18 ms·
IKEA's New Catalogs: Less Pine, More Pixels
- kaiyi 14y agoI like Ikea's selections, and its designs are appealing to younger home owners. But from my experience, Ikea really needs to improve customer service. I called Ikea regarding some problems with delivered furniture, and they put me on hold for about an hour.
- DeepDuh 14y agoI can't really tell anything about their phone service. I've had good experiences with their in-store service however. So I think it's not all areas of their customer service, but they could certainly improve.
- twelvechairs 14y agoHave you ever tried their website with 'Ask Anna'? I actually wasted my own time formulating a very direct and specific question, got a 'hold on, I'm thinking' response, then 10 minutes later found out that it wasn't a live text-chat with customer services, but a terrible AI, whose final response was 'have you tried looking at the catalogue?' (yes! and its not there. Which is why i need to ask someone a question!). Thanks for wasting my time Ikea! Better to just not have that 'feature' there at all IMHO...
- tricolon 14y agoI just wish they'd stop using Verdana.
- MagerValp 14y agoThey want the catalog to look cheap though, and Verdana certainly helps with that… The font nerd in me died a little bit when they switched.
- sbierwagen 14y agoBah, yet another "can you spot the CGI" test. I've never seen one that wasn't badly imbalanced in favor of CGI, by using tiny (400x300) images.
- panacea 14y agoI got 4/5 (and the one I got wrong was the one I was most unsure about). Even with the small nature of these images, there's certain things that stood out as either not worth the hassle to get right in 3D for a catalogue (too naturally imperfect or detailed), and others where it looked like it would take way more time to make realistically in 3D instead of just taking a photo. Some of the lighting effects were pretty poor too.
- timdorr 14y agoSupposedly, this should be the updated 2013 calendar: http://onlinecatalog.ikea-usa.com/US/en/IKEA_Catalog/ http://onlinecatalog.ikea-usa.com/US/en/IKEA_Catalog/ Either the CGI is really good, or maybe it's for the next 2013 catalog.
- terhechte 14y agoI got all of them right. I think the 3D ones are still identifiable easily. Though I've do admit I do a lot of 3D work in Blender3D, so I may just have an eye for when it looks to perfect.
- BklynJay 14y agoI've had a consistently bad experience with Ikea furniture. Bedroom dressers - the bottoms fall out of the drawers and should ideally be glued in place (the instructions don't suggest this). Even with glue, they sag after a year or so. Kitchenware - their handles on their pots and pans are very heat conductive so make sure you're wearing an oven mitt. Their kitchen block furniture with the thick wood top is well made, though it should be stained and varnished to avoid stains. Chairs - maybe half the chairs I've gotten from Ikea had poorly drilled screw holes such that the chair couldn't be assembled correctly. Fortunately, the benches are made of such soft pine (read: scratchable) that you can drill your own hole easily. Sometimes Ikea will eliminate a part (eg: a supporting brace for a dresser) but not redesign the assembly instructions. You might think you're missing that part, when in fact it was omitted deliberately. They save money where they can by selling you disposable furniture.
- culturestate 14y ago> They save money where they can by selling you disposable furniture. Well, yes, that's the general idea of most items in their catalog. You buy their well-designed version instead of Wal-Mart's poorly-designed version. Their target market is not exactly people who would otherwise shop at Restoration Hardware. In my case, Ikea is a lifesaver. I move around quite a bit, and when I need a piece for a new apartment I'd rather not spend a bunch of money when I'm going to be leaving it behind in a year or less. I've probably bought that damn perforated aluminum cutlery holder 8 times on 3 continents.
- ericdykstra 14y agoReally? I've had pretty good luck. I've been using one of their shelving units [1] for more than 5 years, and it's held up very well. My wife and I are using their dining set that was just $100 for the table and two chairs, and it's fantastic [2]. We're also using an Ikea bed. I was a little skeptical about getting a bed from Ikea at first, but it's more comfortable than any regular mattress I've ever tried, or the Select Comfort bed I used for a number of years (it's one of the foam mattresses with slats). Sure, it's a pain to put some of them together (especially the bed frame and slats... yikes), but I've had consistently good quality. The only problem is that you really need to check the box before you go home. There are often missing or wrong parts. Just my experience, though. The furniture is good, but shopping there is an adventure I'd rather not go through again. 1. http://www.ikea.com/us/en/catalog/products/10196431/ http://www.ikea.com/us/en/catalog/products/10196431/ 2. http://www.ikea.com/us/en/catalog/products/80157129/ http://www.ikea.com/us/en/catalog/products/80157129/
- jswanson 14y agoA lot of IKEA criticism here, but what they are doing is actually pretty neat. All of their products are probably designed in some sort of CAD software, which means they already have the models necessary to do these sort of mockups. It still must have taken them foresight and money to get from "having models" to "easily arranging and realistically rendering", but now that they are there they can save money, update their catalogs faster, and generate less waste. Fairly obvious, yet still a cool practice. Wonder how many other companies are doing something similar.
- panacea 14y ago"Wonder how many other companies are doing something similar." Easy bet that Apple's website 'hero' images have been 3D renders for years.
- mongol 14y agoI just checked the fifth image from the top (the kitchen) http://si.wsj.net/public/resources/images/OB-UG852_IKEAb0_G_20120822201235.jpg http://si.wsj.net/public/resources/images/OB-UG852_IKEAb0_G_... in the real catalog. I would never have guessed it was not real when browsing through it. If I knew there were some it could have been a candidate because there are no people in it. But otherwise, it looks like a very regular photograph. EDIT: Mistake! I did not look at the correct image, mine was similar but different. Disregard the above. EDIT 2: So this means I am looking at a picture in the catalog that I don't know whether it is real or rendered. But knowing that they new render some images, that the image has no people in it (which is not uncommon in the catalog), and that especially the cupboard doors have some artificial feeling to them, my guess is that "my" image is rendered too. But also, there is a bottle of olive oil on the counter, and its brand is a brand that is common in Sweden, and contains details on the label that seems authentic. So they put much effort into small details in that case.
- ZoFreX 14y ago"In all, IKEA plans to publish 208 million catalogs this year, more than double the amount of Bibles expected to be produced." What a silly comparison. I'm not sure if that's supposed to sound impressive or not, but I would assume the number of bibles being produced isn't that high - everyone that wants one already has one, and it's not like they update it each year!
- megablast 14y agoIt is a fun comparison, that is all. You can compare anything to anything, it doesn't have to be meaningful in a big way.
- panacea 14y agoI now choose to compare the Curiosity rover doing a donut on Mars, with IKEA's choice of Verdana and 3D imagery in their catalogue.
- ramblerman 14y agowhat a weird thing to be bothered by.
- Spooky23 14y agoBible printing isn't just driven by intrinsic demand -- various groups push lots and lots of bibles out into the world to evangelize their religion. I think one group claims to have sent 250,000 bibles to American servicemen.
- nathan_long 14y ago"everyone that wants one already has one" - that may be true in first-world countries, but not worldwide. Religious oppression and persecution is still a large phenomenon in the world. But yes, it is silly to compare production numbers a book you may own for decades with a catalog that is tossed when the next issue arrives. The catalog would win by a large factor even if the readership was exactly the same.
- simonbrown 14y ago
- znarfdwarf02 14y ago12% 3D-Renderings per catalog seems a nice optimisation effort, but rather deadline-wise than cost-wise. While it makes it easier for them to meet the catalog deadline, the cost savings are neglible (at least compared to the total cost of the "demo furniture" in their 350 shops worldwide)
- confluence 14y agoI honestly think everything is going to go information. Also, I think that games, the little industry that could, is going to totally disrupt and destroy creative media production and consumption (movies/music/tv). Get ready to see an entire industry absolutely crush it. Human needs - outside of survival - are largely experiences. Having that great car, going on that ski trip, watching a movie, having a good family, spending time with people we like etc. I'm talking first world here (the vast majority of consumption). The rest of the world will catch up (I'm fully aware of their situation). Experiences are information and information is cheap, scalable, plentiful and most importantly - limitless. Want a great house? Jack into your own personal VR and have whatever you like. Want to drive a lambo through Monte Carlo in the summer? GTA 15 has got that covered. Want to go out with a French supermodel? Done and done. If all humans want are experiences then photoreal VR has, or will have, everything you could possibly need (outside of survival). You can create music. You can create movies. You can do that which you cannot do because of scarce resources (I'm ignoring the second law of thermodynamics). Games are going to lead the charge, and you can already see the beginnings of it with the rise of the Machinima movement and, most importantly, with the recent release of photoreal game engines that support full scale movie production and development (Valve with Source Filmaker and Crytek's Real Time Cinema tech). The price of making films is going to zero. The price of making novels is going to zero. Music - zero. Flying a jet - zero. Whatever it is that you want - VR can and will do it - and it will begin within this decade. Indeed - with the advent of fusion - energy is going to zero. What could you achieve if everything was free? What happens when you can divide by zero? We may very well see the death of physical consumption within this century (outside of fusion supplied energy). Tell me I'm crazy. Sources: Crytek CryEngine 3: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZqNHJ-ekMR4 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZqNHJ-ekMR4 Source FilmMaker: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zri1c_If6Ic http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zri1c_If6Ic DICE FrostBite 2 for Battlefield 3 - "Is it real?": http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qtMaJf45mQ8 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qtMaJf45mQ8 [E3 2012] Watch Dogs: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xU7WGAJPRRw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xU7WGAJPRRw [E3 2012] The Last of Us: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kbLOokeC3VU http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kbLOokeC3VU Red vs. Blue epic fight scene: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ke9wtbzGjCI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ke9wtbzGjCI GTA4 "Like a G6" music video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W5tuUU5dKb8 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W5tuUU5dKb8
- nathan_long 14y agoThe quote that caught my eye was: >> "We don't have to throw away kitchens in the Dumpster after the photo shoot." That does not speak well for the quality of the furniture.
- freehunter 14y agoQuality? We're talking about Ikea, not Thomasville. It's like saying a buffet isn't a high-quality meal. It's not supposed to be. They compete on value and convenience. This means things need to be easy to assemble yourself, and cheaper than pre-built and delivered furniture. Besides, I have to imagine Broyhill and La-Z-Boy do the same thing with their quality merchandise. It's worth the loss of merchandise to not have to spend money shipping it back to a store.
- nicholassmith 14y agoIt's been used commercially, which makes it tricky to repackage and sell. It could be donated to a charity, but once it's been used for a shoot it'll generally be torn down rather than taken down to save time.
- nathan_long 14y agoYeah, I'm just imagining this conversation. "Should we let some charities know they can come get free furniture when we're done?" "Nah, it's probably break if they try to move it now that it's already set up. Just trash it." And "we don't have a few hours to wait" doesn't sound like a great excuse, either.
- nicholassmith 14y agoDepends, when you've got one studio to work in, a very finite amount of time allocated to you and you've got to build and take down an entire set they'll generally not be too worried about keeping things in giftable condition. I don't necessarily agree with it, but I do understand it.
- ef4 14y agoTo me this is another interesting example of Marc Andreesson's "Software is Eating the World" meme: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424053111903480904576512250915629460.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405311190348090457651...
- mnicole 14y agoI love this, it puts them in a great position to be able to offer DIY SketchUp-like interior design right from their website simply by inputting your room's dimensions. The boyfriend was just speaking to how useful this would have been for some of his recent projects if Home Depot offered something similar. Allow the ability for people to build with individual parts from other pieces ala IKEA Hacking and I bet it would be really successful.