincingly that wealth inequality isn't really relevant because while we can expect that technology will act as a lever to make the absolute differences bigger than they are now, at the same time everybodies relative wealth will get closer and closer together.
And that is true. I know a guy who has a higher networth than I is likely to ever earn. He has a Masaretti, a plane, a nice house, etc.
But while the absolute differences between the two of us are great, the relative differences between us are small, compared to what they would have been historically -- after all we eat mostly the same food and while he can fly first class that is not going to get him to the destination much faster than me in coach.
200 years ago, he would have been the owner of a corporation, making a ton of money and living in a that would look like the set of Downton Abbey. I would have been living in some shack somewhere with no running water and and outhouse that was likely to be frozen in the winter.
So yeah, I don't give much of a crap about income difference and I don't buy that the middle class is bankcroupt due to the very rich (1% isn't very rich, btw). I believe the middle class wealth has grown slightly less than it used to because it hasn't produced as much as it used to.
Remember wealth is not a static quantity, it can be created and it can be destroyed. It is created only when people produce and as far as I can see, the middle class has not produced very much at all.
Of course the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan have a great deal to do with the destruction of wealth too, as have the bloated government system.
- ender7 14y agoThat is not the point of the article. You're talking about quality-of-life, while the study is talking about the health of the national economy: "The reason the decline of the middle class is important is not just about fairness. It's about the health of the economy as a whole." So, even a hypothetical world where even the poorest person in the country has a stellar quality of life would be bad if there was no middle class, specifically because the economy would suffer. Corporate revenue would be hobbled, and so would R&D. You'd get a country of happy people that didn't do anything. A few decades of this and it would be quickly left behind by the rest of the developed world. Those few citizens who are motivated to actually do things (like found companies) will move to countries with economies that can actually support commerce.
- douglasisshiny 14y agoI don't agree on some points here. I don't think anyone reasonable is claiming that the 1% is bankrupting the middle class. The observation is that middle class earnings have been stagnant and even deteriorating over the last decades. That's just an observation. You claim that the middle class hasn't produced. What exactly do you mean by that? If you mean that workers for large (and small) corporations haven't produced as well as they have historically, then why are corporations making record profits? Certainly a small number of executives can't be making the difference. How have the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan destroyed wealth? On the contrary, U.S. defense contractors (some very large employers) have made quite a bit of money as the defense budget has swelled. Hence the outcry over sequestration.
- tomjen3 14y agoI will address the last paragraph first, because it is such a common and extreemly dangerous misunderstanding. Every tank made represent a cost, indeed quite a high cost, as does every other piece of military technology. The money that has been spent on a tank cannot be spent e.g bridge repair in Minesota or even a nice vecation for you. Yes the defence contractors have been hansomely paid for their services, and yes they have properly hired somebody who would not have had such a good job. But have they made wealth? No. On the contrary. An engineer who works for a defence contractor cannot at the some time make a more fuel efficent car engine or a cheaper high speed train/monorail. The cost of the wars is not just the money and lives that goes in to it, but also what is not created. What could have been. As for haven't produced I should perhaps be clearer -- if you expect that your standard of living should increase then what you can buy with your income needs to increase too (either things have to become cheaper or you have to make more money). That has not happened, and while I am not an economist it would appear likely that it is because most of the jobs the middle class have today is make work jobs (too many manager jobs, too many useless compliant jobs, too many lawyers, etc) jobs that, like our defences contractors above don't actually produce value. Add to that the housing bubble and the higher cost of colleges (both fueled by the idea that no price is too dear for either and cheap credit) and a lot of people can appear to be productive for a long time before the mirage is revealed. As for the record profits, that I suspect are mostly lagging indicators (e.g. RND being brought to the market, with nothing new in the pipeline) and a lot cheaper tech.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- vannevar 14y agoThe flaw in this argument lies in this sentence: ...after all we eat mostly the same food and while he can fly first class that is not going to get him to the destination much faster than me in coach. What makes you think that someone who is unemployed or making minimum wage, can afford to fly coach? Contrary to your implication, there are in fact people in the US living in shacks without running water, and their number is growing. Wealth is created and destroyed, but it is a fact that the upper incomes have been growing faster than overall economic growth for many years now, while the middle and lower income levels have stagnated or regressed. We can argue why that is so, but it's clear that the top 1% are consuming a greater and greater share of an economic pie that is not keeping pace with their accumulation of wealth.
- tomjen3 14y agoAnd those people are not in the middle class, and are therefore not relevant for an article about the middle class.
- vannevar 14y agoThe point of the comment was that relative differences are decreasing, and the comment used anecdotal evidence to support the contention. I pointed out that the anecdotal observation was flawed. The definition of middle class itself is relative, and the current trend is downward toward poverty rather than upward toward business class.
- kitsune_ 14y agoThe middle class is virtually bankrupt. This "relative wealth" you speak on is an illusion, because it is based on debt. Debt enslaves you. The true wealth of the top 1% is their freedom. One miss-step, disease, misfortune, and you will cherish the power of money. You are standing on a thin, melting ice sheet and below is the abyss. When you are below the poverty line, you will realize that this relative difference in wealth is not relative but absolute.