3 ms·
Have you tried recently? This hasn't been my experience. I modify the code it's written, then ask it to reread the file. It generally responds "I see you change
by icedchai 1y ago
Have you tried recently? This hasn't been my experience. I modify the code it's written, then ask it to reread the file. It generally responds "I see you changed file and [something.]" Or when it makes a change, I tell it I need to run some tests. I provide feedback, explain the problem, and it iterates. This is with Zed and Claude Sonnet.
- dkersten 1y agoI do notice though that if I edit what it wrote before accepting it, and then it sees it (either because I didn’t wait for it to finish or because I send it another message), it will overwrite my changes with what it had before my changes every single time, without fail. (Zed with Claude 4)
- jagged-chisel 1y agoGemini has insisted on remembering an earlier version of a file even after its own edits. “We removed that, remember?” “Yes! I see now …” Sometimes it circles back to that same detail that no longer exists.
- icedchai 1y agoInteresting. I always wait for it to finish with my workflow.
- dkersten 1y agoIt does it even if I wait for it to finish, but don't accept. Eg: Starting code: a quick brown fox prompt 1: "Capitalize the words" AI: A Quick Brown Fox I don't accept or reject, but change it to "A Quick Red Fox" prompt 2: "Change it to dog" AI: A Quick Brown Dog