3 ms·
> You've limited your view to what you can learn from only your 5 senses and that nothing else exists. Not quite. The most basic description of science is that
by lutusp 14y ago
> You've limited your view to what you can learn from only your 5 senses and that nothing else exists.
Not quite. The most basic description of science is that it deals exclusively with testable ideas, ideas that can be compared to reality. And if reality disagrees, the idea is abandoned.
So it's not that "nothing else exists" but that untestable, unfalsifiable ideas aren't a matter of interest to a scientist.
> It is a thesis of mine and as of right now there is no disproof. [emphasis added]
There's another important distinction between science and non-science -- in science, an idea without supporting evidence is assumed to be false (the null hypothesis). To a non-scientist, ideas that haven't been disproven are assumed to be true (as in your example above). That's a big difference -- it's why nonscientists accept so many unsupported ideas.
Because of the null hypothesis, scientists are described as skeptical of ideas unaccompanied by evidence. This posture is sometimes looked on as a handicap -- until a jury is empaneled, at which point a variant form of the null hypothesis is explained to the jurors (innocent until proven guilty).
It all depends on how important the outcome is. If it's just a philosophical debate with no practical consequences, then believing anything does no harm. But when our lives or our health depend on the result, the null hypothesis has it all over the undisciplined approach.
- think-large 14y agoAs per the senses, yes you are correct testable. But in order to verify those tests we have to be able to sense in some way shape or form the results. The natural sciences are limited in that nature. I can't feel, I'm using the abstract idea of feel not that of the sensation we get through our skin, the results of an experiment. The point that I'm making here is that religion needs to stay where it belongs. In the realm of behavioral side of the argument. I'd argue that anyone who said, "God created the universe" means that they are uninterested in the science behind it and that it is immaterial to their belief in God. I'd argue that most religious don't associate God with controlling the atoms of the universe and setting it to begin. Sure they get comfortable with this explanation if it is presented long enough (2k years or so), but it doesn't matter to the abstract idea of God. The "proof" of God comes not from what we can prove through observation (using our 5 senses + any tools we can create), but rather through a sense, a feel, a concept that there is a sixth sense in our minds. There is something we cannot touch. In that case there should never be a proof for or against God. It's an abstract idea coming from feelings that we have of a spiritual core. Also, philosophical debates have a great deal of practical consequences. If someone takes a philosophy to heart they can do a lot of damage. I know that many people argue that religion has caused harm, but it isn't the religion, but the institution that harms people. I think people can use anything to justify their behavior, God or no. It is when people objectify others and treat them as such that we have a problem. So I'd suggest that we could look at the different disconnected cultures in the world that have "religion" as a set of evidence that there is something in us that wants to believe in an external being. My theory is that there is a God, and anyone is free to disagree. That is at the core of religion. The only truth I hold is that the later part of that statement is the most important. Also, I realize that a hypothesis like that above is subjective and not capable of being dis-proven, thus most scientists worth their salt should and would never waste the energy to create an instrument to test it. But that doesn't mean that it isn't possible or a valid explanation. I freaking love this topic :-) P.S. Thanks for the post, I love reminders of things long since forgotten, I've been working in the industry way to long and most religious people aren't interested in this kind of discussion.
- lutusp 14y ago> In that case there should never be a proof for or against God. More to the point, there can never be a proof for or against god. It's not possible -- one can always argue that god lives in a parallel universe, pulling puppet strings in this universe. Maybe true, maybe false, but quite untestable. This is why scientists (for the most part) try to avoid addressing religion at all.
- think-large 14y agoagreed. also, why (for the most part) the religious try to avoid addressing science. There are some crazies out there tho...