3 ms·
My view, and how I conduct my peer reviews, is that I do not care to make decisions of whether a question is important/interesting or not. I feel like my job is
by SubiculumCode 1y ago
My view, and how I conduct my peer reviews, is that I do not care to make decisions of whether a question is important/interesting or not. I feel like my job is to judge the paper on rigor, and whether it fails (purposely or from ignorance) to address/acknowledge the relevant literature.
- rjakob 1y agoWe also provide feedback on rigor across 7 different categories: https://github.com/robertjakob/rigorous/tree/main/Agent1_Peer_Review https://github.com/robertjakob/rigorous/tree/main/Agent1_Pee...