4 ms·
It's pretty common to subsidize employee equity because employees having equity are incented to work, and because common generally is discounted to preferred by
by rdl 14y ago
It's pretty common to subsidize employee equity because employees having equity are incented to work, and because common generally is discounted to preferred by a larger factor very early in the formation of the company. It's reasonable to simultaneously treat employee equity as $2mm valuation and investor equity at $5mm valuation, especially with a note.
In this case, though, I think the way to win the negotiation is to walk. A competent engineer is more like $150-200k total comp in the bay area, and doing that as $100k + 100k of equity/yr in a real company is pretty plausible.
A more plausible story is offering $50-100k and then equity levels which ramp up rapidly as you go down to $50k. Someone taking $50k vs. $60k should get more than $10k x 4 of extra equity. Maybe something like 100/0.10 90/0.15 80/0.25 70/0.40 60/0.6 50/1. Then, if you need to prioritize candidates, absent other factors, the 50/1 people have a plus mark.
- tptacek 14y agoI'll admit: my issue here comes down to hating sliding equity/salary scales like this one. The rough amount of skin you want a team member to have in the game should be a part of the role definition, not a detail of the comp plan. There have to be better ways to account for sub-market salary than a salary/equity scale multiple percentage points long. Ick.
- rdl 14y agoI'd probably have a range for the req (based on budget), and make an offer with two points (specific to the employee). The market is weird enough now that if you wanted to hire an SSL protocol expert, you might end up hiring someone with 2-3 years of general security and dev experience who has read the book, or someone who is EAY, and even the first option might be better than no one in many roles. I've heard Palantir does three offers, and taking the top cash one is a bad signal. Also, I think employees undervalue equity, and there's a weird signaling/etc. effect where shitty companies give out equity freely, good companies don't. Cash is cash, though.
- tptacek 14y agoI strongly agree with the last part of your comment; I think that nails my uneasiness about this particular offer.
- dkador 14y agoYou think that if a company offers a sizable equity percentage as part of their comp it signals something negative about that company?
- rdl 14y agoYes, if the founders of a company, who have the best visibility into the company, don't value their equity, it's a waving red flag on fire. Either they are idiots (inexperienced at best, incompetent more likely), or company = doomed. Obviously offering tptacek 5% in a company isn't bad, but offering an office admin 5% is.
- tptacek 14y agoThis person isn't an office admin. I don't know where that notion is coming from (elsewhere on the thread, I assume), but it's a little disturbing.
- bmm6o 14y agoI didn't read the comment as referring to the author as an admin, it was just offering a lowly position stand-in in the current hypothetical.
- rdl 14y agoYeah, that was that I intended -- a general example. Given her previous salary of $116k+, she was obviously in some kind of professional/technical IC or low level manager role before.
- dkador 14y ago
- ricardobeat 14y agoHigher equity is always the most rewarding option in the best possible outcome. But it's hard to leave safe money on the table. Four years from now the company could be worth way more than the current $5mm, then those $20k/year would look like scraps. I agree with tptacek; 100/0.1 and 50/1 suit very different persons, the company should decide which type it's going after and limit that range.
- robryan 14y agoAt 50/1 for a company just out of of an accelerator you would have to think that you would be better off jut starting your own company.
- rdl 14y agoAlso depends on which company, and who you are. There are companies that go into accelerators after raising money, with great traction, etc. If you're just out of school or bigco and NOT a potential founder right now, doing 50/1 for 2 years to build great experience might be worthwhile, although pushing for higher cash comp once the company raises >$1mm or so might be reasonable. From what I've seen of YC W12 and S12 companies, there are >10 where I would have done $50-70k + 1% to work there for 2-4y, back when I was 25, and absolutely after leaving school.
- dchichkov 14y agoI think that 50k/1% should be considered only as a 'hobby occupation'. Or, if one is trying to change a field of work. Because this early employee 1% is a) going to get diluted; b) it is over 4 years; c) most likely will result in $0 - $5000 cash-wise. And 50k (without benefits I assume) is.. well nothing.
- rdl 14y agoIf you're already well-off enough to not need income, or have a rich doctor as a spouse, it's quite reasonable to trade salary for equity. Also, I'd love to take $50k/yr + 1% equity in an already successful startup. Say, Facebook.
- sofuture 14y agoYeah, and I'd take $20k/yr + a winning Powerball ticket.
- potatolicious 14y ago> "If you're already well-off enough to not need income, or have a rich doctor as a spouse, it's quite reasonable to trade salary for equity." It is never reasonable to trade your skills at substantially below-market compensation - regardless of if you can afford to do so. I have a lot of savings, but that doesn't make it reasonable for me to start lighting cigars with $20 bills. Equity is a form of compensation, in this case dchichkov worked it out to be a expected value of $5K (or thereabouts) - how does one justify taking a haircut substantially more than this? (in this case, the haircut is on the order of $50-100K depending on the person).
- colmvp 14y agoUnless lighting cigars with $20 bills could give you more money, I don't see that as an applicable analogy. If anything, it's a version of gambling. Taking a significant paycut can be worth it if the options offered proportionately compensated the salary disparity IF the startup exits AND at a number that you estimate it could potentially hit. If one isn't willing to take that risk then they should opt for less equity/no equity but a fairer market value.