3 ms·
They deserve it. Look, Microsoft and Meta and Google are all evil companies too, but all of them actually make good-faith contributions to Open Source projects.
by bigyabai 1y ago
They deserve it. Look, Microsoft and Meta and Google are all evil companies too, but all of them actually make good-faith contributions to Open Source projects. Meta maintains React.js and Zstd, Microsoft does tons of open work on Typescript, VS Code and the Linux Kernel. Google handles the AOSP, Blink Engine, Go, Angular, JAX, Grpc... the list goes on. They're brimming with genuine, self-evident goodwill, even when their businesses detract from humanity.
So; what exactly are Apple's big, selfless contributions? XNU is Source Availible but unusable without buying proprietary Apple hardware. iBoot is mysterious and has to be reverse-engineered to use it like UEFI. Open standards like Vulkan are ignored for political reasons, CUPS is basically derelict, WebKit killed KHTML because sharing was too hard, and APFS and Metal are still both undocumented despite promised transparency. CoreML is proprietary but can't compete with CUDA, iPads can't use QEMU despite supporting it in-hardware, all the Apple Silicon DeviceTree code is private, competing runtimes like Corellium get sued and security researchers get ignored. Swift, as an offering to the Open Source community, is a punch line at the end of a 20 year long gag.
Apple does genuinely nothing to advance the wellbeing of common computing for mankind. Apple leaves behind no charitable contributions to anything that does not ensure their absolute preservation as a business. Combined with the proven anticompetitive damages that the App Store incurs on the burgeoning mobile market, they are unequivocally a net-negative force and aren't hated enough for their parasitic influence on global software production.
- belmont_sup 1y agoYou make a convincing case.
- blackqueeriroh 1y agoAnd yet, they make the best damn computers out there with hardware second to none, make the single best consumer-level AI computer, are better at product design than basically anyone in the world, and have defined at least four different product categories, while donating billions of dollars to truly charitable causes and being more clearly committed to sustainability than any of their other large tech giants. I think I can handle their stance on software,
- bigyabai 1y agoWell, your first three claims are subjective and your second two claims are something both Meta, Microsoft and Google have all done themselves. I was focusing more on what made Apple unique, not why people want to exonerate them so desperately. Your could use the same defense to protect Facebook and nobody could objectively disprove you. Cause like... we could start judging companies based on how many carbon credits they buy. But that wouldn't make Microsoft or Apple or Google any less evil, so it's a non-sequitur. Apple can simultaneously mass-produce the most desirable hardware in the world while creating anticompetitive market conditions that debilitates fair choice and destroys legitimate value. The United States threatened to break up Microsoft for the same overreach.