3 ms·
"Why haven't we seen an explosion of new start-ups, products or features?" You're posting this question on a forum hosted by YC. Here's a story from March 202
by simonw 1y ago
"Why haven't we seen an explosion of new start-ups, products or features?"
You're posting this question on a forum hosted by YC. Here's a story from March 2024: "YC’s latest W24 batch includes 240 companies. A significant portion of the companies have some AI component, with 63% tagged as “Artificial Intelligence” — a notable increase from 51% in the preceding S23 batch and 29% before that.". https://jamesin.substack.com/p/analysis-of-ycs-latest-w24-batch https://jamesin.substack.com/p/analysis-of-ycs-latest-w24-ba...
I've not seen the same analysis for more recent batches.
- pera 1y agoSorry I don't follow, would you mind clarifying your point?
- creesch 1y agoNot the person you are asking to clarify. But, I can read it in two ways: 1. A huge part of the demographic group visiting HN is biased in favor of AI given the sort of startups YN decides to fund. 2. The large amount of start-ups funded by HN that are related to AI should answer your question. I am slightly leaning towards the first one combined with a little bit of the latter one. A lot of people working in startups will be used to building up a structure from scratch where incorporating the latest "thing" is not that big of a deal. It also means they rarely see the long term impact of the code they write. They have a huge blind spot for the reality of existing code bases and company structures where introducing these tools isn't as easy and code needs to be maintained for much longer.
- simonw 1y agoYou said "Why haven't we seen an explosion of new start-ups?" so I replied by pointing out that a sizable percentage of recent YC batches are new AI startups. I categorize that as "an explosion", personally. Do you disagree?
- pera 1y agoYeah I don't agree that having more start-ups checking a box saying that at least one of their component uses some form of AI indicates that we are experiencing a surge in new start-ups. The amount of start-ups getting into YC hasn't really changed YoY: The W23 batch had 282 companies and W24 260.
- simonw 1y agoThe YC acceptance number is a measure of how many startups YC has decided they can handle in a single batch. I think percentage of accepted startups doing X carries more information than total number of startups accepted as a whole.
- danShumway 1y ago> The YC acceptance number is a measure of how many startups YC has decided they can handle in a single batch. Agreed. > I think percentage of accepted startups doing X carries more information than total number of startups accepted as a whole. Disagreed, I think it carries almost no information at all. The only thing your analysis signifies is that companies believe that using AI will make YCombinator more likely to fund them. They are competing for a limited number of slots and looking for ways to appeal to YCombinator. And the only thing that signifies is that YCombinator, specifically, likes funding AI startups right now. This is not surprising. If you're an investment firm, funding AI companies is a good bet, in the same way that funding Web3 firms used to be a genuinely good bet. Investors ride market trends that are likely to make a company balloon in value or get bought out by a larger company. Investors are not optimizing for "what redefines the industry"; investors optimize to make a return on investment. And those are two entirely different things. But it's also not surprising given YCombinator's past - the firm has always kind of gravitated towards hype cycles. It would be surprising if YCombinator wasn't following a major tech trend. If you want evidence that we're seeing an explosion of companies, you need to look at something much more substantial than "YCombinator likes them". And that's especially given the case that OP wasn't asking "is the tech industry gravitating towards AI?" They were asking, "are we seeing an explosion of new economic activity?" And frankly, we're not. There are a lot of reasons for that which could have nothing to do with AI (tariffs and general market trends are probably a bigger issue). But we really aren't seeing the kind of transformation that is being talked about.
- maplant 1y agoI don't think that refutes the parent's point. So many AI companies, but where are the companies _using_ the AI?
- ndiddy 1y agoIt's also interesting how when you look at the websites for the new wave of AI B2B SaaS startups, most of the customers they list are other AI B2B SaaS startups. It makes me wonder how much of the "AI industry" is just startups sending VC money back and forth to each other.
- dabockster 1y agoProbably a large part of it, honestly. I was just talking with someone the other day about how the whole cloud economy for the past 15 years may have been grossly exaggerated by very loud VC backed companies flooding the internet with blog posts like this one. The big behemoths - hospitals, governments, law offices, manufacturers - those people tend to run a lot of local tech for various reasons. And they’re also the most quiet when it comes to the internet.
- computably 1y agoThat sounds like "working as intended." The main selling points of the cloud are liquidity and accessibility. VC-backed startups are basically the target demographic.