5 ms·
> understand that disrupting homeostasis in a durable and meaningful way is actually darn hard to do This is a huge problem in online ADHD communities, too. T
by Aurornis 1y ago
> understand that disrupting homeostasis in a durable and meaningful way is actually darn hard to do
This is a huge problem in online ADHD communities, too.
The ADHD subreddits are a constant stream of people having “Wow I feel amazing” reactions after taking their first stimulant dosage, followed a week later by complaints that it “stopped working”. It’s a constant cycle of informing people that the euphoria they experienced was a side effect, not how they’re going to feel for the rest of their life taking a stimulant.
- protocolture 1y agoYeah I remember that high lasted for several weeks.
- landl0rd 1y agoYeah there's functionally no good solution besides occasional stimulant use and staying off them the rest of the time. I vaguely recall some literature that claimed many patients had basically no benefit by some period (believe over a year) which matches friends' anecdotal experience. Exceptions exist; they aren't super common. Direct dopamine regulation is just a crappy target for this. TAAR1 agonism may be a better target. I've heard some sketchy reports that things in the class of bromantane might be good options, as it acts to epigenetically upregulate dopamine synthesis rather than altering clearance, but not super well-investigated and noot bros are a little weird here (initial research chose it for a balance between physical work capacity increase vs. cognitive benefits, whereas a cognition-focused analogue might perform better.) HDAC inhibition is vaguely interesting but much too large a target. There are some possibilities to work on, but basically this remains a very unsolved problem, and rhetoric around tolerance often reminds me of the oxycodone "pseudo-addiction" language as much as anything. "Your brain is dopamine-deficient!" No, homeostasis means this probably isn't the case. There may be deficits in signaling but it's not an issue with the concentration of a neurotransmitter.
- Aurornis 1y ago> Yeah there's functionally no good solution besides occasional stimulant use and staying off them the rest of the time. This is literally the misunderstanding I was talking about. The startup euphoric effects are a side effect, not the main ADHD therapeutic function. This is the confusion that leads people off track, especially when they’re prescribed too high of a starting dose. Taking the stimulant every day and acknowledging that it’s not supposed to be euphoric is the only way to use them for actual ADHD treatment. The attention-enhancing effects largely remain. This is also where the “stimulant medications affect ADHD people differently” myth comes from. The real reason is that the ADHD patient has taken the med for years and doesn’t get a stimulant rush when taking it. The college student who borrows the fully-titrated dose from their friend is speeding around because they are stimulant naive. > Direct dopamine regulation is just a crappy target for this. TAAR1 agonism may be a better target. Amphetamine (Adderall) is a TAAR1 ligand. Guanfacine (non-stimulant ADHD medication) is as well. > I've heard some sketchy reports that things in the class of bromantane might be good options, as it acts to epigenetically upregulate dopamine synthesis rather than altering clearance, Bromantane is thought to upregulate expression of some genes related to dopamine, but it also might have some effects on the sigma receptor, act on a potassium channel, and it does have some dopamine reuptake inhibition though the exact amount is up for debate. Anyway, people often equate ADHD and dopamine, but norepinephrine is actually the common thread among all ADHD medications. Like you said, there’s a lot of “dopamine deficiency” broscience on the internet that doesn’t really match the science.
- Spivak 1y ago> This is also where the “stimulant medications affect ADHD people differently” myth comes from This doesn't seem right, the effect people talk about isn't a non-ADHD person taking adderall and going off the wall— it's someone with ADHD taking a stimulant, even a pretty high dose, for the first time and it having very little effect outside of a mild calm and focus. It very well might be a myth that this is related to my ADHD and it's caused by something else weird with my body but I can vouch for this experience. I was offered a 30mg adderall at a party and it didn't do much of anything for me except I felt "normal." No euphoria, just kinda sleepy, but I could think about stuff and my brain wouldn't hurt after a while which was nice.
- arresin 1y agoFrom personal experience the right enantiomer at a low dose works longterm without any breaks. It’s not a panacea though. If you’re tired or you don’t have the will power, you’ll still twiddle your thumbs—except you’ll be really into the twiddling. My issue was that even with the will power, sleeping and perfect nutrition, etc, my brain physically wouldn’t do it and it was extremely demoralising. Again, not a panacea and if you don’t actually have a condition I think it would be foolish to take (you may feel like you’re doing more but it will likely be at a lower quality).
- landl0rd 1y agoInteresting, are you saying you found a difference in efficacy or tolerance? Was it based on enantiopure d-amphetamines or the ratio of d/l-enantiomers?
- ifwinterco 1y agoFor some reason people without ADHD really want to make it not a thing, but anyone who actually has it knows these drugs can be life changing The feeling of wanting to do productive stuff but being physically unable is hard to describe but it's really not a good feeling and moderate doses of dopamine raising agents really can alleviate it consistently and for the long term
- cynicalkane 1y agoThis isn't always true. Stimulants can -- for a subpopulation, at least -- meaningfully improve focus in ADHD individuals in long-term measurable ways and low risk of side effects. This contrasts starkly to ordinary people, who will quickly build up a tolerance to typical stimulants. The difference is measurable with clinical tests.
- adastra22 1y agoI am not sure why you are being downvoted. Stimulants work very well for long term treatment of ADHD. It's the gold standard with >90% success rate.
- DontchaKnowit 1y agoBeing downvoted cause they werent paying attention to what the comment above them was saying. The Euphoria WILL always wear off, doesnt mean it doesnt continue to treat symptoms. Also yes stimulants are the gold standard but I would argue that our metrics for success are bunk
- adastra22 1y agoGenerally speaking (there are exceptions) ADHD people do not experience euphoria when taking stimulants. I never have, not even the first time. It’s known as the paradoxical reaction. Some people do develop tolerance, but usually building an off day into the schedule is enough to counter that.
- astrange 1y agoStimulant tolerance means you aren't taking enough magnesium. Or for Vyvanse, your diet is too acidic.
- DontchaKnowit 1y agothat is absolutely just straight up untrue. Yes excessive stimulant usage depletes magnesium, mostly cause you forget to eat. And yes for both vyvanse and adderall, if your stomach is too acidic it will decrease bioavailability, but neither of things things have anything to do with tolerance, which accrues on a semi-permanent basis every time you take the drug.