25 ms·
Universal Basic Income isn't about free money – it's about a freer life
- lordfrito 1y agoAs long as it's not about free money I don't see anyone objecting.
- p0w3n3d 1y ago[flagged]
- toomuchtodo 1y agoInflation is coming regardless due to global structural demographics. Handing out fiat is likely infeasible, it’s too brute force without being able to control inflation per category, but a bifurcation with housing, energy, food, etc provided and fiat more reserved for human labor purchases is possible imho. I came across the idea somewhere of two currencies: one for things made by machines, and one for things made by humans. The first can be printed, the second worked for or otherwise constrained. I think that is what the future may look like as energy and tech abundance hits the declining demographic curve. https://www.mckinsey.com/mgi/our-research/dependency-and-depopulation-confronting-the-consequences-of-a-new-demographic-reality https://www.mckinsey.com/mgi/our-research/dependency-and-dep... https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-030-42657-6 https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-030-42657-6 https://www.cato.org/cato-journal/spring/summer-2018/demographics-their-implications-economy-policy https://www.cato.org/cato-journal/spring/summer-2018/demogra...
- p0w3n3d 1y agoGovernment has no money. They do not produce anything. There is printing. Govt can print money and give it to people, which causes inflation. I live in Poland. When I as 4 people were losing every money they had at their own because of hiperinflation because govt was spending too much money. They just printed it. When it started my parents were earning 1000zl monthly, a few years later I could buy one ice cream ball for 2500zl.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoDoes Poland not have public housing? Public transport? Roads? Government owns infrastructure. If you don't want to call printing money to provide that to citizens, I'm open to other verbiage as it relates to what UBI and future monetary systems look like. Government creates money. Government builds things. The money is just the accounting.
- wtcactus 1y agoI’m middle class and I live in Europe. Counting all the contributions I’m forced to give the state, they now take about 60% of all I earn. And here we are talking of giving even more free money to people that don’t work. Who is going to pay for that? Am I going to have to work even more or are you going to let me keep even less of my money?
- mettamage 1y agoI really hope it will be AI/robots. It probably won’t but one can hope.
- normalaccess 1y ago[flagged]
- M95D 1y agoDon't you know the answer already? You will have to work more and more, your coworkers will be fired one by one, supposedly replaced by AI, you will take over their work too, then at some point will will be fired too, won't be able to find a job, and when the unemployment benefits end, you will wish to have UBI. About giving money to people that don't work: get the official statistics and calculate as % of your country's budget. You'll probably want to look elsewhere for the money required for UBI. Maybe at the (corrupt) government's contracts and subsidies. No, there are no statistics on those, i'm sure.
- wtcactus 1y agoOh, so just like it happened during the Industrial Revolution, right? Where everyone was supposed to eventually go out of a job because machines would replace us… I live in a country where we need unchecked immigration because “nationals don’t want to do the jobs they do” (never mind less than a 3rd of those immigrants are actually working). So, kind of hard to fit reality with your predictions when there’s clearly work to do (hard work for sure), but lot of people already prefer to live off the welfare state than to bother doing it.
- msgodel 1y agoIt's barely worth showing up to work now, how are they going to motivate anyone to maintain any of this stuff?
- bryanlarsen 1y agoTo be sustainable, UBI has to be sub-poverty levels. Anything more than about $1500 is not monetarily feasible. Not very many people are going to be happy living on $1500/month. Most people will keep working.
- msgodel 1y agoI'd be fine with half that. What luxuries justify spending 8 hours a day dealing with insane corporate bullshit?
- hollerith 1y agoA wife and a couple of kids. Having more options in life, e.g., to pick up and move.
- msgodel 1y agoNo one is doing that anymore regardless.
- toomuchtodo 1y agohttps://iop.harvard.edu/youth-poll/50th-edition-spring-2025 https://iop.harvard.edu/youth-poll/50th-edition-spring-2025 ("Traditional life goals are shifting, with only 48% of young Americans saying having children is important") https://msutoday.msu.edu/news/2025/msu-study-finds-number-of-us-nonparents-who-never-want-children-is-growing https://msutoday.msu.edu/news/2025/msu-study-finds-number-of... (“We found that the percentage of nonparents who don’t want any children rose from 14% in 2002 to 29% in 2023,” said Jennifer Watling Neal, professor in MSU’s psychology department and co-author of the study. “During the same period, the percent of nonparents who plan to have children in the future fell from 79% to 59%.”) https://www.axios.com/2024/07/25/adults-no-children-why-pew-data https://www.axios.com/2024/07/25/adults-no-children-why-pew-... ("64% of young women say they just don't want children, compared to 50% of men.") A record-high share of 40-year-olds in the U.S. have never been married - https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/06/28/a-record-high-share-of-40-year-olds-in-the-us-have-never-been-married/ https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/06/28/a-record-... The childfree are ungovernable - https://beneaththepavement.substack.com/p/the-childfree-are-ungovernable-capitalism https://beneaththepavement.substack.com/p/the-childfree-are-... (us specific, ymmv)
- keybored 1y agoUniversal Basic Income is the billionaire’s consolation price for the working class once the workers have automated the economy to a certain degree. They get to keep the resources while the workers/former workers get to subsist “for free” on a livable pittance. Helped along ideologically by useful idiot multi-millionaires[1] who chant about “just upskill”/“just be Mensa-level intelligent”. [1] https://infosec.exchange/@codinghorror/114606355212363074 https://infosec.exchange/@codinghorror/114606355212363074
- jsharpe 1y agoWhat a strange position this is (from the link): "the future of work is being more than one deviation from the statistical norm" This by definition can apply to only 16% of people who are at least one deviation above the mean. What about the other 84%?
- cheeseomlit 1y agoThe cited studies, like most sociopolitical studies, probably don't prove anything. The article doesn't specify how the subjects were selected, unless I missed something. If I were an advocate for UBI and wanted to organize a study like this, I'd make sure to select people who are likely to keep working and not just quit and smoke weed all day so I could reinforce my narrative. If I were an opponent of UBI I'd do the opposite and enroll people who are unlikely to keep working when they don't have to.
- FireSquid2006 1y agoCopied from the study "To determine whether the measured effects were actually due to receiving the basic income and not, for example, to broader societal developments, the Basic Income Pilot Project was designed as a randomised controlled trial. This ensured that the participants in the control group were so-called 'statistical twins' of the basic income group. This meant that they were very similar in their sociodemographic characteristics and differed mainly in whether or not they had received a basic income. Both groups were essential to the success of the study. Only by comparing their experiences could scientific conclusions be drawn. To prevent bias, care was also taken to ensure that both groups included equal numbers of ideological supporters and opponents of basic income. The study focused on people between the ages of 21 and 40 living alone in a household with a net income of between €1,100 and €2,600 per month. We explain why these characteristics were chosen in our journal."
- M95D 1y ago> quit and smoke weed all day Arguably, those people won't be productive members of the society either way. With UBI, they could even be less likely to shoplift, mug/rob people, or otherwise cause harm.
- paxys 1y agoWhile I agree with UBI at a philosophical level, attempting to study it scientifically with a sample size of N people in an existing functioning economy is pointless. If 10 people have UBI and 1000 others are doing regular work, you can't turn around and say "see how much happier the 10 people are!" Of course they are happy. They earn more money than their neighbors for doing less work. Now give everyone else the same amount of money and see how things play out. Is rent going to be the same? Is anyone going to be working menial jobs? Is UBI going to increase income inequality by sending more money to the capital class (like say COVID relief checks did)? We won't know all this until such an experiment is done at an economy-wide level.
- dinfinity 1y ago> Is UBI going to increase income inequality by sending more money to the capital class (like say COVID relief checks did)? How did COVID relief checks 'send more money to the capital class'? Are you saying that putting money in the hands of ordinary citizens is ineffective because they spend it on stuff sold by the capital class? Perhaps I'm misunderstanding, but that sounds idiotic.
- rbanffy 1y ago> Is anyone going to be working menial jobs? Will they be better paid? > We won't know all this until such an experiment is done at an economy-wide level. This is why we need to continue experimenting at larger scales. Next time, we can try with a small city and see what happens.
- wirrbel 1y agoI studied at a German university where one of the prominent advocates for universal basic income, Götz Werner (the owner of a well-known German health and beauty retail chain), gave several talks. As a member of a student club, I participated in a smaller event with him, which allowed for plenty of questions and interaction. At that time, the concept of universal basic income wasn’t particularly associated with left-wing politics. To summarize: Universal basic income can be seen as a kind of negative poll tax (a poll tax being a fixed tax per person). Werner argued that the current tax system is unsustainable because it places a disproportionate burden on labor. He suggested that instead of taxing income, we should tax consumption—essentially, by significantly increasing sales tax and eliminating income tax. Of course, this would make life unaffordable for low earners, so a negative poll tax (i.e., a basic income) would be necessary to make higher sales taxes socially acceptable. In practice, a large portion of the universal basic income would end up returning to the state through sales tax anyway. Even back in 2010, I sensed that Mr. Werner was promoting a system that would benefit his own financial interests. As an employer with high labor costs, he would gain from lower taxes and fees associated with employment in Germany. And, as a wealthy individual, only a small part of his wealth would be subject to sales tax, since he wouldn’t need to spend most of it on taxable purchases. When pressed about numbers (how high the sales tax, how high the negative poll tax) he just wouldn't discuss numbers saying society would have to figure it out and potentially one might start out with some amount and then progressively increase the negative poll tax, increase the sales tax and decrease other taxes. It really felt like someone not having done any actual simulations / calculations. oh and one thing he really emphasized is, that UBI could allow for people to go from like a 40h work week to a 30h work week being employed and use their fridays for example to become entrepreneurs/artists/etc. That really felt like as close to prosperity gospel as one can get in germany.
- goalieca 1y agoTrump was inspired by a similar consumption tax based on tarrifs and he oft cited the days before income tax. He was expecting Congress to provide an income tax relief package to compensate.
- Simulacra 1y agoUntil the economy adjust for the additional money in the system and prices rise, thereby going back to square one. A universal basic income is impossible without strict price controls.
- IAmBroom 1y agoShow your work.
- rbanffy 1y agoI'm unsure why this got flagged. It's an interesting discussion on an increasingly important topic.
- sfmz 1y agoWe have a whole village in MN running on something like UBI. 800 members of the Shakopee Mdewakanton each receive ~$1m/year because of casino revenues. Apparently, their unemployment level is like 98%; I really wonder how they spend their day.