4 ms·
Some of it is the rapid progress in fundamental research. If in Q2 2025 a company like AAPL or AMZN decides to invest in a current top of the line neural netwo
by PaulHoule 1y ago
Some of it is the rapid progress in fundamental research.
If in Q2 2025 a company like AAPL or AMZN decides to invest in a current top of the line neural network model and spend 18 months to develop a product, whatever they develop might be obsolete when it is released. Holds for OpenAI or any incumbent -- first mover advantage may be neutralized.
Secondly there are a lot of problems in ambient computing. Back in the early 00's I often talked with an HCI expert about ideas like "your phone (pre-iPhone) could know it is in your backpack" or "a camera captures an image of your whole room reflected in a mirror and 'knows what is going on'" and she would usually point out missing context that would make something more like a corporation that gives bad customer service than a loyal butler. Some of Alexa's problems are fundamental to what it is trying to do and won't improve with better models, some of why AMZN gave up on Alexa at one point.
- mrweasel 1y agoIt's also not entirely clear what Alexa was suppose to do, nor Siri for that matter. Being a personal digital assistant turned out to be much less useful than many imagined and being a voice controlled Bluetooth speaker is mostly a gimmick outside the car or kitchen. That's not to say that Alexa and others can't be useful, but just not to enough people that it justifies the R&D cost.
- taeric 1y agoI continue to be baffled that they are going to cannibalize the "voice controlled radio and timer" market in the chase of some "magic assistant" one. It would be one thing if they were just adding extra "smart home" features to connect new terminals. I can see benefit of some of the smart screen calendar and weather things. No, they seem dead set to completely kill what they had.
- cle 1y agoMeanwhile multiple non-technical people that I know pay $20/mo to OpenAI and have long, verbal conversations with ChatGPT every day to learn new things, explore ideas, reflect, etc. These are obviously what voice assistants should do, the research was just not there. Amazon was unwilling to invest in the long-term research to make that a reality, because of a myopic focus on easy-to-measure KPIs. After pouring billions of dollars into Alexa. A catastrophic management failure.
- mrweasel 1y agoAre they talking to ChatGPT, or are they typing? More and more we're seeing that user don't even want to use a phone for phone calls, so maybe a voice interface really isn't the way to go. Edit: Oh, you wrote "verbal" that seems weird to me. Most people I know certainly don't want to talk to their devices.
- ljf 1y agoMy wife paid for ChatGPT and is loving it - she only types to it so far (and sends it images and screenshots), but I've had a go at talking to it and it was much better than I thought. If I'm alone I don't mind talking if it is faster, but there is no way I'm talking to AI in the office or on the train (yet...)
- throwaway314155 1y ago> If I'm alone I don't mind talking if it is faster When is talking faster than text? I only ever use it when my hands are tied (usually for looking up how to do things while playing a video game).
- Retric 1y agoWhen you can talk at your normal pace? People talk at about 120WPM - 160WPM naturally, few can type that fast which is why stenographers have a special keyboard and notation.
- throwaway314155 1y agoI struggle to have naturally flowing conversation with an AI for much the same reason people don't use most of Siri's features - it's awkward and feels strange. As such I can maintain about five minutes of slow pace before giving up and typing. I have to believe others have similar experiences. But perhaps I'm an outlier.
- PaulHoule 1y ago
- com2kid 1y agoIMHO we are at the point now where ambient computing is fully possible using locally self hosted AI and LLMs. I explore the ideas more in a post at https://meanderingthoughts.hashnode.dev/lets-do-some-actual-innovative-sht https://meanderingthoughts.hashnode.dev/lets-do-some-actual-... but the tl;dr is ~24-32GB of VRAM in a server shoved in a basement can do a lot. Imagine a machine that is fully owned by the user with no corporate spying. It can listen 24/7 to everything in the house, using technology like wifi location sensing it knows what room people are in (it is a thing now!) and can relay messages for a person to the closest speaker. Even 8B parameter LLMs are great at ambiguous inputs, and new TTS models are weighting in under 1B parameters. Connecting the LLM up to everything a person wants to do is the real issue. Homekit integrations exist, but Homekit isn't exactly a mass consumer technology. What RabbitOS aims to do is IMHO the proper path: Drive an android phone to accomplish tasks.