11 ms·
Atari Means Business with the Mega ST
- rbanffy 1y agoSomeone should make the Atari ST Max built into that keyboard. And with emulated VME graphics, with an HDMI output and a USB-C port. And 3-button mouse. Able to run Atari Unix.
- alexisread 1y agoSo many missed opportunities with the ST, given the breakneck development speed. If the all-in-one design was used from the off (save on moulds and shipping disc drives) they could done a pro conversion kit: https://youtu.be/atw3FYKzog4 https://youtu.be/atw3FYKzog4 Also, move the joystick ports to the right rather than under the keyboard. A few tweaks here and there would have pushed it a lot more: Unified clocks for genlock and scrolling: https://youtu.be/yexNdSLEpIY?si=pa46sJOr_9Fin4LC https://youtu.be/yexNdSLEpIY?si=pa46sJOr_9Fin4LC Stereo output like the CPC464: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=0yY4BlPfLf4 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=0yY4BlPfLf4 AMY included, along with a 1bit PWM on the DMA chip for DMA sound. The ST had a janky RTC anyway: https://atariage.com/forums/topic/303859-battery-pack-inside-520-st https://atariage.com/forums/topic/303859-battery-pack-inside... 3 button joypads from the start, using U+D and L+R combinations for 2 more buttons Double-sided drive from the start. Finally, they should have included the blitter socket and a full 2x32pin expansion instead of the cartridge port. The blitter socket especially would be handy to drive a T212 transputer in 87, when the blitter was available, instead of producing the ATW.
- bravesoul2 1y agoIt's good enough for Fatboy Slim
- TacticalCoder 1y agoThe Atari ST had a MIDI port: that notoriously lacked on the Commodore Amiga (I think an Amiga with a stock MIDI port would have been a homerun). I saw Atari ST in music studios well into the late 90s/early 2000s because back then quiet beige PCs weren't a thing yet: PCs virtually all came with super noisy fans, which was a big no-no for music studios. A buddy would bring his Korg synth to my neighbour's house and hook it to their Atari ST. Another dude I remember would play drums from Dire Straits song from his Atari ST hooked to some MIDI gear and then he'd take his guitar and play Dire Straits songs. These were the days. I'm not surprised some musicians still use them. If I'm not mistaken Kavinsky (who became famous after the movie Drive came out but recently had renewed interest for he performed at the Olympics games' ceremony) started doing music at a late age, on an Atari ST a friend of his game him. As an anecdote PCs were so noisy that I asked my neighbour (an electrical engineer) if it was possible to come up with a system where the fan would slow down when the CPU wasn't too hot: and sure enough we were then modding our PSUs with "thermistors" and we'd be calibrating our tiny hack, no shit, with boiling water in the kitchen (ah clueless teenagers). Funnily enough about 10 years later every single PSU had variable fan speed. That's the thing: we were used to quiet 8-bit and then 16-bit computers and when we had to move to these piece-of-shit PCs (but with fast CPUs / FPUs and that were upgradeable), we had to endure these painful ultra noisy CPU/PSU fans (and HDDs). So the Atari ST just made sense. You could have these super fast (compared to Atari ST) PCs but they were noisy, fugly, piece of unbearable shits that the cool guys in music studios simply wouldn't tolerate back then. Now of course at some point PCs became just too good and several brands started focusing on quietness and it was then possible to have a totally silent PC, both looking cool and being literally cool (big heatsink, quiet fans, etc.). But yeah the Atari ST was and still is certainly for some a thing for creating music. Lots of respect to the Atari ST for his MIDI port (and that comes from a Commodore Amiga owner and fan).
- Aldipower 1y agoAnd, just to add a third point, the Atari runs stable! I just tried to sequence with a SoundBlaster AWE32 and Voyetra MIDI Orchestra MIDI Sequencer under Windows 95b. For fun. I already recorded some MIDI tracks, then suddenly after 60 minutes Windows presented me with the famous bluescreen. Everything I've just recorded and didn't autosave lost. Haha.
- grumpyprole 1y agoAbsolutely, when I first tried Windows Cubase in the 90s, it wasn't long before it ate all my data. Even today's DAWs still haven't caught up with the original ST Cubase in terms of stability.
- hnlmorg 1y agoTo be fair, everything about PCs back then sucked. DOS was crap, when you had tGEM and Amiga OS. Windows 1 and 2 was beyond terrible. They were shit for games They were bulky They were slow They crashed all the time. They were ugly They were noisy. They were hard to manage (autoexec.bat, no OS in ROM, stupidly tricky partitioning tools, incompatible drivers for the same hardware but in different applications, etc) But IBM lost control of the hardware market so they became cheap, ubiquitous crap. And that’s literally the only reason we got stuck with PCs.
- TheOtherHobbes 1y agoThe PC industry of the late 80s was a disaster. We had affordable windowing and GUIs on the Atari and the Amiga, with instant boot from ROM and tons of RAM. The Amiga had the beginnings of multitasking and hardware acceleration for graphics and sound. Then suddenly the industry decided to go back to a cut-down version of late 70s S-100 computing, with insanely unaffordable prices, crippled specs, bizarre semi-manual memory management, ugly hardware, and a command line interface that was basically CP/M but not as good. Infuriating.
- microtonal 1y ago
- rbanffy 1y ago> move the joystick ports to the right I think they’d be better on the back unless you are supposed to plug them out all the time. > Finally, they should have included the blitter socket That would be hard without having a functioning one first. The blitter would be also handy for a number of things, from PCM sound to network and disk transfers.
- alexisread 1y agoOn the right (ie. Mirror of the STE 15pin ports) would mean that they could keep the electrical layout ie. Connected to the keyboard, and hence a separate keyboard unit. For 2 player games you would be swapping it a lot- there were adapters just to help with this. I agree it would be difficult to design a correct socket, but from interviews it was always the plan to have a blitter, and a socket as standard would have helped adoption. The main thing is that the T212 is a great coprocessor, faster than the 68881 fpu and with a 2k cache. Introducing the transputer as a coprocessor would potentially have changed the computing landscape
- msk-lywenn 1y agoU+D for a button means you can’t go up or down at the same or is there a trick?
- msephton 1y agoI think what was meant was using fire+directions to trigger additional virtual buttons. Many games did this in software anyway.
- alexisread 1y agoJust that you can't go up and down at the same time, so it's a valid electrical signal for another button, and importantly standard so games would take advantage of it.
- toast0 1y agoSure, but if U+D is button 2, you can't register up or down and button 2 together. You need another wire, a serial protocol, or whatever sega did for the 6-button genesis/mega drive controller (i think a toggle?)
- brulard 1y agoThis would be my question as well. If i go up, and pressing this button 2, then the output signal does not know if i'm going up or down or none of those.
- alexisread 1y agoThe code will be polling the input, so it's effectively quantized, and games can treat movement as a vector. Seems to work ok: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=atHTzwcx4Og https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=atHTzwcx4Og Obviously it'd be better to have a protocol like the megadrive, but given the setup in the ST, this is a hack without having to change the ST hardware.
- cmrdporcupine 1y agoI mean the whole point of the ST was "rock bottom price" and a lot of the things you're talking about would have raised the BOM significantly, or delayed its introduction by precious few weeks or months. Beating the Amiga to market, and beating it on price were super important. But I do think there was a serious problem with follow through. The Blitter and GDOS and then the STe came too long to come after. The Blitter never became standard, and the games and software suffered for it. And updates on the operating system were slow and thin until it was way too late. I do agree that the cartridge port thing -- it being limited to 128kB expansion -- was needless. One more pin, even, would at least allow for a proper OS upgrade via cartridge port! Definitely one of the stupidest design decisions on the machine.
- alexisread 1y agoYou have a point, but the ST bottleneck during development appeared to be the software, so there was possibly space for hardware tweaks. The BOM would go up slightly but remember they would have saved on developing and shipping a separate disk drive which would cover a lot of these changes. Realistically it's amazing the ST was as good as it was, given the 6 month development time and the kings of penny pinching at the helm :)
- tom_ 1y agoThe tiny ST with the external disk drive had the joystick ports at the side - a far superior design. I quite liked the STe. The mono monitor was great, RAM upgrades were easy, and they'd improved some of the display hardware's worst limitations. Even though TOS was never especially good, they'd fixed all the worst bits by that point. Still could have benefited from some other extra hardware and OS tweaks though I think. - 800 KB disk format supported directly by the OS - blitter is not as useful as it could be, due to sharing bus time with the CPU. It should be able to use ACSI bandwidth if not in use/Shifter bandwidth during non-display periods, so it can run in parallel with the CPU - 256 px 5 bitplane mode (so still 40 words per line), probably an EHB kind of affair if 32 palette entries would be too much - something to improve endless scrolling? No carry out of bit 15 when computing Shifter address? You'd end up wrapping before the display period was finished if increasing the display stride, but you can work around that in software... - put the 9 pin joystick ports on the side - write signal for that stupid cartridge port that is almost (but not quite) useful for general purpose expansion
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- zabzonk 1y agoI had a 520ST back in the mid 80s. I would have killed for a Mega ST, but I couldn't afford one and realistically needed an IBM-compatible PC, which I eventually got. Things I remember about about the 520ST: - Those horrible diagonal function keys. There was no reason for them to be diagonal, rather than normal keys as they were on the IBM. But I've always hated function keys. - Games like Dungeon Master (really still quite a good game today). - Not a bad C compiler, but I can't remember who by - LightSomething? - The GEM GUI was not so bad, but using it with a floppy disk was. But all-in-all I was quite happy to get my PC-compatible to do serious work with.
- jjbinx007 1y agoThose function keys were bad but why have the joystick and mouse ports underneath in that location? Awful.
- zabzonk 1y agoYeah, I forgot about that. But I suppose you didn't need to replug them very often, and it wasn't much worse than plugging into an IBM PC before USB came along. And at least the Atari had lots of useful ports.
- cmrdporcupine 1y agoMouse cables and ports routinely broke on those machines because of the poor design. I guess the idea was to have a clean design with cables out of the way, but it really was a bad place for them.
- robinsonb5 1y agoIronically, speaking as an Amiga guy, those diagonal function keys were an aspect of the ST I really liked! I don't know if they were consistent with the other keys in terms of feel, but they were a striking, unique design feature that instantly identified the machine as being Atari without compromising practicality.
- doop 1y ago
- pjmlp 1y agoAtari vs Amiga was such an interesting time in computing history. When I see generations that grew up with game consoles, and talk about the current uptake on desktop games, they really have no idea what they missed out in home computing and the first wave of indie game development, from bedroom coders .
- vanderZwan 1y ago> they really have no idea what they missed out Tangent: the older I get, the more it annoys me that this expression kind of implies a failure of young people to study history, when I feel like it's more the responsibility of previous generations to preserve and pass down history for them to learn from. Especially because it's usually people in power in some form who are trying to keep the newer generations naive here so they can be fooled again. Not saying that this interpretation was your intent (in fact I suspect it's the opposite), just directly expressing my annoyance at the expression itself.
- kenjackson 1y agoI never thought that statement was actually about having an “idea”, but more about not actually having lived through the experience. Quite the opposite from your belief, no amount of study would allow them to understand what is was like.
- pjmlp 1y agoUnderstandable, hence why many of my comments kind of look like mini-history lessons, and I tend to be pedantic. However curiosity also plays a big role. If I know so much about computing history since the 1950's, is because I do my research, and take advantage of all archives that have been placed online, certainly I wasn't around to live all of it.
- flohofwoe 1y ago> when I feel like it's more the responsibility of previous generations to preserve and pass down history for them to learn from But everything has been preserved and passed down. The entire home computing phenomenon has been archived and is available on the internet thanks to the rampant 'software piracy' which was common at the time, and detailed schematics and manuals coming with the computers (which have all been digitized and are available on the internet). Even my obscure KC85 games I wrote as a teenager and 'distributed' on cassette tapes by snail mail are available as download because some kind person(s) digitized all that stuff during the early 90s and put it on some 'underground' game download portals. The 80s and early 90s home computer era will be better preserved than anything that came after it.
- cmrdporcupine 1y agoThe Mega ST (not the Mega STe) is the best quality machine of the series. Mechanical cherry keyswitches on the keyboard. Easy access in the case to expand (though the Mega STe/TT had standardized VMEbus and the Mega ST was its own custom thing). The Mega STe had a funkier case, VMEbus, and upgraded specs, but mushy rubber dome keyboard, more brittle plastics. I like to collect the Mega as the best of the bunch, personally.
- schlupa 1y agoThe expansion slot of Mega-ST is just 2 rows of 32 pins that are 1:1 connected to the CPU pins. Any extension that was supposed to be solderedon the CPU could be put in the slot with a simple adapter (see f.ex. the Volksfarben ISA slot adapter for ET4000 VGA cards).
- schlupa 1y agoThe Mega ST keyboard is indeed the best keyboard of the whole Atari family. My TT keyboard has its rubber dome getting stiff with age. This said, the Mega ST keyboard has one big flaw, its plastic is getting extremely brittle and fragile with age. I had one keyboard drop 1m (3ft) to the floor and it exploded like a glas vase. So if you have a Mega ST keyboard, be very careful to handle it gently.
- cmrdporcupine 1y agoThe Mega ST keyboard I have is German QWERTZ unfortunately, so despite having built a USB adapter for it, I never use it.
- Ozarkian 1y agoI owned one of those! I sold my 1040ST to my friend to get some of the money for a Mega 2. I liked how the keyboard was detachable and the hard drive was the same size at the motherboard case, so you could stack them.
- Aldipower 1y agoI own 4 Mega STe and I am using them almost daily. One of them, the rest is spare parts. Producing music with it. The Atari is my MIDI master clock and central piece of MIDI sequencing together with Cubase 3.1 for the Atari. Seriously the MIDI timing is unbeaten until today! The MIDI ports are directly attached to the CIA chip which is again directly connected to the Motorola 68k CPU. Runs absolutely stable even 35 years later. No crashes what so ever and also no distractions by updates or "phone home applications". It just works, distractless! Shame on the "present future".
- vanderZwan 1y ago> Seriously the MIDI timing is unbeaten until today! Is this in any way related to the general "speed is going up but latency is getting worse" phenomenon of hardware in the last decades?
- Aldipower 1y agoYes, I think this is a on point statement. :-)
- GuB-42 1y agoYes, back in the days, I/O was often really low latency because memory and therefore buffers were expensive and gate count was limited, it meant more direct connections, which meant low latency. The Atari 2600 for instance was known for "racing the beam", updating the image while it was being drawn on the CRT monitor. A latency measured in pixels rather than frames! It was necessary because the console didn't have enough memory for a framebuffer. The Atari ST is special for the inclusion built-in of MIDI ports, and it was made cheaply, which at the time meant direct connections and it resulted it low latency.
- zozbot234 1y agoYou can have low latency and low jitter today, but you will need to use a microcontroller not a general-purpose CPU. The old 16/32 bit retro machines are essentially microcontroller architecture devices with general-purpose computer peripherals, for pretty much the reasons you mention. But there are many cheap microcontrollers available today, such as the Raspberry Pico series.
- msephton 1y agoThe Atari ST was foundational for me. I loved it so much, learned a great deal, discovered and played many great video games, designed page layouts, made my own software and games. In December 2023 one of my recent games was listed in Ars Technica's "Best Games of 2023" alongside Super Mario Wonder and I can draw the line right the way back to my time on the Atari ST. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38372936 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38372936
- layer8 1y agoThe positioning of the cursor keys on the Atari STs is interesting [0]. It arguably makes sense for the cursor block to be located more in the vertical middle rather than at the bottom edge of the keyboard. [0] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/54/Atari_1040_STF_%2B_SM_124.JPG https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/54/Atari_10...
- j45 1y agoThe Atari’s still look like they’re a great first computer for kids.
- throw_m239339 1y agoI did prefer the Amiga, but I still got an Atari ST for an very obvious reason: It had MIDI DIN port and was way cheaper than most digital sequencers at the time. It's funny how some young producers today wonder "how did people do it without a computer before the 2000?"...well guess what, we did used computers! I cannot however remember what software sequencer I was using, I know it had MIDI effects (like MIDI echo), that's all I remember. And by 1998, Logic was fairly advanced anyway and even had plenty of plugins.
- Ylpertnodi 1y ago>I cannot however remember what software sequencer I was using, I know it had MIDI effects (like MIDI echo), Possibly/ probably Cubase. Anyone remember the Mike Hunt version? I'm still using cubase on a nice pc, but I miss the stability of the atari.
- bartread 1y agoI have to say, I love the industrial design of these 80s machines from Atari, and also from contemporary Commodore offerings. As an example, the original Amiga 1000 is beautiful, and I'd be incredibly happy to have a machine with that form factor, but equipped with modern internals, today. Honestly, I don't think even Apple could touch the best of Atari and Commodore industrial design in the back half of the 1980s. To be blunt, the early Macintoshs simply weren't practical in their design: for starters, a tiny monitor - that was originally black and white (which in 1984 was already kind of a joke) - and very limited upgradeability, relatively poor multimedia capabilities (speech synthesis was no more than a gimmick that was also available on other platforms), and then the whole aesthetic just wasn't that pleasant. And I say this as someone who, personally, has only owned Apple machines for the past 15ish years, so I'm not exactly coming at this from a "not a fanboi" perspective. I'd still take 1980s Atari or Commodore aesthetic over modern Apple, or modern anything else for that matter[0]. Also, as an aside, I really enjoyed seeing "Atari Means Business with the Mega ST" as the top headline on Hacker News in 2025. Even on a Sunday when content typically tends to be more varied and interesting this was still an entertaining surprise. [0] I suspect the reality may be that I'm an "anything but Wintel" kind of person, although not at any cost, because I did run PCs exclusively for 11 or 12 years. They never really helped me enjoy computing in the way the other machines have though.
- icedchai 1y agoI always felt the Amiga 3000 was Commodore's high point in terms of industrial design. Still, the keyboard garage in the 1000 was neat!
- II2II 1y agoThe industrial design of PCd may have been lacking in beauty, but it was almost always practical. For example: I cannot think of any desktop models that lacked internal expansion. They may have used a riser card to stack in two or three slots sideways, but the slots were there. The design may have been crude, but at least your desktop wasn't turned into a disaster every time the technological landscape shifted: when hard drives became affordable, the world switched to 3.5" floppies, if you decided to use online services or send faxes directly from your computer, get a CD-ROM, or cable Internet.
- b800h 1y agoEvery time I see anything about the varieties of ST, it gives me PTSD over the woeful keyboard. It was like a trampoline made of fudge. This says that the keyboard on the Mega ST was better. And yet still not good enough. Egads, that ST mess was a terrible keyboard.
- hashmash 1y agoThe main problem with the keyboard was the non-standard size of the kepcaps. The standard distance between keycaps is 0.75 inches, and the standard top width is 0.5 inches. The Atari ST keycap distance is standard, but the top width is 0.625 inches. Because of this, if your finger isn't exactly centered over the top of the key, it hits the adjacent key too, leading to key jam.
- whobre 1y agoWell, my first computer was a 48k ZX Spectrum, and after that experience Atari’s keyboard looked like heaven. Still liked the Speccy better…
- rjsw 1y agoThe Mega keyboard was good, comparable to a current mechanical one.
- cmrdporcupine 1y agoMega ST keyboard is Cherry MX switches. Good quality. I have an adapter on mine that converts it to USB and I can use it on a modern computer. Though I never do. Mainly because it's got Ctrl/Alt[Meta] but nothing I could map to Hyper/Super. Mega STe and TT reverted to terrible mushy rubberdome.
- jlokier 1y agoWow, there are a lot of C compilers for Atari ST! I was astonished to find about 22 distinct C compilers, including their own libraries, assemblers, linkers etc. for the Atari ST and its successors. That's not counting separate versions, just distinct products from different vendors. From what I can see now looking at archive sites, there was a huge amount of activity in developer tools on the ST back in the day. Much more than I thought at the time. It might have been a serious contender for the dominant architecture (along with the m68k CPU), if IBM PC-compatibles and x86 hadn't won. Recently I looked for Atari ST C compilers, out of curiosity to test portability of a C program I'm working on. I've been testing C code for diverse Unix systems. As I used to own an Atari 520ST (with 1MB RAM beautifully piggy-backed and hand-soldered on the existing RAM chips :-), it seemed like a good idea to peek at C on an ST emulator. I didn't use C when I had a real Atari ST (no C books in my local library), so I expected to find one or two C compilers, not 22!
- cmrdporcupine 1y agoThere were plenty of C compilers but only a couple were in common use. If I recall, Lattice C was popular. Mark Williams was another one. "Alcyon C" was included I think in the ST development kit, but was considered poor. I think people use "Pure C" these days, but of course also GCC is likely best: http://vincent.riviere.free.fr/soft/m68k-atari-mintelf/ http://vincent.riviere.free.fr/soft/m68k-atari-mintelf/ Is maintained by Vincent Rivière, who is a major contributor on EmuTOS.
- gramie 1y agoI think that I used the Megamax C compiler back in 1987-8. I was just messing around and experimenting, not programming professionally, but it worked well for me.
- chiph 1y agoI had that. Later renamed Laser C. Being a poor college student I used a Radio Shack floppy disk drive for a second 3.5", hand-soldering the DIN connector the ST used. Afterwards I could have my compiler tools on one and source/object code on the other - a huge time saver. Try and get a compiler and linker to fit in 360k these days!
- fdspopofe 1y ago[dead]
- sheepscreek 1y agoAtari “means” business..? I can’t get over the present tense in the heading. I double-checked if they had actually released something new. It feels like clickbait, and I wish it weren’t.
- predictsoft 1y agoI once played Ultima 6 from a RAM disk on an ST with 4MB RAM. Game install from 'Hard disk' to RAM disk - it didn't realise. And then I used bigger size floppy disks (940KB I think) and a fast copy utility to get those 3 disks to start the game and when done, save the game and save it all off to 3 floppies. It was totally fast!
- pavlov 1y ago”I don’t recall seeing Atari specifically market the Mega ST to developers, but I suspect a lot of developers found the better keyboard and extra RAM to be worth the upgrade.” There wasn’t such a thing as a general developer market. When you didn’t have internet and cloud services and free Unix, how could you develop for something else than a specific platform and device? If you bought a Mega ST to write programs, your target audience were still only the people who had a regular ST. You couldn’t reach anyone else. So the advantage was minimal. The idea that there can be a developer market separate from the baseline end-user platform is quite new. It emerged around 2007-2010 when web apps became a realistic option and you didn’t have to be on Windows to target the 90% of people who are on Windows.
- rocky1138 1y agoAs a counter point, Doom was developed on a different platform than the target. Let's say that the lead dev was ahead of the curve.
- bdcravens 1y agoTo say that John Carmack was ahead of the curve is quite an understatement lol
- schlupa 1y agoI bought a Mega ST2 because I studied CS and wanted to become a developper. I sold the Amiga 500 my father had bought me. The ST was cheaper for programming than the Amiga 500 as you would need to add, at least a second floppy and a lot of memory. Furthermore, I hated Workbench the GUI of the Amiga (for the same reason I hated also Windows 3.1, you had to use a special program to access the files on the drives, you had icons in the windows only if you had drawn specifically a special icon, I preferred how on GEM and the Mac Finder, windows would directly show what's on the disk).
- ggm 1y agoMy memory is that one of the Atari units was capable of being treated as a Jerq or Gnot, I recall people running core-wars on it. The keyboard looks familiar but I believe there as a packaging which had the CPU inside that unit, not just in a pizza box.
- djmips 1y ago(1987) ;-)
- Beijinger 1y agoBut does it run MidiMace?