3 ms·
In the time of Newton, there were numerous smart people trying to explain how gravity works. Newton's tremendous insight was that if he could develop a mathemat
by snowwrestler 14y ago
In the time of Newton, there were numerous smart people trying to explain how gravity works. Newton's tremendous insight was that if he could develop a mathematical model that accurately predicted the movement of objects under the influence of gravity, it would not matter whether he could explain "how" gravity works. It was the original "shut up and calculate" moment, and the birth of our modern conception of mathematical physics.
Science describes and predicts. Ultimately it cannot tell us "why"--or "should". These will always be the realm of philosophy and religion.
Where religious dogma contradicts proven scientific understanding, the religious dogma must yield. But I worry that in our zeal to resolve that conflict, scientifically-inclined people also end up attacking the sense of emotional awe that is at the heart of the religious experience. That's a shame because it is also at the heart of why many kids decide to go into science in the first place. Carl Sagan addressed this a bit in his book "Contact", in which he calls that emotional experience "the numinous".
- zerostar07 14y agoI am going to be provocative and say that there are scientists that actively try to expand into the other realm. After all philosophy and religion are products of the human brain activity, which is composed of cells, so why can't these functions be approached in a scientific way? To say that we will have to stop inquiring about it would be lazy
- lutusp 14y ago> philosophy and religion are products of the human brain activity, which is composed of cells, so why can't these functions be approached in a scientific way? That's easy to answer -- because they aren't subject to potential falsification, by way of comparison with reality. Scientific ideas, to merit the name, must be testable against reality, and if reality disagrees, the ideas must be discarded. Philosophy and religion don't have this property -- they (a) don't need to pass a reality test, and (b) in most cases they cannot pass a reality test. This is by design, not by accident -- if religion and philosophy had to meet this standard, their purpose (freedom to speculate about untestable things) would be undermined. > there are scientists that actively try to expand into the other realm. Perhaps, but not as scientists, only as individuals not doing science. And because science rejects authority, a scientist who philosophizes is just another philosopher, no better or worse than any other.
- zerostar07 14y agoWe might, by studying the human brain, figure out that as it functions it starts philosophizing and asking "why", even generating religious ideas. To me that would be enough to demystify and explain them away in a scientific (and falsifiable) way. In this sense, philosophy, religion, and science itself is subject to empirical examination. That's also what i meant by "expanding to the other realm", i mean using brain research to explain the biological basis behind major philosophical concepts such as free will [1]. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuroscience_of_free_will http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuroscience_of_free_will
- snowwrestler 14y agoWe can certainly examine the physical factors that lead to the human brain expressing and experiencing awe, morality, religious fervor, etc. But, that doesn't mean we should deny the power of those feelings in our human experience. After all they are the product of billions of years of evolution, and isn't that awe-inspiring in its own way?
- davrosthedalek 14y agoOne often hears the argument that science never can give a why, and only religion/philosophy can give that. In my opinion, this is simply not true. In this case, the Higgs mechanism explains, in some sense, why particles have mass (N.B., most of the mass you interact with is not generated by the Higgs, but by the dynamic generation of mass inside the nuclei). Of course, the next question is: where does this field come from, etc. etc. But the same you could do in religion. God created the universe. Fine. But where did God come from? And why? The only way religion can end this by postulating that these questions are "forbidden"/impossible. The other thing I am always wondering about is the mental step from accepting the existence of god(s) to following their perceived wishes. Most of us prefer democracy over following a king. Still, many choose to follow the indirect words of their god.
- think-large 14y agoThere are two very different whys here. One is based in the human psyche (God/philosophy) the other is based in our observations of the physical world. Also, that statement that most of us prefer democracy is not backed by any facts here. Is there a study on this? It sounds like a guess. I'd guess that most people don't care otherwise we'd have democracy everywhere.
- davrosthedalek 14y agoThere are also two very different group of answers to the questions. However, the point is that the never ending chain of why exists in both religion and science. The claim that religion can provide more than science in this regard is wrong. Regarding democracy: I actually meant to refer to the "western world". In general, democracy is certainly spreading: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy There is a nice plot of the number of nations with "democracy" vs. time below the heading 20th and 21st centuries. From the people I know, none of the those who believe in a God do not prefer democracy. That is certainly a biased group. And I think you have a point about "don't care", but if asked, I would say that most if not all of those friends would rather fight for democracy than their god.