3 ms·
Modular systems have costs, both in terms of money as well as size and weight. Right. It's absolutely necessary for Apple to make the new iPad so that you can'
by Silhouette 14y ago
Modular systems have costs, both in terms of money as well as size and weight.
Right. It's absolutely necessary for Apple to make the new iPad so that you can't even take it to an Apple Store and get the storage upgraded, and to literally glue the Retina version of the MacBook Pro together so it's almost completely impossible to repair anything if it breaks.
Some integration has a genuine benefit, such as minimising size or weight. But plenty more integration is just artificial, and this trend is increasing. Some of the clients I work with design high-end IT hardware for a living, so I can say with some confidence that if you think the equivalent people at places like Apple couldn't design modern devices in more modular ways than they are, you're just kidding yourself.
Likewise, it's easy to buy non-stupid printers right now, today. But few people want to pay what they cost.
Why can't the colour laser printer I already paid for just work? Printing a black-and-white document with nothing but black toner is not rocket science. Stop apologising for people who deliberately screw their customers.
If you want people to fight the trend, start with yourself. [...] Start by not buying crappy and restrictive printers just because they're cheap.
That printer probably cost the equivalent of $1,500 when I bought it, and was marketed for use in a small office. I'm not talking about cheap consumer junk, not that it would make the slightest difference to my argument if I were.
- mikeash 14y agoNeither of Apple's non-modular systems you mention are artificial. Upgradeable storage would require substantial additional room in a device that has no room. The Retina MBP's screen is glued together because it makes for a substantial thickness and weight savings. I'm not saying you can't complain about junk. I'm saying that it's really odd to complain about how it's some conspiracy of manufacturers when it's actually just people preferring the non-modular systems for many reasons, and then giving an example where you yourself went for junk instead of something that's supposedly like what you want.
- theorique 14y agoNeither of Apple's non-modular systems you mention are artificial. Upgradeable storage would require substantial additional room in a device that has no room. The Retina MBP's screen is glued together because it makes for a substantial thickness and weight savings. Agreed. This is not some evil conspiracy of hardware integrators (led by AAPL) to make non-modular devices. This is a design tradeoff in a leading edge machine [1] in which upgradeability was deemed to be less of a concern than making maximum use of space and weight. [1] You can't get a Retina MBP for less than $2200, making it a premium product for the laptop category.
- Silhouette 14y agoNeither of Apple's non-modular systems you mention are artificial. Nonsense. Go look at the iFixit write-ups of taking apart recent Apple devices, which helpfully show exactly how similar/different the variations are in many respects, highlight all kinds of proprietary components literally down to the level of unusual screws that have no apparent benefit whatsoever over using a standard/compatible component, and incidentally debunk your claim about "substantial thickness and weight savings" in the process. it's actually just people preferring the non-modular systems for many reasons I'm still waiting for anyone to cite any of those reasons. Other things being equal, why would someone prefer to buy a system that was going to cost a vast amount more to repair in the event of screen damage, or where proprietary connectors meant they couldn't swap out the SSD for a higher capacity unit even though the device itself is actually removable? And as noted above, for the most part other things are in fact equal, or so close as makes no difference. then giving an example where you yourself went for junk instead of something that's supposedly like what you want I'm still waiting for anyone to tell me what I should have bought instead. As I said, the printer I was talking about there was very much not an entry-level device, it was pitched as part of a range for professional use in an office, and with a price tag to match. Asking for such a printer to print a black-and-white document with only black toner is not some sort of absurd concession or flippant request. There would be no excuse for nerfing a $150 printer in that way, never mind a $1,500 one. Also, it's not as if I somehow found the only printer or the only printer manufacturer around who has this problem. Again, as I already said, almost everyone seems to work this way these days. If you insist on maintaining that after extensive research I still wound up buying "junk" unnecessarily, you can easily win this debate. All you have to do is cite an alternative device I could have bought, with a reasonably similar spec and for a similar budget, that does not have such artificial limitations. But you can't, and instead of accepting that, you persist in implying that it's somehow my fault that a world class brand deliberately nerfed a device that costs $1,000+ in order to increase their revenue on consumables.
- bronson 14y agoA direct quote from iFixit: http://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/MacBook-Pro-Retina-Display-Teardown/9493/2 http://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/MacBook-Pro-Retina-Display-Te... "Apple did not design and build a 1.5 mm thin LCD panel. They did, however, do something exceptional with the design of this display: rather than sandwich an LCD panel between a back case and a front glass, they used the aluminum case itself as the frame for the LCD panel and used the LCD as the front glass." Remember your whole theory about iFixit debunking substantial weight savings? Turns out iFixit agrees with the OP and not with you.