3 ms·
I hate to sound old-fashioned, but this puts the cart before the horse. Authors should have a book available for sale before accepting delivery payments. Ask an
by lutusp 14y ago
I hate to sound old-fashioned, but this puts the cart before the horse. Authors should have a book available for sale before accepting delivery payments. Ask any publisher how this sort of thing usually works out.
- ky3 14y agoIt's not a bug, it's a feature! The reader gets involved in the making of the book, the writer gets a way to talk with their best customers, everyone wins. A savvy author trumps a crappy publisher any time.
- lutusp 14y ago> The reader gets involved in the making of the book, the writer gets a way to talk with their best customers, everyone wins. Not disparaging this specific author or publisher, but this was once accomplished by having advance reviewers offer their criticisms without any money changing hands. > A savvy author trumps a crappy publisher any time. Yes, but not the reverse. :)
- mikey_p 14y agoHaving an advanced review by a reviewer is not the same as feedback from actual customers.
- bdunn 14y agoFrom my perspective, there's nothing more motivating than having people chomping at the bit to get their hands on your book. The end product is arguably better because it's not being written in a vacuum and is bolstered by a ton of support.
- lutusp 14y agoYes, but that end can be accomplished through pre-publication excerpts and interviews, not by accepting payments for a book not yet written. The former increases public enthusiasm for a book, the latter doesn't. Reasonable people may differ.
- ahoyhere 14y agoIn your arguments against presales, you haven't said why you think that the other way is better. What's your reasoning? I'm assuming "because one creates better publicity" isn't it, since you seem to have something against the idea for deeper reasons.
- lutusp 14y ago> In your arguments against presales, you haven't said why you think that the other way is better. What's your reasoning? In the traditional approach, reviewers who have no economic stake review a book or an excerpt and let the public know what they think. In most cases the public can assume the review is objective. In an approach like this one, an author uses pre-orders or advance payments as evidence for the book's merit. But those pre-ordering haven't yet seen what they're buying. The problem should be obvious -- the author can say, "My book must have merit -- look at all those who have ordered it in advance of seeing it!" Again, I am not saying any of this applies to this author or this book -- it's completely hypothetical.
- ahoyhere 14y agoI can't tell who you think is being served poorly by this. The people who can get their money back immediately if they are disappointed? The same people who might preorder any other kind of book on Amazon.com? The reviewers, who theoretically are less biased about something they got for free? The author, who you presume is using existing sales as a weak ipso facto ex post facto argument for the quality of the book-in-progress (which, as you admit, is purely hypothetical)?
- dchurchv 14y agoNot sure I follow this. Pre-ordering books is a pretty well established practice among publishers (yes, real ones, not just ebook authors). Actually, it's the primary hack for getting on best-seller lists (pre-orders, then fulfillment in strategic batches designed to show consistent sales over time). Or is this a more basic "No one should sell anything that doesn't already exist" argument? If so, I'd point out concert tickets (usually 6 months advance sale), seminars, conferences, and most other large undertakings that need some sort of validated audience numbers as counter-evidence. Why not all products, as long as there's no attempt to deceive, and the purchaser is clear that the product is not ready yet?
- lutusp 14y ago> Not sure I follow this. Pre-ordering books is a pretty well established practice among publishers ... The difference is the person pre-ordering can back out, and generally speaking in pre-orders, no payment is made until delivery. It ends up being a measure of public enthusiasm, not a way to gather revenues in advance of delivery. In this case, people are paying for a book that doesn't exist yet. > Actually, it's the primary hack for getting on best-seller lists Yes, true, but see the pre-order discussion above -- generally, no money changes hands until the book is actually available. Also, I have to add, the ultimate best-seller-list hack is to buy copies of your own book and put the copies back into the pipeline, endlessly, as the Scientologists are said to do. > Or is this a more basic "No one should sell anything that doesn't already exist" argument? But that's true in general -- in the worst cases, where delivery doesn't happen, the seller can be charged with fraud. I hasten to add I am not comparing this hypothetical (but all too common) outcome with the book under discussion, which for all I know is perfectly worthwhile.
- dchurchv 14y agoOk, but you didn't address my point about concert tickets et al. Obviously you pay in advance of seeing the concert, or attending the conference, and sometimes these things get canceled. It's reasonable to expect money back, or worst case some sort of "raincheck" in case of a cancelation or delay. Same applies to ebooks in my mind. "Public enthusiasm" doesn't pay the deposit for a concert hall or conference center, right? Why should an author not get paid in advance of the effort of writing a book? [Hint: authors already figured this out a couple of centuries ago - thus the publishers' advance] So it's not really a question of money changing hands, it's just whose money, and whose hands.
- rprasad 14y agoHe's basically asking for an advance directly from his readers. The flipside, of course, is that he must also return this "advance" if no book is made available.
- bdunn 14y agoExactly. PayPal would also step in and refund if I flaked out on my side of the deal. It goes without saying, I'm pretty certain I'm going to make a LOT more money in sales once the book is ready (immediate gratification). So it's in my best interest to get this out the door soon.