26 ms·
This is very cool indeed, but I laughed when I got to the conclusion: > A limitation of this work is that the resulting de-oxygenated titanium contains yttrium
by Aurornis 1y ago
This is very cool indeed, but I laughed when I got to the conclusion:
> A limitation of this work is that the resulting de-oxygenated titanium contains yttrium, up to 1% by mass; yttrium can influence the mechanical and chemical properties of titanium alloy. After solving the yttrium contamination problem…
So the process removes the oxygen but then adds yttrium to the metal in significant amounts. That’s not quite the ultra pure titanium I was promised in the headline.
As always, I hope someone figures out the rest of the problem space. As-is, this looks like trading one problem for another.
- foota 1y agoI'm not sure if it makes it easier, but there are some differences between the high oxygen titanium alloy and titanium with some yttrium in it that might make it easier to separate? Presumably when you melt the titanium the yttrium doesn't react, whereas the oxygen dissolved in the titanium alloy at room temperature will form titanium dioxide when it's heated (if I'm reading correctly). So maybe you could "just" separate the molten metal by density afterwards? I'm not sure this would work though. For one, you'd need to avoid re-introducing oxygen contamination, but I guess you could do it under a vacuum (yes "just" spin the molten metal at high speed in a vacuum)? This would seem to me to beg the question of why not just grind up the titanium in a vacuum to remove the oxygen and then melt it down, so I might be missing something here.
- LasEspuelas 1y agoAgreed. The original paper states that they have a technique to remove oxygen from the surface of titanium. If that is the case, grinding could be viable. How hard is it to grind titanium?
- freeone3000 1y ago…Very hard. It’s titanium. Every work process has to be done with special carbide bits, at half speed, underwater.
- hinkley 1y agoTungsten carbide isn’t it?
- foota 1y agoI think the titanium on the outside in the slag is the easy part, and not included in the 1% figure, which is on the inside.
- BurningFrog 1y ago"can influence" means either that science doesn't know yet how yttrium influences the alloy properties, or that the journalist didn't ask.
- hinkley 1y agoOr the scientist read the room and decided being vague was the best option.
- robocat 1y agoGrade 2 Sponge Titanium (USD/mt) = $6,087.03 Yttrium: 28.9 USD/kg is 2890 USD/mt So the 1% Yttrium might be financially reasonable (assuming extra demand can be met). Prices from metal.com
- hinkley 1y agoSounds like a ‘find a useful titanium/??/yttrium alloy’ situation. I’m shocked that yttrium is dearer than smelted titanium.
- robocat 1y agoThose figures show Yttrium is about half the price of Titanium metal. I was shocked at how cheap Yttrium is (I searched for pricing because I thought the 1% might be too expensive). Now I want to buy some...
- robocat 1y agoNot cheap. Ah shit. I can't shift zeros. 1% of 28900 $/mt is $289. [Yeah: My initial assumption was that Yttrium is really expensive - and it fucking is - I ignored my own smell test - I should have caught my mistake]. That is say 5% of the current final price of Ti (ignoring purity) to end up with something with less oxygen but 1% fucked with Yttrium. You can't just increase price by percentage points for highly competitive commodities. You especially can't add dependencies on elements that are in limited supply and supply controlled/constrained by politics. So this looks like another academic bullshit result that totally ignores economical realities.
- hinkley 1y agoAh, that was a typo. Not dearer.
- Const-me 1y agoI think you made a mistake converting units, 28.9 USD/kg = $28900 per ton.
- mmooss 1y ago> this looks like trading one problem for another. Every choice trades one problem for another. At a minimum, the new problem is the cost in resources - time, money, personal energy (and in business, usually reputation risk and political capital) - but usually the cost is much more than that, especially when looking at alternative technical solutions. In advice to clients I always present the options as the minimum trade-off (it's my job to minimize it). More generally, the question is, which scenario of outcomes do you want? It could be the scenario with 1% yttrium is far better than the one with oxygen, or that the ytrrium scenario has a very different set of costs and benefits which make it valuable for certain needs that the oxygen scenario doesn't fulfill. It could be that methods for removing yttrium are already mature and only need to be applied to this case. But especially in this case, the report is about research & development. If there were no more problems to solve then it wouldn't be R&D. It's really self-defeating to criticize progress in R&D because some problems remain. 'We scored a goal, but that's just trading one problem for another - the other team has the ball!'
- Aurornis 1y ago> Every choice trades one problem for another. The problem in this case is that the headline claimed “ultra pure titanium” and the closing paragraph had a tiny oh-by-the-way mention that the process contaminates the titanium with yttrium. Which is to say, makes it anything but ultra pure. :) > It could be that methods for removing yttrium are already mature and only need to be applied to this case. Sorry but no. That’s specially a problem they highlighted as needing a solution.
- gsf_emergency 1y agoI was more terrified by the yttrium fluoride. That rings a pancreatic cancer bell very loudly. Additionally, you can be sure that people who understand much more chemistry than biology (or who might have accepted their own deaths) are going to make... different tradeoffs That said, I welcome others to look into substituting, eg, aluminum for yttrium in these methods (since titalum is already a thing)
- 1y ago
- maxerickson 1y agoTitanium dioxide is about 40% oxygen by mass. Converting that to 1% of something else seems like it's doing something.
- shakna 1y agoIsn't yttrium sometimes added to increase the strength of titanium, anyway?
- adrian_b 1y agoYttrium is a more benign contaminant. Very small amounts of oxygen in titanium are enough to make it too hard and too fragile for most applications. Adding less harmful impurities to bind the more harmful impurities that cannot be otherwise removed (a.k.a. gettering) has always been a major purification technique, both in metallurgy and in semiconductor technology. Steel is purified in the same way from the more harmful impurities, by adding other impurities like calcium, silicon or manganese or rare-earth metals. In some cases, the compounds that result from adding impurities may be removed later, e.g. like slag floating on molten steel, but in other cases they may remain in the metal or semiconductor that is the desired end product. It remains to be seen whether the extra yttrium and yttrium oxide that remain in titanium are harmful enough to make it worth to attempt to remove them somehow. In some cases they may even have beneficial properties, though e.g. for dental implants I would want commercially pure titanium that does not have any other metallic impurities like yttrium (commercially pure titanium includes small amounts of oxygen and of iron, both of which have no harmful effects in living tissues).