4 ms·
The way the periodic table is arranged depends on choices made by humans. It could just as easily be a simple list (your first description was 'all elements not
by vacri 14y ago
The way the periodic table is arranged depends on choices made by humans. It could just as easily be a simple list (your first description was 'all elements nothing between') with no groupings. What distinguishes elements is the number of protons - the choice to then arrange the periodic table by other attributes is a human one, just like the choice to label creatures with six legs 'insects' is a human one.
and all your experience is with what they call "soft sciences"
Ah, the meat of the problem. You're prejudiced against disciplines outside of physics.
- ars 14y ago> the choice to then arrange the periodic table by other attributes is a human one No it's not. The arrangement is determined by the structure of the atom - specifically the electron orbital. I'm assuming you didn't know this? It's not arbitrary at all, elements in the same column are very similar chemically, and can take each others place in many chemical reactions. > Ah, the meat of the problem. You're prejudiced against disciplines outside of physics. Prejudiced? Really? If you are going to practice science you have to do it properly, physics does, so do many other disciplines. Some don't. It's not because they are evil - they have no other choice, they do as good a job as possible with the limitations they have. I don't hold it against them, but at the same time they don't have the same status as those that do, the results from those disciplines can never be considered definitive. And for many of them, it's not science, it's history. And you appear not to even know any physics, and so you think everything is like what you know, and have no idea how it can be when done properly. It's a form of the Dunning–Kruger effect - you don't even realize what you don't know, so you think everyone doesn't know.
- vacri 14y agoTo beat a dead horse (been away a few days), the periodic table is still chosen to be grouped that way. I know what you're saying about the structure of the table, but it's still been chosen to be arranged that way, just like declaring 'six legs = insect' is in taxonomy. Similarly, the 'horned' appearance of it is a human decision to help with the grouping. You could just as easily have H and He right next to each other and each new line representing a shell be arranged the same way. The problem is that you're not seeing the forest for the trees. Perhaps another angle: if the periodic table is defined by the structure of the atom, why is there no representation of neutrons? Neutrons are part of the atom, and though an element is able to have differing numbers of neutrons, there is no indication of this in the layout of the table. the results from those disciplines can never be considered definitive You seem to have a lexical problem here: in one breath, you demand that science is definitive ("it can't be science if it's not"), but in another you state that defining things is cataloguing, not science. And you appear not to even know any physics, I know a moderate amount of physics (certainly enough that hollywood films drive me nuts, and I spent several years as a medical scientist), mostly in the form of chemistry, but you're showing all the typical signs of someone who is clueless about the actual practise of "soft sciences" and is running off prejudice. There is plenty of good science in fields like psychology; just because the brain doesn't work like particle physics doesn't mean that you can't have the falsifiable hypotheses that lutusp demands. There is plenty of shoddy science in psychology as well, sure. But that doesn't mean that you can simply discount the good stuff - that's a logical fallacy :)