7 ms·
LibriVox
- Moosdijk 1y agoI wonder if AI will be a benefit or a detriment to this project. On the one hand, there’s going to be a lot more, potentially high quality audio books in its repository, on the other hand it goes against the spirit of the project itself.
- woodson 1y agoThe speech data collected by this project has been used for more than a decade to build automatic speech recognition and text-to-speech synthesis systems (see LibriSpeech, LibriTTS, LJSpeech). It definitely has been a benefit to AI.
- joshstrange 1y agoI think they are talking more about the impact of AI on Librivox, as in people running an ebook through an AI TTS tool and uploading it. On one hand, a well curated/edited AI recording might be great but a lot of people will (try? Idk their policies) to upload AI slop (no proof-listen, no checking, just laziness).
- woodson 1y agoI think that, for the purposes of creating high-quality Free audiobooks, the issues are essentially the same with human-generated recordings as with AI generated ones. The recording quality and faithfulness to the original text (both in terms of “content” and the appropriate reading in terms of tone, expression of emotion, etc.) have to be verified. The problem is scale. There will be many more TTS-generated recordings uploaded than human-generated ones. Some automated filters (e.g., ASR WER, audio quality metrics) would be a great first step to discard bad-quality slop right away (though it might unfairly penalize real human accented speech). Importantly, the recording should indicate whether it was human or AI generated.
- username223 1y ago> Importantly, the recording should indicate whether it was human or AI generated. This is all that's necessary. Sometimes I'm fine with mediocre TTS; sometimes I want an actual professional; librivox is somewhere in between, but should clearly specify whether I will be getting an amateur human or a robot.
- swores 1y agoI disagree, for the reasons stated by the person you replied to. Historically, being told that a voice recording is AI generated would be enough to tell you to expect basic TTS robotic voice, but with advances in AI voice generation we're approaching the point where AI can sound as good as real humans - it's not yet to the point where it's easy to generate an audiobook as good as a professional reader, but that point will come in the not too distant future. And equally on the other side, something being recorded by a human doesn't automatically mean it has the quality of a professionally-read audiobook. This is something LibriVox has always had to deal with, by gatekeeping which volunteer recordings to either give feedback requesting improvements to or to not use at all. In some but not all cases, an amateur human reader can already be as good as a professional, that will soon be true for AI. For both AI and humans it will remain the case that some efforts are not as good, but the line between them (for quality) isn't going to be whether or not they are AI - though I do agree that AI or not should also be labelled.
- username223 1y agoCertainly TTS has improved a lot thanks to modern AI, but it simply doesn't have the information to improve beyond sounding like a human reading words fluently. A professional audiobook reader modulates his tone to reflect narrative mood, chooses voices for the characters consistent with their natures, etc., and transformer models can't do those things. For an example of a professional audiobook, check out Rob Inglis' version of The Lord of the Rings.
- swores 1y ago
- kristopolous 1y agoI imagine there's various disabilities where audio readings greatly simplify people's lives. They're probably appreciative of anything accurate regardless of whether it's humans talking or not.
- UmYeahNo 1y agoWell, you can safely assume that everything in Librivox was used to train the AI. So, "benefit" or "detriment"... you make the call.
- spudlyo 1y agoI'd like to think that in the future this will be possible, but at present I believe there are still too many uncanny valley problems for me to regard any TTS generated audio books as high quality. I can sometimes tolerate listening to articles or technical essays done this way, but quality audio book narrators often do consistent and distinct character voices, understand complex emotional states, and are capable of reacting to contextual clues and subtext. This seems like a pretty high bar for current TTS models. Something like NotebookLLM seems shockingly good at first, and gives me hope that eventually we'll have machines that are nearly as good as humans at this; but after listening to it for an hour or so the novelty wore off and the artifice of it now seems galling and distracting.
- bookofjoe 1y ago>quality audio book narrators often do consistent and distinct character voices, understand complex emotional states, and are capable of reacting to contextual clues and subtext. The best experience I've ever had with audio books is John le Carré reading his early novels (not in public domain). He uses a different voice for each character and they are SO pulsing with life it's breathtaking.
- spudlyo 1y agoThanks for the tip! I love well narrated audiobooks, and I've been meaning to get into one of le Carré's books for a while. I see he narrates the "John le Carré Value Collection" on Audible which has Tailor of Panama, Our Game, and Night Manager for a single credit. Is that what you're referring to? Along those lines, there is a great 2007 unabridged audiobook[0] of Frank Herbert's Dune that is read by Simon Vance for narration, but other characters are dramatically performed by other voice actors. It's excellent, but sadly a tad bit uneven and inconsistent in production. It's like they got 3/4ths of the way through the project and some of the original voice actors couldn't complete the project and Vance had to pick up the slack. Regardless, it's still one of my favorite audiobooks. [0]: https://libro.fm/audiobooks/9781427201447-dune https://libro.fm/audiobooks/9781427201447-dune
- 1y ago
- SubGenius 1y agoI've enjoyed quite a few very well narrated audiobooks on LibriVox. The Jane Austen novels voiced by Karen Savage are phenomenal.
- towledev 1y agoHaven't listened to Librivox in years and years, but I still fork over the annual $2.99 because I feel I owe it. It's horizon-broadening. Lots and lots of interesting reads/listens I never would've picked up otherwise. 1800s ghost stories, darkly racist novels like The Leopard's Spots (good luck getting through the first 10 pages). My favorite is Havelock the Dane: A Tale of Old Grimsby, first written circa the 14th century but thought to be much older. When you listen to it, it is apparent that the author and the intended audience know 100x more about nautical things than you do. It's also charmingly simplistic; the main character is sort of like Conan the Barbarian. He'll do things like "lift a stone the weight of an ox and throw it the length of two men." You imagine the audience being like, "Oh my fucking god.... that's amazing."
- Nopoint2 1y agoElizabeth Klett is good too.
- hombre_fatal 1y ago[flagged]
- hagbard_c 1y agoNo, this is fine for what this is, essentially a library catalogue. I prefer this over the pushy this is what others are reading type of interface as I tend to access these catalogues knowing what I'm looking for. If I want to know what others are reading/listening to I'll go to a book recommendation site or forum and take it from there. Library catalogues should be neutral, just show what is on offer and leave the popularity contest to others.
- hombre_fatal 1y agoBut you already have a search box and alphabetical list if that's what gets you excited. What about the rest of us? Building a featured or popular section is basic UX and creates a nice call to action to let the visitor see what they can expect without browsing to see if the site has any books they want. Even my local library puts more work into their homepage with a featured reads section. So disappointing when nobody cares about UX or holds minority HNer views like "a featured list on the homepage is bad and pushy–I quite like alphabetical lists myself".
- mxuribe 1y agoMaybe your comments didn't meant to come off like those people who complain about volunteer efforts, and maybe you legitamately meant them in goodwill...but, have you considered submitting this as feedback directly at the project - instead of on HN? What might seem obvious to you, may not seem obvious to the *volunteers* of this effort. (Or, maybe they address this aspect within their forums - i honestly don't know?) Maybe send some feedback and suggestions - in a respectful manner - to the volunteers who manage this effort, so that, they can consider your suggestions?
- hombre_fatal 1y agoHey, maybe you're right about that. I was feeling pretty mischievous when I made that original comment. If someone were to do that, one idea is to pitch is that they can inline some different LibriVox recommendation lists on the homepage: https://www.google.com/search?q=librivox+book+recommendations https://www.google.com/search?q=librivox+book+recommendation... Doesn't even involve a DB query. Maybe store 10 lists in JS/HTML and randomly pick one on every homepage page load. For a project that depends on thousands of hours of donated content from strangers, 10 minutes of work on the homepage to promote some high quality donations isn't a big ask. That's a decent thing to remind them of when they resist the suggestion.
- dlcarrier 1y agoI once couldn't find the audiobook of a book that my book club was reading, and it was a long book at I didn't have time to set aside to solely reading. It turned out that there weren't any commercially produced audiobooks of it, but it was public domain, and I found it on LibriVox. The book was long and boring, but at least the narrating was good.
- waltbosz 1y agohttps://librivox.org/the-adventures-of-sherlock-holmes-version-4-by-sir-arthur-conan-doyle/ https://librivox.org/the-adventures-of-sherlock-holmes-versi... David Clarke does a very good narration of many Sherlock Holmes stories.
- begemotz 1y ago"This is a libravox recording. All libravox recordings are in the public domain..." I contributed to a Robert Lynd project on libravox many years ago, and I still remember saying these intros. (Lynd was a wonderful essayist, if anyone might be interested).
- WillAdams 1y agoOne of my favourite novels, H. Beam Piper's _Little Fuzzy_ is in the public domain (because he died intestate and the Commonwealth of Pa. failed to renew his copyrights before they were turned over to his estate). There is a professional-quality reading of it by Tabithat: https://librivox.org/little-fuzzy-by-h-beam-piper/ https://librivox.org/little-fuzzy-by-h-beam-piper/ which I recommend highly. Unfortunately, the quality of the readings can vary widely, and my family has often been unwilling to put up with a poor quality recording on long trips. That said, I use their app on my phone while doing boring tasks at work, and greatly appreciate the project.
- rectangleboy 1y ago> Unfortunately, the quality of the readings can vary widely . . . I tried LibriVox in college to listen to difficult-to-understand poems (at the professor's recommendation) on my iPod and my ears couldn't take the harsh plosives that nearly every recording I tried had.
- WillAdams 1y agoThere is a collection of different authors reading Coleridge's "Kublai Khan" which is a great way to get an experience of a lot of different readers and possibly find one you like. For my part, I'm grateful that folks volunteer their time and energy, and when there is only one reader for a given text, accept it.
- Der_Einzige 1y agoIt really is the e-book version of trying to do "netflix n chill" with FOSS. It's sad that the best tech projects are not useful to normies.
- nl 1y agoI don't think "netflix n chill" means what you think it does.
- 1y ago
- abawany 1y agoFWIW they now accept donations via the Internet Archive: https://wiki.librivox.org/index.php?title=Donate https://wiki.librivox.org/index.php?title=Donate .
- photochemsyn 1y agoA real gem is the Adrian Praetzellis reading of Kim by Rudyard Kipling: https://librivox.org/kim-by-rudyard-kipling/ https://librivox.org/kim-by-rudyard-kipling/
- theschmed 1y agoAnother site, which includes a smaller but more professionally curated set of recordings, is Lit2Go (https://etc.usf.edu/lit2go/books/ https://etc.usf.edu/lit2go/books/). My children and I for example have greatly enjoyed Lorraine Montgomery’s recording of “Curly and Floppy Twistytail”, a series of delightful nonsense stories performed with gusto. (https://etc.usf.edu/lit2go/183/curly-and-floppy-twistytail-the-funny-piggie-boys/ https://etc.usf.edu/lit2go/183/curly-and-floppy-twistytail-t...) They’re not all aimed at children either, high quality recordings of Dracula, David Copperfield, etc
- Min0taur 1y agoOhhh, I never thought I'd see FCIT/lit2go mentioned on HN! I used to work in the sound booth for lit2Go, it was one of my favorite jobs. We had some wonderful vocal talent come through, and I learned much of what I know about recording/mixing from that work.The people in charge of organizing that project were diligent/earnest to the point of sainthood. They have quite a few historic stereo-views scattered around their open source pic site, I always enjoyed browsing those with my 3d shades on: https://etc.usf.edu/clippix/search?q=stereoview https://etc.usf.edu/clippix/search?q=stereoview (They had more than this search would suggest; hopefully they're still around...)
- Tryk 1y agoElisabeth Klett is phenonmenal, way beyond any professional recording I've purchased. https://librivox.us/search.jsp?search=reader%3A%22Elizabeth+Klett%22 https://librivox.us/search.jsp?search=reader%3A%22Elizabeth+...
- miki123211 1y agoI wonder if we could make LibriVox, but with Eleven Labs. Sure, Eleven Labs isn't anywhere near as good as professional narration (yet), but it's better than your average Librivox reader for sure. At this point, it's just a matter of throwing money at the problem (and not that much money at that), and that's usually easier than finding talent.
- parkersweb 1y agoI think Eleven Labs has essentially done that already with ElevenReader haven’t they?
- Deprogrammer9 1y agohttps://librivox.org/anarchy-by-errico-malatesta/ https://librivox.org/anarchy-by-errico-malatesta/ this is the way.
- spookie 1y agoI really appreciate the existence of this project and all people who have contributed to it. I want to contribute a reading of a book someday in my native tongue, as it is slowly dying (less than 1k speakers). A way of preserving it.
- rendall 1y agoWhat is it?
- Greta4Gaza 1y ago[flagged]
- spookie 1y agoI fear it would be too personally identifiable lmao It's within the EU though
- bArray 1y agoI think there needs to be a way to apply multiple filters, i.e. I want Science Fiction and to listen in English. It would be good to also be able to combine with keywords too.