4 ms·
i think that the biggest problem is the potential for making places on our planet unsuitable to live in forever (for all practical purposes). people look at che
by baq 14y ago
i think that the biggest problem is the potential for making places on our planet unsuitable to live in forever (for all practical purposes). people look at chernobyl and see a place that will be dangerous to all life long after they're dead. they don't want that to happen again. fukushima is potentially the next such place, albeit on a lower scale.
the fact that radiation doesn't hurt doesn't help either. if our civilization ever falls, chernobyl will be a place cursed by gods.
- rbanffy 14y agoI don't think there are any Chernobyl-like reactors in operation today. Even if the design of reactors like ones at the Fukushima plant may be considered horribly flawed (they should be able to cool themselves passively, with no external power input whatsoever, after someone hits the scram button) the magnitude of the disaster is much smaller. An article posted here a couple days back mentions the hot zones around Fukushima are 3x less radioactive than downtown Denver. This is something to think about. Also, we must consider what other options we have for power generation. Can solar, wind and hydro generate all the power we need? How long until we can build economically viable fusion plants?
- wazoox 14y ago> An article posted here a couple days back mentions the hot zones around Fukushima are 3x less radioactive than downtown Denver. This is something to think about. Radiation is like cancer: one word to describe many different, related phenomenons. Denver radioactivity comes from radon, which is a relatively harmless gas as long as you allow it to disperse rapidly. OTOH pollution from nuclear accidents mainly comes from caesium which mimics calcium and get fixated on bones, thus provoking long, continuous, deep exposition to radiation.
- DennisP 14y agoTrue, but the decay products of radon are solid alpha-emitters that get lodged in people's lungs. And the comparisons to Fukushima are generally in terms of rem, which is already adjusted for biological effect.
- rbanffy 14y agoThe numbers quoted in the article were, IIRC, about cellular damage and aren't dependent of the isotope the person was exposed to. I agree some radioactive materials are much more dangerous than others and a noble gas has less chances of ending up in important molecules inside your body, but if the scale measures damage, not exposition, I assume they are equivalent.
- baq 14y agosolar can definitely fulfill any power requirements. the problem though isn't power generation but energy storage. if we had better batteries, we wouldn't be putting internal combustion engines in cars. gasoline is about two (or is it three? can't remember) orders of magnitude better at energy density than li-ion batteries. i strongly suggest reading this blog http://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/ http://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/.
- maxerickson 14y agoWhy not check: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RBMK http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RBMK There have been extensive (safety oriented) modifications to the design since the Chernobyl incident: http://www.world-nuclear.org/info/inf31.html http://www.world-nuclear.org/info/inf31.html The second article says the modified reactors account for almost 50% of Russia's nuclear power generation.
- rbanffy 14y agoThat's the point - the retrofitted reactors are much safer than the original design. Even if 10 are still in operation, they are much safer (and better staffed).
- maxerickson 14y agoI took "Chernobyl like" to mean "of the same design family".
- rbanffy 14y agoSorry. For me it means something that shares the design, the flaws and the criminally undertrained operators. While I wouldn't rate its current relatives as safe, at least they aren't disasters waiting to happen.
- pivo 14y agoDon't forget about Centralia, Pennsylvania (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centralia,_Pennsylvania http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centralia,_Pennsylvania) where an underground coal fire in a coal mine has been burning since 1962, making the town uninhabitable.