6 ms·
From the headline I thought they were making a single incremental change (Nix) but the article sounds like they’re doing an entire rewrite under a new project n
by Aurornis 1y ago
From the headline I thought they were making a single incremental change (Nix) but the article sounds like they’re doing an entire rewrite under a new project name:
> Since we transitioned away from Nix, we also transitioned away from the name Nixpacks in favor of Railpack. We also changed the codebase from Rust to Go because of the Buildkit libraries.
Suddenly the move away from Nix seems less like an incremental change and more like one part of a complete overhaul of the entire project. Did they have a team changeover or something? Or did they just want to start over from scratch and rewrite the whole project?
It also seems strange to switch to an entirely different programming language for a single library. I haven’t found library FFI to be a huge obstacle in Rust.
- cybrexalpha 1y agoThat also jumped out to me as pretty weird. Buildkit as a library is nice, but there's no way it's good enough to justify throwing out the entire project. It feels like there was some big change internally, and the new team either wanted to rewrite and didn't know Rust, or ideologically prefer Go to Rust. Edit: Although looking at it, maybe not? Both the new project railpack[0] and the older one nixpacks[1] are both started by and mostly written by the same person[2], who is also the author of the article in question. So it doesn't look like a team change. It still feels... odd? Less that they made the change, projects go from Rust to Go all the time. But usually it's because of issues with Rust (hard to hire for, learning curve, etc.), describing it like this feels unusual? [0] https://github.com/railwayapp/railpack https://github.com/railwayapp/railpack [1] https://github.com/railwayapp/nixpacks https://github.com/railwayapp/nixpacks [2] https://github.com/coffee-cup https://github.com/coffee-cup