8 ms·
First employee or co-founder?
- Swizec 14y agoI love working with/for startups. But I have a very simple rule: Either I'm a cofounder, or I'm a freelancer[1]. If I really really like your idea, I will lower my rate. When you do the calculations, by the time there is an exit event even starting with 30% equity is barely worth it considering the exit size of most startups. For 1% equity ... few things under a google-sized exit will make you well off, most wont even come up to getting a market-rate salary. [1] I actually specialize in freelancing for startups and small businesses.
- alexatkeplar 14y agoThis. When founders bemoan the "talent crisis", they are really complaining about the shortage of people who are excellent coders/marketeers/whatever but have naively optimistic expectations of what their equity will be worth. It normally only takes one startup job for people to fall out of that Venn intersection. There's a third option if you can code and want to be involved in/profit from the startup scene: contract for big day rates somewhere like NYC or London, and angel invest your spare cash and tech mentor a basket of N startups. You will probably make better picks (and give saner advice) than most VCs.
- shalmanese 14y agoYou can only angel invest (right now) if you're an accredited investor which is a non-trivial barrier for a freelancing engineer to overcome.
- alexatkeplar 14y agoFor US or Canadian companies, you are correct. Happily in Europe we treat adults like, well, adults, and it's pretty common for non-1% people to angel invest in early stage companies. Foreign investors are welcome too - and I don't think even the SEC can stop you investing your money overseas.
- ideamonk 14y ago"Either I'm a cofounder, or I'm a freelancer" - +1 . I've started following this recently, it really keeps things simple and weeds off any chances of misbalance between 'your perception about your role' and 'their perception of your role' in the company.
- jrgnsd 14y agoHow do you find your clients? I'd like to do pretty much the same, but I have a hard time finding clients. I've been lurking on reddit/forhire and building up my network, but there hasn't been any big hits yet.
- arkitaip 14y agoThis strikes me as a mature approach to the issue. It's so common to be enchanted by the idea of working for a startup - especially if you're young - that you'll accept any type of deal, even if it sometimes means making so little money that you can't make ends meet.
- brudgers 14y ago>"When you do the calculations, by the time there is an exit event even starting with 30% equity is barely worth it considering the exit size of most startups." The article motivated me to go ahead and release my crude fuck you money calculator: http://fumoney.kludgecode.com/default.aspx http://fumoney.kludgecode.com/default.aspx
- tzaman 14y agoI'm the technical co-founder of my own startup (http://carmivore.com http://carmivore.com) and I can't say I agree with this one. See, developers are easy to find (yes, probably not the best ones, but since I'm a developer myself I know a good one when I see their code), and to get an MVP going, you don't really need a highly qualified expert, just someone that can build a relatively simple and stable app (or whatever), hell, even in PHP. And usually, first employees just don't share the passion for a startup in the same amount founders do, which means there's probably less self-initiative and less contributive to the product itself. So why should I offer equity to someone who I can easily replace (yes, everyone is replacable, but since it's my company I call the shots :)? At the end of the day, their job will only be transforming my thoughts into code. EDIT: On the other hand I agree that if I'm not sharing equity, the first employee should get proper salary.
- Swizec 14y ago> And usually, first employees just don't share the passion for a startup in the same amount founders do, which means there's probably less self-initiative and less contribution to the product itself. As someone once put it: Give me 1%, and you get 1% of me. Give me 10%, and I will be motivated. Give me 30%, and I will ask for 20 and work harder than you ever thought it was possible for a human being to work. PS: "At the end of the day, their job will only be transforming my thoughts into code." is a really really really bad signal to be giving. With that mindset you've probably made it onto the blacklist of most developers. The only ones you'll be able to get are the ones who can't get a job anywhere else. I'd really work on that attitude if I were you. Friendly advice as a Slovenian to a fellow Slovenian.
- tzaman 14y agoAnd what if I give you 30% and it turns out that you're not that good? Not worth the risk IMHO.
- Nikker 14y agoYou should probably know that before you start dealing with a prospective employee. If you are hiring quality people then it is definitely worth it. If you don't know for sure then you should not be hiring anyone.
- joewee 14y agoFrom my experience no amount of equity can make someone feel like a "owner." Either they are dedicated to making it work and sacrificing similarly like the person who developed the original concept, in which case they should be treated as a co-founder. Or they are in a holding pattern to "wait and see" in which case they should clearly be treated and paid like a contractor. Anything else just causes problems.
- realrocker 14y agoI did this as a first employee(software engineer). Crashed out in 4 months. One of my worst mistakes ever. Reasons: 1. It felt like most of the times, I am the only one building the product while the CEO(non-technical) was reading blogs and plotting strategy for a yet non-existent product. 2. The success and failure of the product somehow shifted to me, as I was the only guy actually building the product. Wouldn't have felt bad about it, if I was a co-founder. 3. Since, the other guy is now the boss, he would come up with strategic personal inputs to magically transform the product into a unicorn, without backing it with any arguments. This was the most frustrating thing. Now, I don't see how anyone can validate being a first employee for a start-up.
- nihonjon 14y ago"...while the CEO(non-technical) was reading blogs and plotting strategy for a yet non-existent product." "...he would come up with strategic personal inputs to magically transform the product into a unicorn, without backing it with any arguments." This is exactly why I will never again join a startup founded by a business guy with no technical background or willingness to learn.
- carleverett 14y agoI am in a very similar situation right now. Near graduation in the spring I joined a start-up I was really excited about as a sort of unpaid intern - I basically offered to help them out free of charge. Unlike the article though, I was not friends with the founders beforehand, I found out about them online. I was their first "employee" however. The two founders and I worked hard towards our product launch in July and it was a great success. Everyone loved the product, and it was obvious that I was now a vital part of the company, even though my title at that point was unpaid intern. Afterwards I brought up compensation for the first time. Knowing they wouldn't be able to afford a salary, I pitched 2% a month of equity for a year, ending with 24%. The problem thus far is that our product is a small airplane (gasp not tech!), which costs $55,000. Despite the tremendous positive feedback we've gotten on the plane, no one has pulled the trigger in the month since our launch (not a huge surprise since our financials have us starting out at 1 sale a month for our first year). It is enough however to make the two founders wary of how much equity to give as they have absolutely no clue what the current value of the company is. Our current deal is that I'm given a monthly stipend for a few months while we process some sales and get a better idea of what the company is worth, so that I can be compensated accordingly. I've been wary so far of considering myself a Co-Founder, since I took no part in the original idea or the funding for the company. From what this article is telling me though, I should absolutely be considering myself a co-founder. If this is the case, how much should I push for in terms of compensation? Is 24% a reasonable number to go after considering the facts? I'm trying to look out for my best interests but honestly just have no idea what I'm doing. Any advice from HN would be greatly appreciated. Thanks for the article.
- Swizec 14y agoIf you joined before the prototype of the product was built, and you worked full-time, you are a cofounder. Also, what's this company? Small aeroplane sounds exciting compared to HN's usual "next best todo app".
- carleverett 14y agohttp://www.skycraftairplanes.com http://www.skycraftairplanes.com - we're just selling kits now but we're pushing on being certified to sell ready to fly by this winter. What does a late-coming co-founder expect then in terms of equity in a typical company? Clearly I don't deserve 1/3, but I'll be my salary will be restricted to whatever minimal amount the other founders and I can survive off of until the company grows up.
- melissa_mccoy 14y agoI'll keep this in mind when I go search for my chief engineer next week.
- mattangriffel 14y agoThis is all ego. I know VCs that love giving away "co-founder" titles because they can often get away with giving less equity in exchange for the title.
- nihonjon 14y agoI'd sooner be called "janitor" and receive fair share than have a title and less. But your point is depressingly common, especially with the Rocket Internet CEOs/co-founders who receive less than 5% for anything the Samwer Brothers try cloning.
- tptacek 14y agoHow does a VC "give away a 'co-founder' title"? Investors don't set titles.
- adrianscott 14y agothey may have a role in selecting the CEO ;)
- nihonjon 14y agoI find most startup guys to be complete douchebags that just want to profit off the hard work of more competent and talented individuals. That or have the fancy title. This is based on two experiences of being the nice guy whose skills/connections were wanted. Shame on me for being trusting, I know.
- wrath 14y agoI joined my company as the first employee. I was the co-founder of other start-ups before joining my latest company and had hired "first employees" myself. So I understood the difference and knew what I was getting myself into. IMO, the choice depends on your personality, what you like to do, and where you are in your life. There are two key factors that made me accept the first employee offer. 1. As a co-founder you will need to take part in some of the administrative part of the company. Even if another one of the founders is taking care of the operations, there will always be things like board meetings, financing, taxes, etc. As a co-founder it has always been my opinion that you need to be interested in the operations. It's your duty to be informed as a co-founder. 2. Family. When I accepted my position I was a point in my life where I had two small children and a wife that wanted to pursue her own career. As a first employee I had the opportunity to "request" that my office hours were 9 to 5. It's not that I worked only 8 hours but that I didn't feel obliged to be in the office first and be the last to leave. My family was more important to me then being a co-founder. I'm currently the CTO of the company (360pi.com) I joined as the first employee. For me it was a great decision at the time. I spent more time with my wife and children, leaned a ton of new technologies, made lots of great friends and still got to live the life of a start-up. I think each individual has to make their own decision and that there's no one clear answer...
- rcamera 14y agoI've lived recently through a experience in which I failed to convince the founders into making me a co-founder. Two very successful entrepreneurs (with many successful exits, one of which worth hundreds of millions of dollars) invited me a couple months ago to join them to work in their idea. I started working part-time at first, getting to know them, and from day one, I stated I wanted to be their co-founder, not employee. I tried to stay part-time until I was more sure of how working with them would be like. We assembled a team, refined the vision and were then negotiating how everyone would join it, so we could build the MVP. I was ready to work full-time, but suddenly, they were trying to reason with me that % of equity doesn't matter, what matters is the number of shares you own, and tried to offer me a regular salary + options (not even a decent salary). I tried to convince them about why % matters, and why it was fair for me to get equity, but then they told me that this model doesn't work when they are the investors who are going to put millions of dollars into the company, having effectively the control of dilution over me. I proposed ideas that would take care of the dilution problem, but it was no good, they weren't really listening to me, using the same arguments over and over. This was the first red flag that raised in my head, and later, we started disagreeing on how to build the company (I was showing them how the Customer Development Model works, showed them the canvas from business model generation and all). I noticed they had very strong beliefs on how to do it, and weren't willing to discuss it with me. That's when the illusion popped and I noticed, I wasn't a co-founder, and ended up getting a call a week ago with them saying that "maybe I wasn't ready to face the risks of starting up" and that I shouldn't participate in the meeting later that day... It's a shame, I liked the team, and the idea was quite interesting, but no way I would put 4-6 years of my life into this without being a co-founder. In retrospect, I think that what caused our issues was mostly the fact that they never had another co-founder and all of their previous startups were bootstrapped. So when I asked equity, they likely saw it as too risky, even though we worked together and they saw my determination and skills.
- chimi 14y agoOne of the biggest differences between cofounder and employee is the direction of money flow. If you're putting money in and working, you're a cofounder. If you're taking money out as a salary you're an employee. It sounds to me like you were an employee.
- michaelochurch 14y agoThe problem with most of these "business guys" is that they think their connections deserve to trade at a ridiculous level relative to talent, skill, and effort. Technical skill, to them, makes you a JAP (Just A Programmer) but not "founder material". It's the country-club mentality. I'll admit that there's room for negotiation in an exchange rate (I'd prefer pure meritocracy, but sadly that's not how the world actually works) between connections and talent, but the people who think their connections (usually inherited on account of having a prominent father and going to the right MBA school) entitle them to a ridiculous share of the profits are just exhausting to deal with and, in my experience, most of them aren't nearly as well-connected as they claim to be. If you're so well-connected, then why aren't you funded already? If you honestly believe that your connections merit 10+ times the share that my talent and skill do, then you better prove it by getting me in a room with the likes of top venture capitalists, CEOs at target clients, and heads of state on a weekly basis (and then, after a year or two, unless you treat me extremely well, I'll be independent and start my own show).
- jpwagner 14y agomost of these "business guys" who are you talking about? this is a gross generalization.
- kops 14y agoI guess anyone who can't write code but earns more than a programmer ;-)
- tomstokes 14y agoLook at it this way: A good "business guy" is going to be a shrewd negotiator, using every trick in the book to maximize the value of your company in every deal. S/he will go to great lengths to make your company look bigger, more capable, and like an excellent fit in every introduction, meeting, and potential sale. However, every one of those negotiating skills is going to also be put to use when negotiating salary and equity split with your company. It's a double-edged sword. I don't buy into the notion that business-minded people undervalue engineering talent in general. Sure, there are plenty of anecdotes otherwise, but the savvy business people know exactly what engineering talent is worth. However, that doesn't mean they won't still try to maximize their own share of the company's equity and payroll. Meanwhile, they have every incentive to minimize the amount of equity and salary handed out to engineering talent so they can hire as many people as possible without spending a dollar more than necessary. It's not personal, it's just business. I'm not suggesting it's right, of course. Learning good negotiation skills and how to sell yourself well will go a long way to leveling the playing field.
- polshaw 14y agoI'm on the 'founder' side of this. I'm a lone founder and would dearly love to bring in a 'co-founder' or employee to work with.[1] The problem is that i have worked for a long time, progressed a lot, and have a strong vision of what i want to end up with[2], there is no way on this earth i would give up 50% of that to someone because they were a great programmer/EE (and i don't know anyone personally who i feel would be able to add significant value, or i would have brought them in earlier). I also have the vision of what the business could become, far beyond the first product, so i value it a lot higher than any outsider would[3]. So what choice does that leave me? I can't imagine anyone willing to work 1-on-1 for a significantly minor steak. Opinions here consistently make it clear that a small stake is considered almost worthless[4].. so it seems to me the only option is struggle on alone, and eventually give a salary[5] by whatever means possible, perhaps preceded by an intern if i find someone interested. What does HN think? 1. there is a reason 'co-founder' almost supersedes the word founder around here.. working on a big project on your own is an absolute bitch. 2. working on a product, with HW and SW components, not 'just a website'. 3. which is also why i haven't sought any investment yet. 4. you may be thinking '99% of startups fail', but i am thinking 'i know i will suceed'. 5. i need a competent programmer to free up my time for other things and bounce ideas off, not a 'superstar'
- josephlord 14y agoThe risk that you are taking is that you will end up with 100% of nothing. If you are already in 'struggle on' mode I would re-evaluate the plan to achieve the goal. This comment also assumes that you don't have cash to bring to the table otherwise you would have hired someone already. It really sounds like you need some help so either you need to offer sufficient equity (less than 50% as you have already come a long way although probably more than 20% [over time] unless you are already near launch) to a co-founder OR seek investment which would enable you to hire a contractor. Either way you would need to convince someone of your concept (investor or co-founder) and your personal value to the business. If hardware is required you will need investment at some stage. Kickstarter may also be an option for you if the project is likely to be sufficiently popular but you really need to work out what you are promising first and be prepared to make it public.
- akldfgj 14y ago> If you read this far you should probably follow me on twitter I thought this fad was dead.