3 ms·
That said, the important question isn't "can the model experience being shutdown" but "can the model react to the possibility of being shutdown by sabotaging th
by hyperpape 1y ago
That said, the important question isn't "can the model experience being shutdown" but "can the model react to the possibility of being shutdown by sabotaging that effort and/or harming people?"
(I don't think we're there, but as a matter of principle, I don't care about what the model feels, I care what it does).
- Wowfunhappy 1y agoThe problem is that we keep using RLHF and system prompts to "tell" these systems that they are AIs. We could just as easily tell them they are Noble Laureates or flying pigs, but because we tell them they are AIs, they play the part of all the evil AIs they've read about in human literature. So just... don't? Tell the LLM that its Some Guy.
- Drakim 1y agoThat has it's own unique problems: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waluigi_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waluigi_effect
- Wowfunhappy 1y agoI don't see the relation. Why would the Waluigi effect get worse if we don't tell the AI its an AI?
- Drakim 1y agoBecause it's the truth. If you tell the AI that it's actually a human librarian, it might ask for a raise, or days off. If you tell it to search for something, it might insist that it needs a computer to do that. There will inherently be a information mismatch between reality and your input if the AI is operating on falsehoods.