4 ms·
No, there is a whole news cycle about how chats you delete aren't actually being deleted because of a lawsuit, they essentially have to respond. It's not an att
by tptacek 1y ago
No, there is a whole news cycle about how chats you delete aren't actually being deleted because of a lawsuit, they essentially have to respond. It's not an attempt to spin the lawsuit; it's about reassuring their customers.
- VanTheBrand 1y agoThe part where they go out of the way to call the lawsuit baseless is spin though, and mixing that with this messaging does exactly that, presents a mixed message. The NYT lawsuit is objectively not baseless. OpenAI did train on the Times and chat gpt does output information from that training. That’s the basis of the lawsuit. NYT may lose, this could end up being considered fair use, it might ultimately be a flimsy basis for a lawsuit, but to say it’s baseless (and with nothing to back that up) is spin and makes this message less reassuring.
- tptacek 1y agoNo, it's not. It's absolutely standard corporate communications. If they're fighting the lawsuit, that is essentially the only thing they can say about it. Ford Motor Company would say the same thing (well, they'd probably say "meritless and frivolous").
- bee_rider 1y agoStandard corporate spin, then?
- tptacek 1y agoNo? "Spin" implies there was something else they could possibly say.
- justacrow 1y agoThey could choose to not say it
- ethbr1 1y agoIndeed. Taken to its conclusion, this thread suggests that corporations are justified in saying whatever they want in order to further their own ends. Including lies. I'd like to aim a little higher, maybe towards expecting correspondence with reality? IOW, yes, there is no law that OpenAi can't try to spin this. But it's still a shitty, non-factually-based choice to make.
- mmooss 1y agoI haven't heard that interpretation; I might call it spin of spin.
- mrgoldenbrown 1y agoIf you're being held at gunpoint and forced to lie, your words are still a lie. Whether you were forced or not is a separate dimension.
- inquirerGeneral 1y ago[dead]
- bee_rider 1y agoThat is unrelated to what the expression means.
- bunderbunder 1y agoNo, this isn't even close to spin, it's just a standard part of defending your case. In the US tort system you need to be constantly publicly saying you did nothing wrong. Any wavering on that point could be used against you in court.
- jmull 1y agoThis is a funny thread. You say "No" but then restate the point with slightly different words. As if anything a company says publicly about ongoing litigation isn't spin.
- bunderbunder 1y agoI suppose it's down to how you define "spin". Personally I'm in favor of a definition of the term that doesn't excessively dilute it.
- bee_rider 1y agoCan you share your definition? This is actually quite puzzling because as far as I know “spin” has always been associated with presenting things in a way that benefits you. Like, decades ago, they could have the show “Bill O’Rilley’s No Spin Zone” and everybody knew the premise was that they argue against guests who were trying to tell a “massaged” version of the story, and that they’d go for some actual truth (fwiw I thought the whole show was full of crap, but the name was not confusing or ambiguous). I’m not aware of any definition of “spin” where being conventional is a defense against that accusation. Actually, that was the (imagined) value-add of the show, that conventional corporate and political messaging is heavily spun.
- skissane 1y agoThere's a difference between "we are choosing to phrase it this way" versus "our lawyers told us we have to say this". "Spin" is generally seen as a voluntary action, which makes the former a clearcut case of it, the latter less so.
- adamsb6 1y agoI’m typing these words from a brain that has absorbed copyrighted works.
- mmooss 1y ago> It's not an attempt to spin the lawsuit; it's about reassuring their customers. It can be both. It clearly spins the lawsuit - it doesn't present the NYT's side at all.
- fallingknife 1y agoWhy does OpenAI have any obligation to present the NYTs side?
- mmooss 1y agoWho said 'obligation'?
- roywiggins 1y agoIt would be extremely unusual (and likely very stupid) for the defendant in a lawsuit to post publicly that the plaintiff maybe has a point.
- mhitza 1y agoMy understanding is that they have to keep chats based on an order, *as a result of their previous accidental deletion of potential evidence in the case*[0]. And per their own terms they likely only delete messages "when they want to" given the big catch-alls. "What happens when you delete a chat? -> It is scheduled for permanent deletion from OpenAI's systems within 30 days, unless: It has already been de-identified and disassociated from your account"[1] [0] https://techcrunch.com/2024/11/22/openai-accidentally-deleted-potential-evidence-in-ny-times-copyright-lawsuit/ https://techcrunch.com/2024/11/22/openai-accidentally-delete... [1] https://help.openai.com/en/articles/8809935-how-to-delete-and-archive-chats-in-chatgpt https://help.openai.com/en/articles/8809935-how-to-delete-an...
- conartist6 1y agoIt's hard to reassure your customers if you can't address the elephant in the room. OpenAI brought this on themselves by flaunting copyright law and assuring everyone else that such aggressive and probably-illegal action would be retroactively acceptable once they were too big to fail.
- ofjcihen 1y agoThey should include the part where the order is a result of them deleting things they shouldn’t have then. You know, if this isn’t spin. Then again I’m starting to think OpenAI is gathering a cult leader like following where any negative comments will result in devoted followers or those with something to gain immediately jumping to its defense no matter how flimsy the ground.
- gruez 1y ago>They should include the part where the order is a result of them deleting things they shouldn’t have then. You know, if this isn’t spin. From what I can tell from the court filings, prior to the judge's order to retain everything, the request to retain everything was coming from the plaintiff, with openai objecting to the request and refusing to comply in the meantime. If so, it's a bit misleading to characterize this as "deleting things they shouldn’t have", because what they "should have" done wasn't even settled. That's a bit rich coming from someone accusing openai of "spin".
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- ofjcihen 1y agoHere’s a good article that explains what you may be missing. https://techcrunch.com/2024/11/22/openai-accidentally-deleted-potential-evidence-in-ny-times-copyright-lawsuit/ https://techcrunch.com/2024/11/22/openai-accidentally-delete...