3 ms·
todsacerdoti is a real person, we've been in contact with him, and after mulling it over several years ago (not for several years, but several years ago!) we de
by dang 1y ago
todsacerdoti is a real person, we've been in contact with him, and after mulling it over several years ago (not for several years, but several years ago!) we decided that HN is better off with these submissions than without them. He has contributed many constructive and fascinating threads to HN.
In fact, IIRC I asked him to stop at one point (which he was totally fine with) and then changed my mind after looking closer, because many of these articles are so good for HN. Of course, when the author of an article also posts it (as was the case with the OP), or when some less prolific submitter posts it, then we want that person's post to "win", but this doesn't always happen.
I wonder if we could write some code to catch this when it does happen, and then maybe we could have the best of both worlds or at least a chunk of it.
- Y_Y 1y agoMr. Gackle, you're a credit to yourself, and a hero to the rest of us. I did something pretty lazy by taking the poster's recent submissions, seeing if they were posted to lobste.rs earlier, and how often. Here's an slightly updated version of the stochastic parrrot excrement code I gave to a sibling thread: https://pastebin.com/gFgBVkC4 https://pastebin.com/gFgBVkC4 Fwiw you're giving no credence to the theory espoused here that you don't actually read every post.
- aspenmayer 1y ago[flagged]
- pvg 1y agoThey likely have other bots that remain undetected. Why is this 'likely'?
- aspenmayer 1y ago> > They likely have other bots that remain undetected. > Why is this 'likely'? Is it more likely that a person that didn’t make the first bot also has a second that they didn’t make, or less likely? Is it more likely that a known bot user who has a working successful bot might make multiple bots in order to arrive at the working one we see, or less likely? I don’t think it’s likely that fully formed organisms would appear, but it could happen. I think evolution is more likely. Of course it’s possible that they have been detected, and the acts simply attributed to others, or allowed under the same reasoning as the first.
- pvg 1y agoIs it more likely that a person that didn’t make the first bot also has a second that they didn’t make, or less likely? It's hard to tell without assuming some sort of malicious or disruptive intent of which there isn't any evidence.
- aspenmayer 1y agoWe don’t need further evidence of generalities to determine that there was a distinct negative impact in this specific case. OP posted their original content and the automated poster got the karma. We don’t even need to understand how we got here to see that where we are isn’t where we thought we were or where we’d intended to end up. Where do we go from here? To continue doing this would be walking in circles. Surely the users of HN deserve better. Bot posters ought to mark their accounts or posts as such, and HN should expose that information to the community, when definitively known, as in this case. Anything less would be a disservice to the community, although I’m open to being convinced otherwise. I just felt for OP, and one silver lining is that this post at least came good.
- pvg 1y agoWe don’t need further evidence of generalities to determine that there was a distinct negative impact Seems like we would, given that the moderator comment above says the opposite - there's evidence of positive impact.
- aspenmayer 1y agoI don’t think that HN is hurting for posts or posters. In the same vein of fairness, I’d rather 100 bots banned than a single human poster sidelined by an automated system. We’re talking about a specific post and poster being scooped by a bot, and it’s happened before, and apparently will happen again, from the same automated poster.